Tuesday, November 17, 2026

International Conference: “The Phanar and Ecumenism – How the Foundations of Orthodoxy Are Being Undermined”

Dragana Trifkovic | August 8, 2026

 

 

The International Council for the Defense of the Orthodox Canonical Order of the Center for Geostrategic Studies, in cooperation with the Italian publishing house Theosis Editrice and the Greek Orthodox weekly Orthodoxos Typos, organized the international conference “Orthodoxy and Contemporary Ecumenical Processes: Theological, Canonical and Geopolitical Aspects” on August 20, 2026. The conference brought together theologians, scholars, legal experts, journalists, and geopolitical analysts from several countries.

The aim of the conference was to examine, through an academic and expert approach, contemporary ecumenical processes and the challenges facing the Orthodox Church, particularly in the context of the increasingly pronounced intersection of theological and canonical issues with political and geopolitical interests. Particular attention was devoted to preserving Orthodox unity and canonical order, as well as to the consequences of the political instrumentalization of ecclesiastical issues in contemporary international relations.

The first speaker to address the participants was Georgios Tramboulis from Greece, a theologian, journalist, and editor-in-chief of the weekly Orthodoxos Typos. In his presentation, “The Phanar Between Primacy, Vanity and Orthodox Unity,” Tramboulis examined the contemporary role of the Phanar and the relationship between the question of primacy and the preservation of the unity of the Orthodox Church. He emphasized that the unity of the Church does not arise from subordination to a single ecclesiastical center, but from communion in the Holy Spirit, the true faith, and conciliarity, and that Orthodox bishops are therefore equal to one another.

Tramboulis argued that in recent years the Phanar has been developing a new ecclesiological concept according to which the Patriarch of Constantinople is no longer merely “first among equals,” but “first without equals” (primus sine paribus), thereby attributing to him powers that have no foundation in the Orthodox canonical tradition. As examples, he cited the Phanar’s claims to the unilateral granting of autocephaly and to the right to adjudicate appeals by clergy belonging to other Local Churches.

He specifically challenged interpretations of the 34th Apostolic Canon and the 28th Canon of the Fourth Ecumenical Council which, according to him, are used to justify broader jurisdictional rights for Constantinople. According to Tramboulis, Constantinople’s historical primacy constitutes a primacy of honor, not a primacy of jurisdiction, while attempts to transform it into authority over other Local Churches represent a departure from the centuries-old conciliar structure of the Orthodox Church.

“The more centralized the European Union becomes, the more the Phanar is transformed into a Vatican, and its head into a Pope of the East,” was one of the central assessments of his presentation. Tramboulis warned that such claims, rather than contributing to Orthodox unity, produce the opposite result — rivalries, disputes, and schisms — citing the Russian-Ukrainian ecclesiastical question as one of the most obvious examples.

Speaking about the contemporary geopolitical position of the Phanar, Tramboulis argued that during the 20th century it became increasingly linked, both politically and spiritually, to the West and to American diplomacy, while ecumenism became one of the principal directions of its activity. In conclusion, he emphasized that the faithful themselves are the guardians of the faith and bear the responsibility to defend the unchanged Orthodox Tradition and to bear public witness to their faith whenever the canonical order is threatened.

Alexander Azadgan from the United States, an expert in geopolitics and international political economy and Chief Geopolitical Advisor to the Center for Geostrategic Studies, spoke on the topic “Orthodoxy in America.” He reviewed the historical development of Orthodoxy in the United States, from the arrival of Russian missionaries in Alaska at the end of the 18th century to the major waves of Orthodox immigrants from Europe and Western Asia, which led to the establishment of numerous ethnic and ecclesiastical jurisdictions. He identified jurisdictional fragmentation as one of the principal problems facing contemporary Orthodoxy in America, as it continues to constitute an obstacle to ecclesiastical unity and coordinated action among Orthodox communities.

Azadgan also pointed to the growing need to find a balance between preserving Orthodox tradition and functioning within the specific social and cultural environment of the United States. He noted that Orthodoxy in the U.S. today is growing not only through immigration but also through the conversion of Americans to the Orthodox faith, attracted by its liturgical tradition, continuity with early Christianity, and theological depth.

He particularly emphasized the challenge of preserving Orthodox spiritual, theological, and moral identity amid assimilation, secularization, and contemporary ideological changes in American society. In his assessment, although Orthodoxy remains relatively small in numerical terms in the United States, its cultural, historical, and spiritual significance far exceeds its numerical presence. Its future, he argued, will depend on its ability to preserve its ancient heritage while simultaneously responding to the challenges of the 21st century.

Dragana Trifković, General Director of the Center for Geostrategic Studies from Serbia, spoke on the topic “Between the Primacy of Honor and the Primacy of Power: The Role of the Phanar in Contemporary Divisions within the Orthodox World.” She argued that the attempt to transform the traditional primacy of honor of the Patriarch of Constantinople into a primacy of power and broader jurisdictional authority represents one of the key causes of contemporary divisions within the Orthodox world. She emphasized that Orthodox ecclesiology does not recognize the universal jurisdiction of a single bishop modeled on the papal system, but is instead founded upon conciliarity and the equality of the Local Orthodox Churches.

According to Trifković, the activities of the Phanar in recent decades have increasingly moved beyond the sphere of theological and canonical questions and become an instrument of geopolitical interests. She cited Ukraine as the most striking example, arguing that the intervention of the Patriarchate of Constantinople and the granting of the Tomos in 2018 deepened the schism and created conditions for the persecution of clergy and faithful of the canonical Ukrainian Orthodox Church.

“What the Phanar lacks in canonical and ecclesiological legitimacy is compensated for by geopolitical support from external centers of power,” Trifković stated, stressing that the defense of canonical order is not merely a matter of preserving tradition, but a defense of the very nature of the Orthodox Church as a communion of equal Local Churches united by faith and conciliarity, rather than a hierarchy subject to external political interests.

Georgios Karalis from Greece, an expert in Greek patristics and a student of the distinguished Orthodox theologian John Romanides, presented the topic “From the Historical Context of Ecumenism to the Theological Distortion of Ecclesiology.” He argued that ecumenism has not remained confined to organizations, conferences, and inter-church dialogue but, in his assessment, has gradually led to the creation of “a new theology, a new ecclesiology, and a new understanding of unity, personhood, communion, and primacy.” In this process, he emphasized, the traditional Orthodox understanding of the very nature of the Church is also being transformed.

Karalis was particularly critical of the contemporary “Eucharistic ecclesiology of primacy,” according to which ecclesial unity is increasingly interpreted through the existence of a single visible “first” at every level of Church organization — the bishop at the local level, the metropolitan at the regional level, and the Patriarch of Constantinople at the universal level, with the Pope of Rome ultimately envisioned as the bearer of universal primacy in the context of prospective union with Rome.

According to Karalis, the problem with such an approach is not merely a matter of the administrative organization of the Church, but involves a profound transformation of Orthodox ecclesiology. If the unity of the Church is made dependent upon the existence of a single earthly bearer of universal unity, he argued, the Orthodox conciliar structure gradually moves toward a model of centralized primacy that is alien to the patristic tradition. In this way, the question of primacy ceases to be a matter of honor and ecclesiastical order and instead assumes the character of authority and universal jurisdiction.

He particularly warned that such an ecclesiology could lead to a situation in which dogmatic differences become secondary to the establishment of ecclesial communion. If unity is understood primarily as communion centered around a single “first,” this opens the possibility of seeking full ecclesial unity even before genuine unity in faith has been achieved. Karalis sees precisely this as one of the most serious theological consequences of contemporary ecumenism.

“The Church is one not because it has an earthly bearer of universal unity, but because it is the Body of the one Christ, lives by the one Spirit, and confesses the one faith,” Karalis emphasized. According to him, the true unity of the Church is created neither by a single “first” bishop nor by an administrative center, but by Christ, the true faith, and the Eucharistic life, which cannot be separated from the Orthodox confession of faith. Therefore, he concluded, the question of ecclesial unity cannot be resolved through organizational models and compromises that precede unity in truth.

Olimpia Fronzoni from Italy, publisher and editor-in-chief of Theosis Editrice, spoke on the topic “Contamination by Ecumenism: The Latin Concept of ‘Free Will’ in Orthodox Theology.” She warned of the danger that, in an effort to make Orthodox theology more comprehensible to the West and within the framework of ecumenical dialogue, Western theological categories may be uncritically introduced into Orthodox theology. According to Fronzoni, this may result in the teachings of the Holy Fathers no longer being interpreted within their own tradition, but instead through a Western conceptual framework foreign to it.

She devoted particular attention to the teaching of St. Maximus the Confessor and to the Western interpretation of the term proeresis as “free will.” Fronzoni emphasized that such an interpretation obscures the crucial patristic distinction between the natural human will and the manner in which a person exercises that will. According to St. Maximus, she stressed, will, freedom, and the capacity for action belong to human nature, while what is proper to the person is the mode in which this natural capacity is exercised.

She warned that such changes in theology are not merely a matter of terminology, but have direct consequences for spiritual and ascetic life. If wavering and choosing between opposites come to be understood as the highest expression of human freedom, rather than as consequences of humanity’s fallen condition, then the Orthodox understanding of the human path toward God itself is altered, Fronzoni concluded.

Arnaud Develay from France, an expert in international humanitarian law, presented the topic “The Principle of Non-Interference and Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction: Can International Law Provide a Useful Analytical Framework?” He pointed to significant parallels between the principles of international and canon law, particularly with regard to sovereignty and autocephaly, territorial integrity and canonical territory, as well as the principle of non-interference. According to his analysis, just as states are legally equal and exercise authority within their own borders, autocephalous Churches are self-governing and canonically equal.

Develay devoted particular attention to the Ukrainian ecclesiastical question, analyzing it through the principle of non-interference. He presented the Moscow Patriarchate’s argument that Constantinople’s intervention within its canonical territory and the granting of autocephaly constituted interference in an internal ecclesiastical dispute, comparing such a situation to external support for a secessionist movement in international relations. In this context, he also examined the dispute over the interpretation of Constantinople’s claimed right to intervene within the jurisdiction of another Local Church.

Develay also drew particular attention to the legal proceedings currently underway in Turkey against the Phanar, concerning the powers claimed by the Patriarchate of Constantinople and the concept of a “primacy of power” as opposed to the traditional “primacy of honor.” He noted that, in this context, questions are also being raised regarding the compatibility of such claims with the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne and the constitutional order of the Republic of Turkey, describing it as an important case whose outcome should be closely monitored.

Konrad Rękas from Poland, a geopolitical analyst and journalist, spoke on the topic “Uniatism, Ecumenism, Hostile Takeover: Western Strategies against Orthodoxy in Historical Context.” He placed contemporary pressures on Orthodoxy within a broader historical context, arguing that although the methods have changed over the centuries — from direct force and Uniatism to ecumenism and the creation of non-canonical ecclesiastical structures — the objective has remained the weakening of Orthodox identity and the displacement of Orthodoxy from its canonical territories.

Rękas particularly highlighted the historical role of Uniatism, from the Union of Florence in 1439 and the Union of Brest in 1596 to contemporary developments in Ukraine. In his assessment, following the failure of attempts to subordinate Orthodoxy through direct pressure, ecumenism became a new and more subtle instrument of influence over the Orthodox world.

“Ecumenism was intended to infect Orthodoxy with the viruses that have been afflicting the Roman Catholic Church for decades,” Rękas stated, arguing that a Church that renounces the uniqueness of truth gradually loses its own religious identity as well. He described contemporary non-canonical ecclesiastical structures as “hybrids of Uniatism and ecumenism, disguised as Orthodoxy,” citing Ukraine and the Baltic states as examples of a broader process that he views as an attempted “hostile takeover” of Orthodoxy.

In conclusion, he emphasized that the response to such processes must be the preservation of the Orthodox faith and canonical order, as well as cooperation with traditional Christian circles in the West that oppose secularization and the radical transformation of the Christian heritage, without compromise on matters of faith.

Nicolò Ghigi from Italy, a PhD candidate in Ancient Studies at Ca’ Foscari University of Venice, specializing in Byzantine philology and who also pursued theological studies at the Moscow Theological Academy, presented the topic “The Subordination of the Church to Political Expediency as a Motive of Ecumenism.” He pointed to the historical connection between ecumenical processes and political interests, distinguishing between historical, Protestant, and Roman Catholic ecumenism. In his assessment, contemporary ecumenism cannot be viewed exclusively as a theological phenomenon, since in different historical periods it has been closely connected with the interests of political centers of power.

As examples of the political instrumentalization of ecclesiastical issues, he cited relations between Church and state in the Soviet Union, the activities of the Patriarchate of Constantinople under Western political influence, as well as earlier attempts at union with Rome. According to Ghigi, the common denominator of these processes was the placing of political success and secular interests above the purity of faith, and the acceptance of dogmatic compromises in pursuit of political objectives.

Referring to the example of St. Mark of Ephesus, Ghigi emphasized that even political advantage cannot justify ecclesial unity based on compromise in matters of faith. Union, if it is to exist, must be founded on truth, not on compromise and falsehood, he stated, stressing as a fundamental principle that political interests must never be placed above the Orthodox faith.

The final speaker, Dmitry Belyakov from Belarus, President of the Center for Systemic Human Rights Protection, spoke on the topic “The Role of Great Britain in the Religious Question in Ukraine and Eastern Europe.” Belyakov analyzed religious developments in Ukraine and the broader Eastern European region in the context of international political interests and geopolitical competition, arguing that the religious question has become an important instrument of foreign policy.

He identified five levels of British involvement in the religious question in Ukraine — institutional, diplomatic, parliamentary, informational, and military. As examples, he cited regular contacts between British officials and the leadership of the Orthodox Church of Ukraine, activities in the British Parliament and on expert platforms such as Chatham House, as well as the involvement of British military chaplains in the training of approximately 200 Ukrainian military chaplains.

Belyakov particularly drew attention to what he described as a one-sided approach in British policy, which supports the Ukrainian authorities and the new ecclesiastical structure while, at the same time, disregarding the persecution of the canonical Ukrainian Orthodox Church, the seizure of churches, and restrictions on the religious rights of its faithful. In his assessment, such an approach calls into question Britain’s declared commitment to religious freedom and points to the use of ecclesiastical divisions as an instrument of geopolitical pressure.

He also addressed claims made by the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service concerning British support for activities of the Patriarchate of Constantinople aimed at weakening the influence of the Russian Orthodox Church in Ukraine, the Baltic states, and other parts of Eastern Europe. Belyakov emphasized that such claims require critical assessment and further verification, but warned that the spread of the Ukrainian model of ecclesiastical divisions to other countries could pose a serious risk to the canonical unity of Orthodoxy.

Following the presentations, a discussion was held with the participation of the speakers and conference guests. One of the central questions raised was how to preserve Orthodox unity and canonical order in circumstances in which ecclesiastical disputes are becoming increasingly intertwined with geopolitical conflicts.

In the concluding part of the conference, it was emphasized that the challenges facing the Orthodox world today cannot be understood from a single perspective alone. Theological questions are inseparable from ecclesiology and canonical order, while contemporary canonical disputes are increasingly intertwined with political and geopolitical processes. Geopolitical interests, in turn, can have far-reaching consequences for inter-church relations and Orthodox unity.

Particular emphasis was placed on the fact that preserving Orthodox unity requires respect for canonical order, conciliarity, and the legitimate autonomy of the Local Orthodox Churches, as well as the ability to distinguish the authentic needs of the Church from political interests seeking to instrumentalize religious issues for geopolitical purposes.

The International Council for the Defense of the Orthodox Canonical Order of the Center for Geostrategic Studies, together with its partners Theosis Editrice and Orthodoxos Typos, announced the continuation of international dialogue and cooperation among theologians, scholars, legal experts, journalists, and other specialists engaged with questions concerning the position and future of Orthodoxy.

Report: Center for Geostrategic Studies
August 2026

 

Source: https://eurasianmediaforum.com/how-the-foundations-of-orthodoxy-are-being-undermined/

Monday, November 16, 2026

Full Letter of Metropolitan Philaret of New York to Metropolitan Epiphanios of Kition (1975)


 

September 7/20, 1975
Forefeast of the Nativity of the Most Holy Theotokos

To His Eminence Metropolitan Epiphanios of Kition
Larnaca, Cyprus.

Your Eminence and beloved Brother in Christ,

Christ is in our midst.

Having recently returned from an extended visit to the holy Bishops and communities in Europe, I find myself confronted with many administrative matters awaiting my attention, among them my overdue reply to the letters of Your beloved Eminence.

I was pleased to hear that your recovery is progressing well. I assure Your Eminence of our humble prayers for you and your God-protected flock, that you may all be preserved safe and unharmed, to the glory of the God of the Orthodox and to the utter shame of the unbelieving enemies of the pious Greek people. Amen.

We have received from Christ the Savior the command to be ready at all times to give a defense, whenever the need arises. Perhaps never before in world history has our Faith been tested as it is being tested today. Our Holy Church, striving to meet and care for the spiritual needs of a flock scattered to the ends of the earth under difficult circumstances, and whose members do not all share the same understanding of Orthodox exactitude [akriveia], has exercised pastoral economy, while never abandoning the principles of exactitude in the confession and practice of our Uninnovated and Most Holy Faith.

For this reason, we are astonished and slow to respond when our brother Greek Hierarchs allow themselves to be scandalized by distorted and, in any case, isolated incidents that in no way represent the uninnovated Confession of our Holy Synod, and when you hasten once again to ask us for assurances concerning our Confession, as though it were possible for us to invent some “new” Orthodoxy.

Your Eminence: Has it perhaps escaped your notice that our Russian Synod Abroad is excluded and isolated from the Local Churches precisely because of our stand against the pan-heresy of Ecumenism and every form of modernism and innovation? Try to find out whether these Churches acknowledge any connection with us. And now, moreover, do you and your venerable Synod consider it just to suspect us of being two-faced, and of somehow harboring both overt and latent heretical sentiments and beliefs, on account of isolated, wholly unrepresentative, and perhaps even distorted incidents here and there within the worldwide body of our martyric Church?

Glory be to the All-Good God, our Russian Church has not suffered the affliction of the calendar innovation; but do we not also bear our own wounds? And does not the Apostle exhort us to understand and bear one another’s burdens? From the beginning, our Russian Church recognized that the calendar innovation was unacceptable and did not dare to disturb this boundary handed down by the Fathers, for the Ecclesiastical Calendar is a matter pertaining to the life of the Church and, as such, is safeguarded by the ordinances of Sacred Tradition.

It is, however, evident to all that the calendar innovation brought about a schism in the Church of Greece in 1924, and the responsibility for this schism rests entirely upon the innovators. One arrives at this conclusion by examining the Patriarchal Tomes (such as that of 1583) and by taking into account the sorrowful and manifest fact of the schism, as well as the dreadful penalties, persecutions, and blasphemies endured by those devoted to the ancestral piety of Sacred Tradition.

Reasoning thus, our Holy Synod has determined that “we avoid concelebrations with the New Calendarists–modernists.” We do not concelebrate with them, nor would we grant permission or a blessing to any of our clergy for such a concelebration. As evidence that this is indeed the case, we inform Your Eminence that any community of the diaspora received into our Church is required to follow the ancestral Ecclesiastical Calendar of the Orthodox Church.⁹

Your Eminence, holy and beloved Brother,

We are united in one Faith, which we both revere and for which we are prepared to die. We are one, although efforts are being made to divide us through mistrust and distortions. Holy Scripture assures us: “How beautiful are the feet of them that preach the gospel of peace.” Become, most beloved Brother, such an angel of concord and peace, that you may receive the unfading crown of a peacemaker and son of God by Grace, to the shame and disgrace of those who seek to bring about the division of the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church of God—a division which only the Antichrist desires.¹⁰

Please convey my respects to His Beatitude Andreas, the Primate of your Holy Synod, and to the other holy Hierarchs and brethren, whose holy prayers I earnestly request.

I remain Your Eminence’s humble brother in Christ and fervent intercessor before the Lord.

† Metropolitan Philaret


Translated from the Greek edition contained in a typewritten memoir of the recipient, Metropolitan Epiphanios of Kition (+2005), dated February 21, 1976, and composed in Athens.

St. Nikodim Milaš (+1915) on the Hierarchical Authority of Bishops Prior to Conciliar Condemnation

 

 

 

An excerpt from St. Nikodim’s commentary on Canon 4 of the Council of Antioch (+341):

 

This canon, renewing and supplementing Apostolic Canon 28, has as its purpose the safeguarding and strengthening of the judicial authority of the Council and the Bishop: the former when judging a Bishop, and the latter when judging a Presbyter, Deacon, or other cleric.

[…]

According to the canonical teaching of the Orthodox Church concerning the Mystery of Holy Orders, its spiritual aspect—the imparting of Divine Grace to a particular person—is just as important as its juridical aspect, that is, the spiritual authority through which this Grace is imparted.

This authority constitutes a public right, and its conferral upon another person takes place through a solemn act of public law. So long as a person possesses this authority, he may exercise it with full right, and everything he performs by virtue of that authority has validity, even though he himself may be morally corrupt and unworthy of it.

This latter circumstance does not deprive him of his authority, but may only serve as grounds for its being taken away from him. Such authority, moreover, can be withdrawn only through a solemn act of public law, by virtue of which that authority ceases, together with all its juridical prerogatives, and, in particular, every act he performs thereafter is deprived of efficacy and all validity.

Consequently, if a Bishop begins to preach heresy or organizes a schismatic community, he does not thereby immediately lose the right to perform ordinations. But if such a Bishop, for this or some other grave offense, were condemned by a Council and definitively deposed from his rank, he would lose all his hierarchical rights, because he would have been deprived of the Grace of the priesthood and of the right to be a mediator of that Grace to others.

That is to say, such a person can no longer ordain anyone, because deposition—by which we mean definitive deposition (παντελὴς ἀφορισμός)—is precisely that canonical act whereby a person loses the sacred authority that belonged to him until that time and is reduced to the status of a layman, as he was before his ordination.

 

Russian source: St. Nikodim (Milaš), Bishop of Dalmatia-Istria, The Canons of the Orthodox Church with Commentaries, Vol. II (St. Petersburg: St. Petersburg Theological Academy, 1912), Commentary on Canon 4 of the Council of Antioch (341).

Online:

https://predanie.ru/book/73745-pravila-svyatoy-pravoslavnoy-cerkvi/?chapter=chapter_364

 

In ROCOR History: Statement of the Chancery of the Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia Concerning the Case of Archimandrite Anthony Grabbe (1986)


 

The Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia observes with sorrow the ever-increasing attacks in the press upon lawful ecclesiastical authority in connection with certain measures taken by the Church concerning its cleric, Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe), and certain institutions with which he was associated.

Not wishing to provoke controversy in the secular press over matters of a purely ecclesiastical and administrative nature, the Church has hitherto refrained from making public the documents and facts in its possession concerning the case of Archimandrite Anthony. However, in view of the ever more widespread rumors circulating among our flock, apparently originating from circles hostile to the Holy Church, and wishing to protect our God-loving flock from spiritually harmful misinformation, the Synodal Chancery is compelled to bring the following to the attention of the clergy and faithful children of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia:

1. At its meeting in Mansonville, Quebec, Canada, in September 1985, the Council of Bishops, after hearing a report from the Head of the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem, Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe), appointed a Commission consisting of Archbishop Anthony of Los Angeles and Southern California, Archbishop Laurus of Syracuse and Holy Trinity, and Bishop Hilarion of Manhattan, to audit Archimandrite Anthony’s financial and administrative affairs as Head of the Mission.

2. At the end of October 1985, the members of the Commission visited Jerusalem for three weeks, during which they began an audit of the financial accounts of the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission, examined the available documents, and personally questioned Archimandrite Anthony on various matters relating to the audit.

3. The Commission found the financial records of the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem to be in a chaotic state, despite the fact that the Auditing Commission of 1973 had given Archimandrite Anthony precise instructions on how to rectify the accounting procedures. For example, there was no income-and-expenditure ledger at all, and certain very large sums of Church money went directly into Fr. Anthony’s personal account. There were also numerous deficiencies relating to other financial matters and the sale of land belonging to the Mission. The Commission’s report on Fr. Anthony, which detailed clear breaches by Archimandrite Anthony of his obligations to safeguard Russian Church property (known in American legal terminology as fiduciary responsibilities), was presented to the Council of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia, held in New York City in the latter half of January 1986. On the basis of this report, and after prolonged discussion, the Council asked Fr. Anthony to resign from his duties in the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem and the Orthodox Palestine Society and, by its resolution of January 21/February 3, relieved him of those duties.

4. At its meeting on March 14/27 of this year in Montreal, the Synod of Bishops continued its examination of Archimandrite Anthony’s case and issued a resolution setting forth in detail his violations of a number of canons and ecclesiastical regulations. In that resolution, the Synod requested its President, His Eminence Metropolitan Vitaly, under whose authority Archimandrite Anthony was serving, to suspend him from priestly ministry until Fr. Anthony had fully resolved all the matters set forth in the Synod’s resolution.

5. After Bright Week of this year, Metropolitan Vitaly suspended Archimandrite Anthony from priestly ministry pending a decision in his case by an ecclesiastical court.

6. Meanwhile, Archimandrite Anthony, without the blessing of his ecclesiastical authorities, flew to Belgrade to petition Serbian Patriarch German to receive him into the jurisdiction of the Serbian Orthodox Church. The representative of the Serbian Church in the United States, Bishop Christopher, in a letter to Metropolitan Vitaly dated May 7 of this year, expressed his willingness to receive Archimandrite Anthony into his diocese, provided that the latter obtained a canonical release from his ecclesiastical superiors. In a letter dated May 23/July 5 of this year, Metropolitan Vitaly replied to Bishop Christopher that, so long as Archimandrite Anthony remained under suspension and was subject to an ecclesiastical investigation, the Synod could not issue him a letter of canonical release.

7. At the same time, Archimandrite Anthony submitted a petition to His Eminence Metropolitan Vitaly requesting his transfer to the Serbian Orthodox Church. The petition was considered at a meeting of the Synod of Bishops held in Mansonville on May 16/29 of this year, and Archimandrite Anthony was given the following instructions:

a) As long as you remain under suspension, there can be no question of your release to another Local Orthodox Church.

b) The Synod of Bishops considers the explanations submitted by you on May 9/22, 1986, unsatisfactory, since they neither constitute a substantive response to the resolution of the Synod of Bishops of March 14/27, 1986, nor remedy the violations enumerated in that resolution.

c) As a monk and cleric bound to obedience to your ecclesiastical authorities, you are instructed to relinquish your duties as Director of St. Sergius Gymnasium at the conclusion of the academic year (in June 1986).

d) You are temporarily placed under the authority of His Grace Bishop Mark, to serve as custodian of Church property in Wiesbaden, and are to reside in the Church house there, to which you are instructed to relocate within one month after the conclusion of the current academic year.

e) The Synod of Bishops directs you to cease immediately all activity, whether direct or indirect, relating to the affairs of the Orthodox Palestine Society.

f) You are given until the beginning of September 1986, according to the New Calendar, to provide a substantive response and resolve the matters enumerated in the resolution of March 14/27 of this year.

8. Instead of submitting, as a monk and clergyman, to his ecclesiastical superiors and humbly accepting his new assignment and the other instructions, Archimandrite Anthony, on his own authority and unlawfully, withdrew from obedience to the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia and was likewise unlawfully received by Metropolitan Paisios, a Greek Old Calendarist hierarch in Astoria, New York.

For a number of reasons, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia has not been in Eucharistic communion with this branch of the Greek Old Calendarists since 1974. The 1969 decree recognizing the Old Calendarists, published in Novoye Russkoye Slovo (New Russian Word) on June 29 of this year, ceased to have effect after they violated the terms of the agreement in 1974.

Archimandrite Anthony’s unauthorized transfer and his unlawful reception by Metropolitan Paisios violate the following ecclesiastical canons, which state:

“If any Presbyter, or Deacon, or anyone at all enrolled among the clergy, shall leave his own district and depart to another, and, having permanently removed, shall reside in another place without the consent of his own Bishop, we command that such a one shall no longer be permitted to serve, especially if he has disobeyed his Bishop when summoned to return. But if he persists in this disorder, let him remain there in communion as a layman.” (Apostolic Canon 15.)

“But if the Bishop with whom such persons happen to be shall disregard the prohibition against serving imposed upon them and receive them as members of the clergy, let him be excommunicated as a teacher of disorder.” (Apostolic Canon 16.)

“If any clergyman or layman who has been excluded from ecclesiastical communion, or who is unworthy of reception into the clergy, shall depart and be found in another city without letters commendatory, let both the one who receives him and the one who is received be excommunicated.” (Apostolic Canon 12.)

The statements by Metropolitan Paisios and Archimandrite Anthony that the latter was subjected to an unjust ecclesiastical trial do not correspond to the facts, since no ecclesiastical trial of Archimandrite Anthony has yet taken place; there has only been a preliminary investigation.

9. The Secretary of the Synod of Bishops, His Eminence Archbishop Laurus, sent a written protest to the First Hierarch of the Greek Old Calendarists in Athens, Archbishop Chrysostomos, concerning the unlawful interference of a member of his Synod in the affairs of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia. On June 19 (Old Style), the Greek Archbishop Chrysostomos and Bishop Kallinikos sent the Secretary of our Synod a copy of their letter to Metropolitan Paisios, in which they gave him the following directive:

“In view of our desire to restore canonical relations with the Synod [of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia], which were broken off as a result of the ill-considered actions of the former Archbishop, now Monk Auxentios Pastras, the Holy Synod [of the Greek Old Calendarists], at its meeting of June 18/July 1 of this year, unanimously issued a statement opposing the reception of Archimandrite Anthony Grabbe into communion. You should bear in mind that any adverse action on your part will hinder efforts to restore good relations between our Church and our sister Church, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia.”

Thus, even Metropolitan Paisios’s own ecclesiastical authorities acknowledged the unlawfulness of his actions.

10. According to reliable information, Archimandrite Anthony, while under ecclesiastical suspension, has begun performing sacred services and intends to establish a new schismatic parish under the jurisdiction of Metropolitan Paisios. According to the understanding of the Orthodox Church, such divine services and Mysteries performed by clergy under suspension are devoid of grace and constitute sacrilege. Such conduct on the part of Archimandrite Anthony, should he remain unrepentant, will inevitably entail the severest ecclesiastical disciplinary measures, up to and including deposition from the sacred rank.

The Synod of Bishops warns its faithful children not to enter into any prayerful or liturgical communion with Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe) as long as he remains in schism from his lawful ecclesiastical superiors. According to Apostolic Canon 10:

“If anyone shall pray with a person excommunicated from ecclesiastical communion, even in a private house, let him also be excommunicated.”

11. This brief account of the facts and circumstances concerning the case of Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe) is presented to our faithful to clarify the matter, together with a request for their holy prayers that the one who has gone astray may be brought to understanding.

Chancery of the Synod of Bishops

 

Translator’s notes

1. The first canonical quotation in §8 is from Apostolic Canon 15. The Russian text cites it as “Апост. пр. 5,” apparently omitting the digit 1. The English text identifies the correct canon; the Russian original is preserved unchanged below.

2. In §6, the date “May 23/July 5” is reproduced exactly as printed in the Russian text. This is not a normal Old Style/New Style date pair; the intended date has not been independently established.

 

Russian source: “Statement of the Chancery of the Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia,” Church Life (Церковная жизнь), Jordanville, 1986, Nos. 5–6 and 7–8, pp. 74–78.

 

Also see: https://orthodoxmiscellany.blogspot.com/2025/09/on-life-of-archimandrite-anthony-grabbe.html

In ROCOR History: Protocol Concerning the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church


 

On the Feast of the Transfiguration of the Lord, as we reported in The Bulletin of the German Diocese, No. 5/1992, a solemn concelebration took place at the Romanian monastery of Slătioara, with the participation of four Romanian Old Calendar hierarchs, the Greek Metropolitan Cyprian, and the head of our Diocese, Archbishop Mark.

In December, a delegation of the Romanian Old Calendar Church visited our Synod and several parishes in the United States and concelebrated with our bishops at the Synodal church in New York.

We reproduce below excerpts from Protocol No. 704 of November 25/December 8, 1992.

The Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia heard the following:

An oral petition from a Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox delegation composed of His Eminence Metropolitan Vlasie, head of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church; Bishop Demosthenes of Neamț; and their interpreter, Hieromonk Cyprian, requesting that their Church, together with its clergy and flock, be received into prayerful communion with our Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia.

Background:

1. The delegation had previously submitted a formal written petition dated June 16/29, 1992, which was considered at an expanded session of the Synod of Bishops held in Cleveland on September 22/October 5, 1992.

2. At the same time, a letter was received from His Grace Archbishop Mark of Berlin and Germany, reporting on the readiness of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church and its flock to suffer for their faith:

“...this is a deeply believing, martyred people.”

He therefore considers them worthy of every possible support.

3. After discussion of the petition and consideration of Archbishop Mark’s written report, the following resolution was adopted on September 22/October 5, 1992:

To invite representatives of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church to visit the United States with a view to the possible establishment of communion with the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia.

At the present session, the petitioners briefly recounted the history of the introduction of the New Calendar in the Romanian Orthodox Church in 1923 and the subsequent struggle for the Old Calendar, which was accompanied by severe persecution by the Communist authorities and even more severe oppression by the official New Calendar Church.

They further stated that in 1985 they entered into prayerful communion with the Greek Old Calendarists, who were headed by Archbishop Kallistos of Corinth.

Now that political circumstances permit, they petition for the establishment of prayerful communion with our Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia.

After thorough discussion of the foregoing petition, the following resolution was adopted:

From the very beginning of her history, the Holy Orthodox Church has endured, and continues to endure, many trials. These are particularly severe in our evil times, and the present circumstances therefore make unity among those truly devoted to the Faith of the Fathers especially necessary.

Accordingly, the Synod of Bishops resolves:

1. To receive the hierarchy of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church as brethren in Christ into prayerful and liturgical communion.

2. On the Feast of the Kursk-Root Icon of the Mother of God, our Hodegetria of the Russian Diaspora, November 27/December 10, 1992, to concelebrate the Divine Liturgy at the Synodal Cathedral as a testimony to our fraternal unity in Christ.

3. To request that the Synod of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church likewise maintain fraternal relations and exchange reports on the life of our Churches and, should the need arise, that we support one another both morally and through prayer and defend one another against all hostile attacks on our Churches.

4. To invoke God’s blessing upon the clergy and faithful of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church.

5. To communicate this decision in writing to His Eminence Metropolitan Vlasie, President of the Synod of the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church, and to inform the faithful of our Church accordingly.

 

Source: “Protocol Concerning the Romanian Old Calendar Orthodox Church” [«Протокол о Румынской Старостильной Православной Церкви»]. Bulletin of the German Diocese of the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia [Вестник Германской епархии Русской Православной Церкви Заграницей], No. 1 (1993): 11. Munich, Germany.

 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Saint of Aegina and the Controversies Concerning Him: Refutation of Opposing Arguments – Objections

Fr. Nikephoros Nassos | November 22, 2019


 


Preamble

On November 9th, our Church joyfully and solemnly honors the much-beloved Saint, the luminary of Aegina and wonderworking Father and Hierarch, Nektarios, Metropolitan of Pentapolis of Egypt. Many, over time, have portrayed the figure and radiant personality of the one “who appeared in these latter times,” a friend of virtue and imitator of the Lord, he who was revealed by God as Great, “having exemplified the life of the saints of old in evil days,” as we chant in the doxastikon of Vespers in the liturgical Service composed in his honor.

There are, however, also those (a very few, fortunately) who do not honor him, but rather criticize him and attempt to tarnish his memory—either secretly, within closed circles (fearing the reactions of the faithful), or openly, expressing their untheological and baseless objections against him. This amounts to a rejection of the God-confirmed sanctity of the protector of Aegina and wonderworking Saint. What follows will be a brief reference to this issue, and certain points will be emphasized somewhat succinctly, since we have already presented a thorough refutation of the dissenters’ arguments in our now out-of-print work titled “Together with All the Saints” (Athens 2009). Soon, God willing, a dedicated study will also be published concerning the theological and pastoral handling by the Church of errors found in the writings of certain Saints, with special reference to Saint Nektarios, Saint Augustine the holy hierarch of Hippo, Saint Gregory of Nyssa, and other Saints, in connection with the matters at hand.

However, it must be understood that within the framework of the Church, no one decides on their own, according to their own judgment, who is a Saint and who is not! Only the Church pronounces such matters authentically. We cannot introduce arbitrariness into the realms of theology, ecclesiology, and dogmatics—where all things have been resolved in the Holy Spirit by our God-bearing Fathers—just as matters of hagiology have likewise been resolved: namely, the recognition of Saints under certain conditions, or the questioning of such recognition under certain conditions, etc. No one in our Orthodox Church “sets up his own will,” as we say, nor does anyone pronounce judgment in a papal, unsubstantiated, and self-authoritative manner. No member of the body of the Church can raise his personal conscience above the conscience of the Church and appoint himself judge and censor of her judgments and assessments.

In what follows, we will present the arguments of those who do not accept the sanctity of the light-bearing and deified bishop of Pentapolis, Nektarios, who reposed in holiness in the year 1920, and we will refute these arguments theologically and patristically with every possible brevity. Let it be stated by way of introduction that, following the word and example of the great Dogmatic theologian of our Church, Saint John of Damascus, “I shall say nothing of my own,” we will not speak anything from ourselves. We shall rely—as upon a secure staff—on our Patristic literature, since, as Orthodox, we must pronounce judgment “according to the God-inspired theologies of the Saints and the pious mind of the Church.” [1]

FIRST ARGUMENT:

Errors in the Writings of Saint Nektarios

The Saints were not perfect in all things nor faultless—that is, sinless—for they too were mortal human beings. The only Perfect and Sinless One by nature is the Triune God. The Saints were free from delusion, but not infallible! Fallenness and blemish, misjudgment and error, deviation and slip are characteristics even of holy men, as history shows and as Saint Gregory the Theologian aptly notes: “For blemish touches not only the many but even the excellent, since it belongs to God alone to be wholly blameless and untouched by passions.” [2] There are many such instances in our ecclesiastical history which refer to various falls of holy men—whether theological, ecclesiastical, literary, etc.—demonstrating that even the Saints are subject to the conditions of human nature and may commit errors, as they strive, with divine aid and Grace, to transcend the boundary between heaven and earth.

Within this framework, we can objectively acknowledge the existence of writing errors in certain holy men of our Church—Saint Nektarios of Aegina not excluded—who distinguished themselves as theologians and authors, yet whose human weakness gave rise to some inaccuracies. These stem either from ignorance or from other factors, which the Patristic experience of our Church analyzes.

Specifically, there exists a recorded expression of the mind of the Orthodox Church on the issue of writing errors in Saints and sacred authors. This is found in a profound letter (Epistle 24) of the great Photius, Patriarch of Constantinople, addressed to Bishop John of Aquileia. This letter is preserved in the Volume of Joy on ecclesiastical history by Dositheos of Jerusalem, and in Migne’s Patrologia Graeca, volume 102. (As we proceed in our treatment of this subject, we will cite both sources as occasion demands.) This particular letter of St. Photius says it all! It leaves no room for doubt in the mind of the well-intentioned inquirer. It expresses the spirit of the Church concerning such matters, as it has been realized in the Church’s historical journey and recorded in the Acts of the Ecumenical Councils. We will present some points from the letter of St. Photius, analyze them, and subsequently refer to the case of Saint Nektarios.

According to this theological letter of the most wise Father, St. Photius the Great, the Church approaches with much prudence, discernment, responsibility, and pastoral sensitivity the cases in which erroneous views are found in the writings of Saints who are members of the Church. There are many circumstances which have caused numerous virtuous individuals to slip, to “depart,” as we say, from Orthodox Teaching, and to formulate mistaken opinions—even in the realm of dogma! This occurred either because they were led astray as human beings (perhaps during the time prior to their theosis), or because they were addressing their words to heretics, or for other reasons known to God.

Behold the words of St. Photius:

“How many circumstances have compelled many to utter distorted expressions, or to say certain things by way of Economy, or due to the opposition of the disobedient, or even from ignorance—as is humanly to be expected?”

But how does the Church respond to such cases? Some ask: can anyone write whatever they think is right without being subject to review, and disagree with what the Church teaches? Certainly not. Let us look at the continuation of the letter. When St. Photius was challenged to respond (see footnote 3) regarding whether he was aware that Orthodox Fathers of the West had written the Latin heresy of the Filioque, and how this should be dealt with in an Orthodox manner, he writes that it is indeed an innovation, but: “We do not condemn” and “we do not dishonor” the Fathers who perhaps deviated due to ignorance or other causes—when their error had not been pointed out to them and they died without being corrected (as in the case, for example, of St. Augustine and other Fathers).

“…Ambrose the Great, and Augustine, and Jerome, and certain others of like rank and equal stature, who acquired a great name through virtue and brilliance of life, in many of their writings composed that the Spirit proceeds from the Son… and we do not dishonor the Fathers.” [5]

It is important to emphasize that the most erudite, enlightened, and foremost anti-papal Hierarch of our Church, St. Photius the Great, does not conceal the truth of the facts, nor does he attempt to cover for the Saints who deviated by means of various artifices—for example, by saying that perhaps the Fathers did not write those things themselves, but that others inserted them into their texts after their death, and so on. Rather, he confesses the truth, which always liberates and saves. Yes, they wrote them themselves, he says; the Fathers erred as human beings. But, as he writes further down, “since they are silent and not present,” we cannot condemn them. It is not possible to condemn someone who was never corrected for his error, who was never given the opportunity to amend it, and who did not persist in it! “We reject the innovation, but as for its father” (i.e., here he means the blessed Augustine), “being silent, not present, and not opposing—him, therefore, we do not condemn.” [6]

According to Patristic theology, as it is powerfully expressed in the 9th century by the holy Photius, the person—the author—is distinguished from the error / erroneous expression, so that the error itself is not adopted or added to the existing teaching of the Church, while the author continues to be honored by the Church. Particularly characteristic and most enlightening in this regard is the phrase of the holy Patriarch of Constantinople, Photius: “The error that was introduced we do not accept as an addition, but we embrace the men.” [7]

In the same context, St. Photius, drawing from a well-known incident of the Old Testament, writes divinely-inspired words: we Orthodox and "nurslings of the Church" know how, following the example of the two respectful sons of the erring Noah (Shem and Japheth), we must protect our father and not expose him, as the shameless Ham did! We are obligated to cover, with reverence, the back-facing shame of the fallen father (in this case, the erring author) and not to disgrace him with insolence! “Those nourished by the Church and not forgetful of sacred teachings know, like Shem and Japheth, how to cover the father’s shame, and they turn away from and condemn the imitators of Ham.” [8]

According to the Orthodox Church, three conditions must be met in order for a sacred author to be condemned and expelled from the rank of the Saints.

The first is the persistence of the one who has gone astray in his error, when it has been pointed out to him and he has been called to correct it. This is because persistence indicates a mindset—not a simple mistake, but a conscious position—which is blameworthy and condemnable. An error does not make an Orthodox person a heretic! Only persistence in error and lack of repentance, when the error has been pointed out, are condemned.

The second is the contentiousness of the one who has erred toward the Church and his disobedience to her. The Church of Christ throughout the ages and Orthodox Patristic Theology, as is well known, never err; and whoever disagrees with and quarrels or contends against the Church and her theology is not saved! [9] On the contrary, whoever disobeys the God-inspired Patristic Theology falls from every honor he previously possessed, as we know from the many heresies and heterodox teachings that have shaken the Church during her two-thousand-year course in the world.

The third is the death of the one who has gone astray in a state of unrepentance, since “in Hades there is no repentance,” as we all know. [10]

Therefore, when the above conditions occur, the one who has deviated is condemned and cannot be regarded as a genuine Father of the Church of Christ; rather, it is necessary that both he and his writings be cast out. Let us, however, see how precisely St. Photius the Great writes this, whose linguistic idiom is particularly difficult, yet equally admirable:

“Furthermore, if, having been reminded concerning the matter at hand, the treatise of the aforementioned Fathers opposed [the truth] and grew bold in resistance and disobedience, and if they persisted in the same distortion of doctrine and, after the rebukes, ended their life in it, then it is necessary that such persons be cast out together with their mindset.” [11]

What, then, can those who dispute the sanctity of Saint Nektarios, the holy Hierarch of Aegina, say on account of the errors that have made their way into some of his writings? When was he ever rebuked by the Church? When did he persist in his error? What proof exists that he reposed unrepentant or in opposition to the Church? And if the Church has such a tolerant and wise approach even toward those who have erred doctrinally—such as the blessed Augustine [12]—then let us consider how much more tolerantly Saint Nektarios must be regarded, who did not err doctrinally, but merely expressed certain precarious views on matters of ecclesiastical and historical practice.

We would become overly lengthy if we were to examine one by one the human literary slips of the holy Bishop of Pentapolis. Let us mention only briefly his most notable misstep as a writer—particularly as a historian. This consists in the fact that Saint Nektarios adopted an erroneous theory of Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos regarding the Seventh Ecumenical Council, and presented it in his work The Ecumenical Councils of the Church of Christ (Regopoulou Press, 1882, with an introduction by Archimandrite Eirenaios Delidemos). The Saint uncritically copied our national historian’s biased position on the matter of Iconoclasm, with the result that he deviated historically and, under strict critique, perhaps even theologically.

However, this error was explicitly corrected by the holy Hierarch a full decade [sic] later, when he published his renowned work Study on the Holy Icons (1902). There, not only does he clarify matters theologically and ecclesiologically, but throughout the entire discussion in that work he emerges as an exceptionally well-versed researcher and, above all, as a genuine iconophile Father and faithful follower “in all things” of the Holy Fathers. He substantiates this most important work with numerous passages from their writings. Among other things, he presents the reverent disposition of Saint Gregory of Nyssa toward the holy Icons, quoting the passage in which the most wise brother of Saint Basil reveals that he never came upon an image of the divine Passion without being moved to tears, recalling the event depicted by the sacred art of iconography: “Many times I have seen in painting an image of the Passion, and I did not pass by the sight without tears, as the art vividly brings the narrative before my eyes.” [13]

It is also important to see the concluding opinion of Saint Nektarios regarding the restoration of the holy Icons by the Holy Seventh Ecumenical Council. The Saint writes:

“Great and necessary was also the Seventh Holy Ecumenical Council, because it restored to the Church her adornment (i.e., the ornament, the holy Icons), defined the character of the honor due to the venerable holy Icons, and brought peace to the Church, a peace that endured for a century. Through the restoration of the Icons, a certain innovation wholly foreign to the Church of Christ and a mistaken mindset, undermining the Orthodoxy of the Church, were combated.” [14]

We ask: would an iconoclast ever write in such a manner, as the audacious and shameless mouths of the fighters against the Saints dared to present the fervently icon-loving Saint of Aegina? Such things are produced by a lack of theological education when it is combined with ill intent… [15]

Nevertheless, it is necessary to note for the sake of historical record that, beyond the few erroneous formulations of the Saint of Aegina—which are subject to the same treatment as those of all other Saints who erred, as we saw in the recording of the mind of the Church by St. Photius the Great—there was also deliberate hostility directed against Saint Nektarios. His texts suffered alterations and mutilations, falsifications and Procrustean excisions, so as to extract the conclusion that the Saint wrote many heterodox and anti-ecclesiastical things and that he was even… pro-papal! We mention only one instance of distortion, by way of example among many: in his book On the Causes of the Schism, the Saint refers, as a historian, to Patriarch Michael Keroularios. He cites the opinions of earlier authors (which he is obliged to do, since he is writing history) and evaluates them. Thus, Saint Nektarios writes, in the chapter “Character of Patriarch Michael Keroularios,” citing Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos: “Patriarch Michael, writes Paparrigopoulos, was a sharp, meddlesome, power-loving, and ambitious man.” From the above passage, the underlined phrase “as Paparrigopoulos relates” was craftily removed by the critics of Saint Nektarios, with the result that the conclusion was drawn that the disparaging characterizations of Patriarch Michael belonged to Saint Nektarios, whereas in fact they belong to Konstantinos Paparrigopoulos! And how many other similar cases there are! [16] Behold the “honest” methods of the accusers of the Saint of our time…

But let us proceed to the second argument of the so-called (as it has come to be known) “anti-Nektarians.”

SECOND ARGUMENT:

The “Making of a Saint” by Athenagoras

The patristically groundless nature of this argument is evidenced by the patristically and theologically improper term “saint-making,” [17] which is employed by those unfamiliar with the hagiological criteria of the Church of Christ.

In Orthodoxy, there is no such thing as making someone a Saint! On the contrary, this exists in Papism. In our Eastern tradition, where grace and truth exist in Christ, only God sanctifies. The recognition of a Saint by ecclesiastical authorities acknowledges and proclaims holiness; it does not confer it! God is the one who reveals the Saints, and the institutional organs (such as the Patriarchate or Synod) simply recognize, declare, and present the one already proclaimed by God as a Saint. In Orthodox understanding, sanctity is not conferred by decree, but rather recognized and proclaimed as already revealed by God. And this practice has taken on institutional form only in recent centuries. The great ancient Saints and eminent Fathers of the Church (the Cappadocians and others) were not proclaimed through patriarchal or synodal acts. In the early centuries, the recognition of Saints took place locally, by the people. [18] Much later, the phenomenon of proclaiming Saints through patriarchal acts appeared. Professor D. Tsamis writes on this matter:

“In the early Christian Church, no ecclesiastical process was needed for the universal recognition of Saints, and the people, by their own initiative, proceeded to recognize the Saint and to render honor to him. In later centuries, this state of affairs generally continued, though consideration was taken in the proclamation of a Saint by the ecclesiastical authority of Orthodox mindset, martyrdom or holy life, and the working of miracles.” [19]

From the 14th century onward, a shift appears in the manner of proclaiming Saints. Three Saints during this period—Athanasius, Patriarch of Constantinople (the First), a certain Saint named Meletios, and the great theological Father Gregory Palamas—were officially proclaimed through a special process. For Saint Gregory in particular, there exists the relevant act of Patriarch Philotheos Kokkinos, who was also his biographer. However, this process had a local character, as Saint Philotheos himself emphasizes. He notes that such synodal acts are not necessary for someone to be honored as a Saint when God Himself has already revealed him as such. [20] In our own times, this practice of the festive proclamation of the sanctity of persons has become customary. It is not a bad thing—provided it is done according to theological criteria—but neither is it everything, since Saints are revealed solely by the Paraclete, the Holy Spirit, who sanctified them through His uncreated Grace. The ecclesiastical institutions do not make Saints, as has already been said, but simply recognize, declare, and publicize the one already revealed by God through signs as a Saint.

Therefore, the “proclamation” of sanctity does not depend in the least on the ecclesiastical or spiritual quality of a Patriarch. Any given Saint is not promoted by a synodal act of “recognition”! He does not become more saintly or more holy! He remains as holy as the All-Holy God revealed him to be.

And to return to the specific accusation of the doubters: Athenagoras added nothing to the sanctity of the venerable Nektarios of Aegina with the issued patriarchal act of recognition in 1961—just as he added nothing to Saints Nikodemos the Hagiorite [21] and Kosmas of Aetolia [22] with the same process and the acts of the years 1955 and 1961, respectively. It was not Athenagoras who made them Saints—but God! Is it really so difficult for the very few so-called “anti-Nektarians” in Greece to understand this?

THIRD ARGUMENT:

The Short Interval Between Repose and Enrollment Among the Saints

“Why was Bishop Nektarios of Pentapolis enrolled among the Saints so quickly—only 40 years after his repose? Should not 100 years have passed?”

This accusation, like the previous ones, has no Patristic foundation. This view is neither attested in Tradition, [23] nor is there any relevant Canon of an Ecumenical or local Council in Orthodoxy that determines that enrollment among the Saints must necessarily take place 100 years after the repose of the person being recognized. And precisely because no such requirement exists, we see Saints being proclaimed much earlier than 100 years, on account of divine signs, etc.—and they are many, as we know from ecclesiastical history. A striking example is the case of Saint Gregory Palamas, on account of his miracles and his lofty theology. The proclamation of his sanctity took place only nine years after his repose (1358)! The signer of the act proclaiming the God-bearing and God-seeing Palamas, Saint Philotheos Kokkinos, states among other things:

“I honor him as a Saint on account of his miracles, which he worked after his departure from here to God, having shown his very tomb to be a source of healings.” [24]

But is not the same true also for Saint Nektarios? Was not his tomb revealed as a source of healings? Are not so many miracles worked throughout the world in the name of this beloved Saint, a sign of the divine mercy and Grace poured out upon him? Are the doubters not informed of these things? For every well-disposed person, therefore, there exists not even a “mere thought” of opposition to what the Paraclete, through His uncreated Energy, silently indicates and infallibly accomplishes! When God decides, who can oppose Him?…

CONCLUSION

We are in need of the intercessions and supplications of our Saints. If a great, heaven-revealing Basil once wrote in a letter concerning the Saints: “I invoke them, that through them—that is, through their mediation—the merciful God may become propitious to me, and may become my ransom for my transgressions and grant me [forgiveness],” [25] what then must we say, and how much more ought we to approach our Saints with reverence and supplication? The rejection of a Saint is an act directed against the Holy Spirit who bestowed grace upon him, and such an action, when done knowingly, brings down the eternally proclaimed consequences of the Gospel…

The All-Holy God, He who is “glorified in His Saints,” moved the pen of a holy Patriarch of the Holy City of Jerusalem, Nektarios, in the 17th century, so that he might record in a few lines the criteria for the recognition of Saints, according to the Spirit-bearing experience of Orthodox Eastern Christianity:

“Three things are considered to bear witness to true sanctity among men: first, blameless Orthodoxy; second, the attainment of all virtues, among which follows steadfast resistance to sin unto blood for the sake of the faith; and finally, the manifestation from God of supernatural signs and miracles. The first is most necessary for salvation. The second pertains to the character of sanctity. And the third is also most necessary for proof.” [26]

All of the above prerequisites—except for martyrdom—were fulfilled by the sanctified life of the Venerable Nektarios of Aegina, who, with his grace-flowing relics (signs of deification), adorns the Island and the Church and consoles the faithful, together with another Venerable Father of Aegina of more recent times, the blessed Elder Ieronymos of Karvali (+1966), who greatly honored the earlier Saint Nektarios. [27] Therefore, every attempt to tarnish his sacred memory and his most holy person falls into the void; and whoever attempts such a thing—namely, an attack against those Saints revealed by God—imitates the shameless Ham and “turns the reproach upon himself,” that is, he dishonors himself, as St. Photius observes in his profound letter, to which we referred in detail during our treatment of this matter. [28]

 

1. See the Synodikon of Orthodoxy.

2. St. Gregory the Theologian, Funeral Oration for St. Basil the Great, 28, PG 36, col. 533.

3. The writing of this renowned letter in 880 A.D., shortly after the great Synod that has been called the Eighth Ecumenical, was prompted by a letter from Bishop John of Aquileia to St. Photius the Great. The zealous Bishop John complained to St. Photius that the Papists had grown audacious and, in their attempt to support their error and the unlawful addition (“and from the Son”) they made to the Symbol of Faith (the well-known Filioque), they were accusing some of our own Fathers and eminent theologians, in whose writings this erroneous doctrine is allegedly contained. They even name, he says, St. Augustine, St. Ambrose of Milan, St. Irenaeus, Bishop of Lyon, St. Jerome, and others. This, then, was the cause and occasion that led St. Photius the Great to compose this profound treatise, in which is recorded and made manifest the spirit of the Church and her stance in such matters.

4. St. Photius the Great, Letter 24 to John of Aquileia, Volume of Joy, Dositheos of Jerusalem, Rigopoulos Edition, p. 252.

5. St. Photius the Great, Letter 24, PG 102, col. 809B.

6. Ibid., col. 816B.

7. Ibid., Letter 24, Volume of Joy, p. 252.

8. Ibid., p. 251.

9. This is why the great philosopher and theologian Vincent Damodos (18th c.) points out the theological deviations of St. Augustine, such as the Filioque and the theory of absolute predestination (Praedestinatio), yet emphatically clarifies that Augustine was not a heretic, precisely because he did not contend with the Church, but simply believed that what he wrote expressed her mind: “Augustine was not a heretic for this reason, because he did not say those things in opposition to the Catholic Church, but believed that this was the Church’s doctrine, about which there had not previously been any dispute or open refutation.” See Divine and Sacred Teaching (Dogmatic Theology), Protopresbyter G. Metallinos, Tradition and Alteration, Athens 2001 (5th ed.), p. 57. The same applies to St. Nektarios, who did not persist in his errors, nor did he behave contentiously toward the Church. It also applies to St. Gregory of Nyssa, who uncritically adopted from Origen the opinion concerning the apokatastasis (universal restoration) and formulated it in his own writings, and likewise wrote of the temporality of evil (see Questions and Answers of Barsanuphius and John, EPE, Philokalia of the Neptic and Ascetic Fathers, 10C, question 604, p. 154 ff.; and EPE 1, p. 152, On the Creation of Man). Nevertheless, the Holy Sixth Ecumenical Council calls him “Father of Fathers,” overlooking his doctrinal lapses in writing, precisely because he did not contend with the Church. We thus see that the Holy Fathers of the Councils do not operate according to the logic of certain people today…

10. The very few posthumous condemnations of ecclesiastical writings—such as that of Origen (240 years after his repose), or of Theodore of Mopsuestia († 428 A.D.), who in fact laid the foundations of Nestorianism (and for this reason his writings were promoted by Nestorius himself as dogma of faith)—were carried out by the Church for pastoral reasons. The texts of these particular persons became a cause of deviation, deception, and the falling away of people from the correct faith; and where such a danger of the loss of souls exists, there the Church intervenes pastorally in order to protect the faithful from heterodoxy. Regarding this position, see St. Papadopoulos, Patrology III, Athens 2010, p. 337.

11. Ibid., Letter of St. Photius the Great, Volume of Joy, p. 252.

12. The very prolific Bishop of Hippo, Augustine, despite his theological inaccuracies (due to ignorance of the Greek language and of the theology of the Eastern Church, especially that of the Cappadocian Fathers), is honored as a Saint by our Orthodox Church; indeed, Saint Gregory Palamas characterizes him as a “wise and apostolic man.” It is also well known among scholars that the God-bearing Palamas identifies with Augustine in a psychological interpretation by the latter concerning the relationship of the Persons of the Holy Trinity, and particularly regarding the conception of the Holy Spirit as the love between the Father and the Son (“ineffable eros”), with parallel expressions (see the article by G. Martzelos, The Theological School of Thessaloniki and Saint Augustine). Moreover, Venerable Nikodemos the Hagiorite includes Augustine in his Synaxarion published in 1819. He even calls him “saint,” “divine,” “holy,” and “blessed.”

13. See Saint Nektarios, On the Holy Icons, Rigopoulos editions, p. 233.

14. Ibid., p. 291.

15. The reference by certain persons—aimed at covering up their hostility toward Saints—to a particular educated hierarch of the 1970s who, as is claimed, did not honor Saint Nektarios, does not convince the logically thinking and well-informed Orthodox Christian, nor does it constitute an example to be followed. And this primarily because, as we have said, even educated individuals throughout history have erred—even Saints. We all know the case of Saint Cyril of Alexandria, who for many years did not recognize the sanctity of Saint John Chrysostom. Secondly, the deception of many on various matters at that time was due to misinformation, owing to the circumstances of the era, with all that this implies—chiefly the existence of various theological currents and tendencies. Often it is not people who are at fault, but the times, as was aptly observed by the very prolific scholar, historian, and Great Chartophylax of the Patriarchate, Manuel Gedeon. Above all, however, insufficient theological information creates insufficient theological formation. Let us not forget that in the 1970s neither editions of all the Patristic texts existed, nor was Migne’s Patrology widely available in Greece, nor could ease of access to the sources be secured for the well-intentioned researcher. Today, however, all these matters are resolved by the Grace of God, and theological errors are no longer excusable.

16. See Hieromonk Theodoretos, The Unmasking of a Saint-Fighting Nun, Athens 1976, where all the manipulations and distortions of the Saint’s texts are presented.

17. The term “saint-making” presupposes a juridical procedure which takes place only in Papism, where the pontiff “makes saints” of whomever he wishes through a process which we consider unnecessary to describe. From the side of the Orthodox Church, the term “saint-making” was adopted by K. Rallis (On the Proclamation of Saints, see Centenary of the University of Athens, Athens 1938, pp. 305–316) and by the Great Chartophylax of the Patriarchate of Constantinople, Manuel Gedeon, in his well-known work The Making of Saints (Ἁγιοποιήσεις), Thessaloniki 1984.

18. In particular, the Martyrs were recognized immediately after their repose, as is well known.

19. See D. Tsamis, Hagiology of the Orthodox Church, Pournaras editions, Thessaloniki 1999, p. 128.

20. Ibid., p. 129.

21. “We synodically establish, henceforth… that Nikodemos the Hagiorite be numbered among the venerable and holy ones of the Church.” Orthodoxia, 30 (1955), p. 391.

22. “…Therefore we establish… that Kosmas the Aitolian be numbered among the saints.” Ecclesia, 38, 191, pp. 255–256. Conceptually related is also the formulation “is enrolled,” which Cyril Loukaris (1621–1638) used for Saint Gerasimos of Kefalonia, for whom he decreed: “let him be enrolled from now and henceforth in the number of the venerable and holy men.” See S. Papadopoulos, Declaration of the Holiness of a Saint, in the Proceedings of the Church of Greece conference The Saint and the Martyr in the Church, pp. 173–174.

23. D. Tsamis, Hagiology, p. 136.

24. PG 151, col. 711B.

25. St. Basil the Great, Epistle 360, PG 32, col. 1100B.

26. “To the presented positions…” Iași, 1682, p. 209 ff. See also P. Paschos, Saints, the Friends of God, Harmos Publications (3rd ed.), p. 128. Cf. Protopresbyter G. Metallinos, Logos as Antilogos, Harmos Publications, p. 54.

27. In the well-known monographs by Petros Botsis and Sotiria Nousi on Elder Ieronymos of Aegina, there is also mention of a prophecy that was completely fulfilled, concerning the accusers of Saint Nektarios. Specifically, Fr. Ieronymos, one year before his holy repose, while speaking with one of his spiritual children, Niki Tounta from Larisa, said the following: “Be careful, daughter, a few years after my death a nun will appear, who will have much money, and having been deceived, she will write books against Saint Nektarios and will mislead many. You must not believe her and must honor Saint Nektarios.” The prophecy has been entirely fulfilled, since Elder Ieronymos reposed in 1966, and in 1974 the nun Magdalene, abbess of the Holy Monastery of the Ascension in Kozani, wrote her first book against Saint Nektarios…

28. Epistle XXIV of St. Photius the Great: “He who dares to revile one who stands outside all these circumstances brings reproach not so much upon that person as upon himself.”

 

Greek source:

https://intpvolou.weebly.com/thetaepsilonomicronlambdaomicrongammaiotakappa940/46

International Conference: “The Phanar and Ecumenism – How the Foundations of Orthodoxy Are Being Undermined”

Dragana Trifkovic | August 8, 2026     The International Council for the Defense of the Orthodox Canonical Order of the Center for G...