Dragana Trifkovic | August 8, 2026

The International Council for
the Defense of the Orthodox Canonical Order of the Center for Geostrategic
Studies, in cooperation with the Italian publishing house Theosis
Editrice and the Greek Orthodox weekly Orthodoxos Typos, organized
the international conference “Orthodoxy and Contemporary Ecumenical
Processes: Theological, Canonical and Geopolitical Aspects” on August 20,
2026. The conference brought together theologians, scholars, legal experts,
journalists, and geopolitical analysts from several countries.
The aim of the conference was to
examine, through an academic and expert approach, contemporary ecumenical
processes and the challenges facing the Orthodox Church, particularly in the
context of the increasingly pronounced intersection of theological and
canonical issues with political and geopolitical interests. Particular
attention was devoted to preserving Orthodox unity and canonical order, as well
as to the consequences of the political instrumentalization of ecclesiastical
issues in contemporary international relations.
The first speaker to address the
participants was Georgios Tramboulis from Greece, a theologian,
journalist, and editor-in-chief of the weekly Orthodoxos Typos. In his
presentation, “The Phanar Between Primacy, Vanity and Orthodox Unity,” Tramboulis
examined the contemporary role of the Phanar and the relationship between the
question of primacy and the preservation of the unity of the Orthodox Church.
He emphasized that the unity of the Church does not arise from subordination to
a single ecclesiastical center, but from communion in the Holy Spirit, the true
faith, and conciliarity, and that Orthodox bishops are therefore equal to one
another.
Tramboulis argued that in recent
years the Phanar has been developing a new ecclesiological concept according to
which the Patriarch of Constantinople is no longer merely “first among
equals,” but “first without equals” (primus sine paribus),
thereby attributing to him powers that have no foundation in the Orthodox
canonical tradition. As examples, he cited the Phanar’s claims to the
unilateral granting of autocephaly and to the right to adjudicate appeals by
clergy belonging to other Local Churches.
He specifically challenged
interpretations of the 34th Apostolic Canon and the 28th Canon of the Fourth
Ecumenical Council which, according to him, are used to justify broader
jurisdictional rights for Constantinople. According to Tramboulis,
Constantinople’s historical primacy constitutes a primacy of honor, not a
primacy of jurisdiction, while attempts to transform it into authority over
other Local Churches represent a departure from the centuries-old conciliar
structure of the Orthodox Church.
“The more centralized the
European Union becomes, the more the Phanar is transformed into a Vatican, and
its head into a Pope of the East,” was one of the central assessments of
his presentation. Tramboulis warned that such claims, rather than contributing
to Orthodox unity, produce the opposite result — rivalries, disputes, and
schisms — citing the Russian-Ukrainian ecclesiastical question as one of the
most obvious examples.
Speaking about the contemporary
geopolitical position of the Phanar, Tramboulis argued that during the 20th
century it became increasingly linked, both politically and spiritually, to the
West and to American diplomacy, while ecumenism became one of the principal
directions of its activity. In conclusion, he emphasized that the faithful
themselves are the guardians of the faith and bear the responsibility to
defend the unchanged Orthodox Tradition and to bear public witness to their
faith whenever the canonical order is threatened.
Alexander Azadgan from the
United States, an expert in geopolitics and international political economy
and Chief Geopolitical Advisor to the Center for Geostrategic Studies, spoke on
the topic “Orthodoxy in America.” He reviewed the historical development
of Orthodoxy in the United States, from the arrival of Russian missionaries in
Alaska at the end of the 18th century to the major waves of Orthodox immigrants
from Europe and Western Asia, which led to the establishment of numerous ethnic
and ecclesiastical jurisdictions. He identified jurisdictional fragmentation
as one of the principal problems facing contemporary Orthodoxy in America, as
it continues to constitute an obstacle to ecclesiastical unity and coordinated
action among Orthodox communities.
Azadgan also pointed to the
growing need to find a balance between preserving Orthodox tradition and
functioning within the specific social and cultural environment of the United
States. He noted that Orthodoxy in the U.S. today is growing not only through
immigration but also through the conversion of Americans to the Orthodox faith,
attracted by its liturgical tradition, continuity with early Christianity, and
theological depth.
He particularly emphasized the
challenge of preserving Orthodox spiritual, theological, and moral identity
amid assimilation, secularization, and contemporary ideological changes in
American society. In his assessment, although Orthodoxy remains relatively
small in numerical terms in the United States, its cultural, historical, and
spiritual significance far exceeds its numerical presence. Its future, he
argued, will depend on its ability to preserve its ancient heritage while
simultaneously responding to the challenges of the 21st century.
Dragana Trifković, General
Director of the Center for Geostrategic Studies from Serbia, spoke on the
topic “Between the Primacy of Honor and the Primacy of Power: The Role of
the Phanar in Contemporary Divisions within the Orthodox World.” She argued
that the attempt to transform the traditional primacy of honor of the Patriarch
of Constantinople into a primacy of power and broader jurisdictional authority
represents one of the key causes of contemporary divisions within the Orthodox
world. She emphasized that Orthodox ecclesiology does not recognize the
universal jurisdiction of a single bishop modeled on the papal system, but is
instead founded upon conciliarity and the equality of the Local Orthodox
Churches.
According to Trifković, the
activities of the Phanar in recent decades have increasingly moved beyond the
sphere of theological and canonical questions and become an instrument of
geopolitical interests. She cited Ukraine as the most striking example, arguing
that the intervention of the Patriarchate of Constantinople and the granting of
the Tomos in 2018 deepened the schism and created conditions for the
persecution of clergy and faithful of the canonical Ukrainian Orthodox Church.
“What the Phanar lacks in
canonical and ecclesiological legitimacy is compensated for by geopolitical
support from external centers of power,” Trifković stated, stressing that
the defense of canonical order is not merely a matter of preserving tradition,
but a defense of the very nature of the Orthodox Church as a communion of
equal Local Churches united by faith and conciliarity, rather than a hierarchy
subject to external political interests.
Georgios Karalis from Greece,
an expert in Greek patristics and a student of the distinguished Orthodox
theologian John Romanides, presented the topic “From the Historical Context
of Ecumenism to the Theological Distortion of Ecclesiology.” He argued that
ecumenism has not remained confined to organizations, conferences, and
inter-church dialogue but, in his assessment, has gradually led to the creation
of “a new theology, a new ecclesiology, and a new understanding of unity,
personhood, communion, and primacy.” In this process, he emphasized, the
traditional Orthodox understanding of the very nature of the Church is also
being transformed.
Karalis was particularly critical
of the contemporary “Eucharistic ecclesiology of primacy,” according to
which ecclesial unity is increasingly interpreted through the existence of a
single visible “first” at every level of Church organization — the bishop at
the local level, the metropolitan at the regional level, and the Patriarch of
Constantinople at the universal level, with the Pope of Rome ultimately
envisioned as the bearer of universal primacy in the context of prospective
union with Rome.
According to Karalis, the problem
with such an approach is not merely a matter of the administrative organization
of the Church, but involves a profound transformation of Orthodox
ecclesiology. If the unity of the Church is made dependent upon the
existence of a single earthly bearer of universal unity, he argued, the
Orthodox conciliar structure gradually moves toward a model of centralized
primacy that is alien to the patristic tradition. In this way, the question of
primacy ceases to be a matter of honor and ecclesiastical order and instead
assumes the character of authority and universal jurisdiction.
He particularly warned that such
an ecclesiology could lead to a situation in which dogmatic differences
become secondary to the establishment of ecclesial communion. If unity is
understood primarily as communion centered around a single “first,” this opens
the possibility of seeking full ecclesial unity even before genuine unity in
faith has been achieved. Karalis sees precisely this as one of the most serious
theological consequences of contemporary ecumenism.
“The Church is one not because
it has an earthly bearer of universal unity, but because it is the Body of the
one Christ, lives by the one Spirit, and confesses the one faith,” Karalis
emphasized. According to him, the true unity of the Church is created neither
by a single “first” bishop nor by an administrative center, but by Christ,
the true faith, and the Eucharistic life, which cannot be separated from the
Orthodox confession of faith. Therefore, he concluded, the question of
ecclesial unity cannot be resolved through organizational models and
compromises that precede unity in truth.
Olimpia Fronzoni from Italy,
publisher and editor-in-chief of Theosis Editrice, spoke on the topic “Contamination
by Ecumenism: The Latin Concept of ‘Free Will’ in Orthodox Theology.” She
warned of the danger that, in an effort to make Orthodox theology more
comprehensible to the West and within the framework of ecumenical dialogue,
Western theological categories may be uncritically introduced into Orthodox
theology. According to Fronzoni, this may result in the teachings of the Holy
Fathers no longer being interpreted within their own tradition, but instead
through a Western conceptual framework foreign to it.
She devoted particular attention
to the teaching of St. Maximus the Confessor and to the Western
interpretation of the term proeresis as “free will.” Fronzoni emphasized
that such an interpretation obscures the crucial patristic distinction between
the natural human will and the manner in which a person exercises that will.
According to St. Maximus, she stressed, will, freedom, and the capacity for
action belong to human nature, while what is proper to the person is the mode
in which this natural capacity is exercised.
She warned that such changes in
theology are not merely a matter of terminology, but have direct consequences
for spiritual and ascetic life. If wavering and choosing between opposites
come to be understood as the highest expression of human freedom, rather than
as consequences of humanity’s fallen condition, then the Orthodox understanding
of the human path toward God itself is altered, Fronzoni concluded.
Arnaud Develay from France,
an expert in international humanitarian law, presented the topic “The
Principle of Non-Interference and Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction: Can
International Law Provide a Useful Analytical Framework?” He pointed to
significant parallels between the principles of international and canon law,
particularly with regard to sovereignty and autocephaly, territorial integrity
and canonical territory, as well as the principle of non-interference.
According to his analysis, just as states are legally equal and exercise
authority within their own borders, autocephalous Churches are self-governing
and canonically equal.
Develay devoted particular
attention to the Ukrainian ecclesiastical question, analyzing it through
the principle of non-interference. He presented the Moscow Patriarchate’s
argument that Constantinople’s intervention within its canonical territory and
the granting of autocephaly constituted interference in an internal ecclesiastical
dispute, comparing such a situation to external support for a secessionist
movement in international relations. In this context, he also examined the
dispute over the interpretation of Constantinople’s claimed right to intervene
within the jurisdiction of another Local Church.
Develay also drew particular
attention to the legal proceedings currently underway in Turkey against the
Phanar, concerning the powers claimed by the Patriarchate of Constantinople
and the concept of a “primacy of power” as opposed to the traditional
“primacy of honor.” He noted that, in this context, questions are also
being raised regarding the compatibility of such claims with the 1923 Treaty
of Lausanne and the constitutional order of the Republic of Turkey,
describing it as an important case whose outcome should be closely monitored.
Konrad Rękas from Poland,
a geopolitical analyst and journalist, spoke on the topic “Uniatism,
Ecumenism, Hostile Takeover: Western Strategies against Orthodoxy in Historical
Context.” He placed contemporary pressures on Orthodoxy within a broader
historical context, arguing that although the methods have changed over the
centuries — from direct force and Uniatism to ecumenism and the creation of
non-canonical ecclesiastical structures — the objective has remained the
weakening of Orthodox identity and the displacement of Orthodoxy from its
canonical territories.
Rękas particularly highlighted
the historical role of Uniatism, from the Union of Florence in 1439 and
the Union of Brest in 1596 to contemporary developments in Ukraine. In
his assessment, following the failure of attempts to subordinate Orthodoxy
through direct pressure, ecumenism became a new and more subtle instrument of
influence over the Orthodox world.
“Ecumenism was intended to
infect Orthodoxy with the viruses that have been afflicting the Roman Catholic
Church for decades,” Rękas stated, arguing that a Church that renounces the
uniqueness of truth gradually loses its own religious identity as well. He
described contemporary non-canonical ecclesiastical structures as “hybrids
of Uniatism and ecumenism, disguised as Orthodoxy,” citing Ukraine and the
Baltic states as examples of a broader process that he views as an attempted
“hostile takeover” of Orthodoxy.
In conclusion, he emphasized that
the response to such processes must be the preservation of the Orthodox faith
and canonical order, as well as cooperation with traditional Christian circles
in the West that oppose secularization and the radical transformation of the
Christian heritage, without compromise on matters of faith.
Nicolò Ghigi from Italy, a
PhD candidate in Ancient Studies at Ca’ Foscari University of Venice,
specializing in Byzantine philology and who also pursued theological studies at
the Moscow Theological Academy, presented the topic “The Subordination of
the Church to Political Expediency as a Motive of Ecumenism.” He pointed to
the historical connection between ecumenical processes and political interests,
distinguishing between historical, Protestant, and Roman Catholic ecumenism. In
his assessment, contemporary ecumenism cannot be viewed exclusively as a
theological phenomenon, since in different historical periods it has been
closely connected with the interests of political centers of power.
As examples of the political
instrumentalization of ecclesiastical issues, he cited relations between Church
and state in the Soviet Union, the activities of the Patriarchate of
Constantinople under Western political influence, as well as earlier attempts
at union with Rome. According to Ghigi, the common denominator of these
processes was the placing of political success and secular interests above
the purity of faith, and the acceptance of dogmatic compromises in pursuit of
political objectives.
Referring to the example of St.
Mark of Ephesus, Ghigi emphasized that even political advantage cannot
justify ecclesial unity based on compromise in matters of faith. Union, if
it is to exist, must be founded on truth, not on compromise and falsehood,
he stated, stressing as a fundamental principle that political interests must
never be placed above the Orthodox faith.
The final speaker, Dmitry
Belyakov from Belarus, President of the Center for Systemic Human Rights
Protection, spoke on the topic “The Role of Great Britain in the Religious
Question in Ukraine and Eastern Europe.” Belyakov analyzed religious
developments in Ukraine and the broader Eastern European region in the context
of international political interests and geopolitical competition, arguing that
the religious question has become an important instrument of foreign policy.
He identified five levels of
British involvement in the religious question in Ukraine — institutional,
diplomatic, parliamentary, informational, and military. As examples, he cited
regular contacts between British officials and the leadership of the Orthodox
Church of Ukraine, activities in the British Parliament and on expert platforms
such as Chatham House, as well as the involvement of British military
chaplains in the training of approximately 200 Ukrainian military chaplains.
Belyakov particularly drew
attention to what he described as a one-sided approach in British policy,
which supports the Ukrainian authorities and the new ecclesiastical structure
while, at the same time, disregarding the persecution of the canonical
Ukrainian Orthodox Church, the seizure of churches, and restrictions on the
religious rights of its faithful. In his assessment, such an approach calls
into question Britain’s declared commitment to religious freedom and points to
the use of ecclesiastical divisions as an instrument of geopolitical pressure.
He also addressed claims made by
the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service concerning British support for
activities of the Patriarchate of Constantinople aimed at weakening the
influence of the Russian Orthodox Church in Ukraine, the Baltic states, and other
parts of Eastern Europe. Belyakov emphasized that such claims require
critical assessment and further verification, but warned that the spread of
the Ukrainian model of ecclesiastical divisions to other countries could pose a
serious risk to the canonical unity of Orthodoxy.
Following the presentations, a
discussion was held with the participation of the speakers and conference
guests. One of the central questions raised was how to preserve Orthodox
unity and canonical order in circumstances in which ecclesiastical disputes are
becoming increasingly intertwined with geopolitical conflicts.
In the concluding part of the
conference, it was emphasized that the challenges facing the Orthodox world
today cannot be understood from a single perspective alone. Theological
questions are inseparable from ecclesiology and canonical order, while contemporary
canonical disputes are increasingly intertwined with political and geopolitical
processes. Geopolitical interests, in turn, can have far-reaching consequences
for inter-church relations and Orthodox unity.
Particular emphasis was placed on
the fact that preserving Orthodox unity requires respect for canonical
order, conciliarity, and the legitimate autonomy of the Local Orthodox Churches,
as well as the ability to distinguish the authentic needs of the Church from
political interests seeking to instrumentalize religious issues for
geopolitical purposes.
The International Council for the
Defense of the Orthodox Canonical Order of the Center for Geostrategic Studies,
together with its partners Theosis Editrice and Orthodoxos Typos,
announced the continuation of international dialogue and cooperation among
theologians, scholars, legal experts, journalists, and other specialists
engaged with questions concerning the position and future of Orthodoxy.
Report: Center for Geostrategic Studies
August 2026
Source: https://eurasianmediaforum.com/how-the-foundations-of-orthodoxy-are-being-undermined/




