A critical examination of the positions of Fr. Euthymios Trikaminas on the Mysteries and heretics, based on his books about Saint Theodore the Studite, with the sole aim of discovering the truth.
(In
Three Parts)
Adamantios
Tsakiroglou
Classical Philologist and
Historian
June
2020
It is evident that
in recent years we have been facing not only the pan-heresy of Ecumenism, which
is devouring the body of our Church and against which we struggle as much as we
can, but also theories and tendencies have also appeared among those engaged in
the struggle, which are not in accordance with our holy Patristic tradition.
Such a novel
theory, which is not found in the teaching and practice of our Saints, is the
theory concerning invalid Mysteries. This theory states that within the Church
there is no distinction between uncondemned and condemned heretics, and as a
result, the Ecumenists, being heretics, do not need synodal examination and
condemnation, and therefore their Mysteries are invalid.
With the people who
spread this erroneous theory and sow division in the struggle against
Ecumenism, efforts were made to approach them and help them understand the
damage they are causing to the struggle, but in vain. However, recently a
variation of this theory appeared, from the respected Hieromonk and struggler
Fr. Euthymios Trikaminas, who, although he accepts the Mysteries of the
Ecumenists as valid, and even sends his spiritual children to the Ecumenists to
receive the Mysteries which he himself does not perform, yet, in a speech he
gave last November, he revealed something that had escaped us. He clarified
something we had not realized: namely, that behind the expression “Mysteries
valid by Economy” lies his conviction that the Mysteries of all the clergy of
the Orthodox Church throughout the world he essentially considers invalid, but
for his own reasons, he himself, on his own authority, declares the invalid
Mysteries to be… valid!!! Properly valid Mysteries (according to Fr. Euthymios)
are possessed by himself and perhaps (he has not clarified this) ONLY about 7–8
priests in Greece, and about the same number throughout the world, out of the
tens of thousands of bishops and priests that exist!!!
We communicated
with Fr. Euthymios and, together with another brother, tried to point out to
him the problematic nature of his theory; and also exchanged letters, but
unfortunately, he continues to persist in his positions, influencing a
multitude of faithful, who change their opinion on the matter of the Mysteries
and distance themselves from the position of the Saints, using Fr. Euthymios as
a source. Since the matter is serious and pertains to issues of the Faith, I
was compelled to compose and publicly present this study, in order to defend
the truth which is being misrepresented.
Remaining faithful
to the position we adopted from the outset as those who have walled ourselves
off, namely, that anyone wishing to defend the truth cannot remain attached to
persons and, because of them and to the detriment of the Church, hide or cover
it up, I undertook a critical examination of the positions of Fr. Euthymios
Trikaminas concerning the Mysteries (using the positions of the Saints as the
criterion) on the basis of his books about St. Theodore the Studite, and there
I found that, indeed, his teaching on “Mysteries valid by Economy” is without
support in the Church’s tradition, internally inconsistent, and ultimately
leads to the conclusion that the Mysteries are invalid. And from the critical
study I conducted, I saw that this is precisely what was happening.
This critical
examination is being published after – as the Church commands – our dialogue
with him, even in the presence of witnesses, bore no fruit. However, I
respected and still respect his struggles, as well as those of all, against the
pan-heresy of Ecumenism and against every form of schism. But this does not
automatically make me a blind follower, lacking discernment and love for the
Truth, which above all we must all uphold.
As the starting
point of this examination, I present the patristic position of Fr. Euthymios
himself, as it is expressed in his book “The Confrontation of the Heresy of
Ecumenism According to Saint Theodore the Studite” (hereafter in the text
referred to as the blue book), p. 348:
“It
is therefore necessary that the thoughts which will be presented not be taken
as a rebuke, nor much less that they are mentioned in order to, in some way,
assume the role of a teacher, or to invalidate a struggle of decades, or to
show some form of rivalry, but rather to be understood as fraternal concerns
and a contribution to a struggle whose motives and purpose are pleasing to God.
If again something mistaken is found in what will be presented, it is necessary
that the error be attributed to our own misunderstanding, that is, that we did
not sufficiently comprehend the Saint, and of course, insofar as it is shown to
us with appropriate evidentiary support, we must ask forgiveness for our own
misapprehension. However, what is mistaken and what is correct must be examined
with ecclesiastical and not personal criteria, because it often happens that
what others do is judged as wrong and what we do as right, and thus, we are
neither able to see our own errors nor, of course, to correct them.”
With the spirit,
then, that characterizes this position, I too endeavor—out of obedience to the
Truth—to approach, as far as possible, this very Truth which brings salvation
to our souls, and to avoid scandalizing or misleading the brethren, in this
case, the matter of the validity or invalidity of the Mysteries of the
uncondemned Ecumenists.
In trying to
understand what the teaching of the Church is on the matter of the validity or
invalidity of the Mysteries of all the tens of thousands of clergy of the
worldwide Orthodox Church, I undertook to examine and compare the positions of
Fr. Euthymios, as they are presented in his own books on Saint Theodore the
Studite.
The public
positions of Fr. Euthymios, as they were expressed in his most recent homily at
Stagiates (Eighth Sunday of Luke, November 10, 2019), are that, according to
St. Theodore the Studite,
a) the Mysteries of
heretics are invalid,
b) there is no
distinction between condemned and uncondemned heretics,
c) heretics are
always outside the Church (whether condemned or uncondemned),
d) today, because
of the circumstances, we consider the Mysteries valid by Economy (the question
of precisely who considers them valid remains unanswered).
From this study,
then, I personally concluded that on the matter of the validity of the
Mysteries—both because of the difficulties presented by St. Theodore’s text and
because many different expressions and words are used for the same concept—
a) the Saint’s
thinking concerning the Mysteries has been misinterpreted,
b) heretics are
indeed distinguished by the Saint into uncondemned and condemned,
c) uncondemned
heretics remain institutionally within the Church, as tares and corrupted
members, until their condemnation and separation from Her all-holy Body.
(Many Fathers also
use expressions such as that they are “outside the Church,” or “they are not
the Church,” but in the sense that they are potentially outside the Church,
that they do not express Her Truth and have personally lost Divine Grace, being
personally bereft of the Holy Spirit. However, this does not render the
Mysteries they perform invalid, since we subsequently see the demand for the
convocation of a Synod, so that the very Synod which elected and ordained them
may also remove from them the Divine Grace by which they perform the Mysteries.
Perhaps here lies the subtle distinction which escapes the attention of those
who support the invalidity of the Mysteries.)
d) Therefore,
ultimately, it is the Orthodox synod that will decide on these important
matters, and until then, walling-off from heretics is sufficient—an act which
contributes decisively (together with the texts that refute heresy) to the
awareness among well-intentioned faithful of the danger of heresy, that is, to
the safeguarding of the body of the Church, insofar as it depends on and is
permitted to them, and it also has salvific consequences for themselves.
To claim that the
Mysteries of uncondemned heretics are invalid and without effect would lead to
the dissolution of the Church, because many times heretics have prevailed in
the Church, and indeed for long periods of time, and the flock was—and
especially today is—in complete confusion. For decades, hundreds of thousands
of faithful have been communing, marrying, being baptized, and receiving
ordinations from clerics inclined toward heresy.
The Mysteries of
uncondemned heretics are valid because they have not been condemned by an
Orthodox Synod. Whoever, however, while knowing the heresy, maintains
ecclesiastical communion with the heretics, is defiled by heretical ideas
(“evil communications corrupt good manners”), and denies the confession [of
faith], since the one who commemorates a heretical bishop, by identifying
himself with him, also—according to the Fathers—shares in whatever that
heretical bishop confesses; this is also attributed to him as his own faith and
confession, since he declares at the most solemn moment, during the Divine
Liturgy, that he has as his head a bishop who “rightly divides the word of
truth,” while the bishop is an Ecumenist and has accepted heretical decisions
(Council of Kolymbari, Ukrainian schism, etc.).
If, in the end, one
does not wall himself off or at least does not acknowledge the correctness of
walling off and his own inability to carry it out (as, for example, the monks
in the time of Bekkos, who, at the warning of the Theotokos, could not endure martyrdom
and fled), but instead believes that the Ecumenists are Orthodox, then for him
the Mysteries are unto his own condemnation, and he will be counted among them,
because not only the heretics and schismatics were examined and judged, but
also those who were in communion with them, accepting and not reproving their
heretical belief. Only when an Orthodox Synod examines, judges, and condemns
the unrepentant heretics do they then fall “in actuality” from the body of the
Church, and their Mysteries become invalid and without effect. These points
will be demonstrated below.
As a first proof of
the above (many more will follow), I present the teaching of the Church on this
matter, as it was briefly and excellently expressed by the Hieromartyr Kyrill,
Metropolitan of former Kazan and Sviyazhsk (+1937), in his letters (and with
this and with all the following sources it will be demonstrated in the study
that Fr. Euthymios, by misinterpreting St. Theodore, expresses the exact
opposite of the Holy Martyr). The Hieromartyr emphasizes the necessity of
walling off from heretics as an evangelical command, but at the same time he
makes clear that the Mysteries of uncondemned heretics are valid until their
deposition. As valid, they become illumination for those who are unaware of the
heresy and commune worthily, and condemnation for those who are aware and
commune unworthily:
"Whether
or not the Grace of God exists in this endeavor of Sergius, we will not dare to
judge until a lawful Synod, through its decision, expresses the judgment of the
Holy Spirit concerning him. However, as with everything similar to the
Renovationist movement, we are not able to recognize the administration of the
Church that has been renewed under Metropolitan Sergius as the Orthodox
administration that proceeded from the succession struggle of His Holiness,
Patriarch Tikhon.
Consequently,
remaining in canonical unity with Metropolitan Peter, the Patriarchal Locum
Tenens, since at present it is not possible to communicate with him, we
recognize the structure of Church administration as the only lawful
arrangement, based on the Decree of the Tsar dated 7/20 November 1920. I firmly
believe that the Orthodox Bishops, with fraternal unity and mutual support,
will, with God's help, preserve the Russian Church in the traditional Orthodoxy
of the still-binding Patriarchal Testament and will lead it to a lawful Synod.
I have the impression that neither you nor your correspondent distinguish
between the actions of Metropolitan Sergius and his followers, which are
performed in proper order and with the power of the rights of grace—which is
received through the sacrament of priesthood—and those other actions which are
carried out in violation of the rights of the Mysteries and with human deceit,
as means of preserving and defending their self-invented rights in the Church.
Such actions have been undertaken by Bishop Zacharias and the priest Patapov,
about whom you speak. These are sacramental acts only in outward form, whereas
in essence they are acts of usurpation of sacramental activity, and thus they
are blasphemous, graceless, and non-ecclesiastical. However, the Mysteries
performed by the Sergianists who are canonically ordained and who have not been
forbidden to serve as priests are undoubtedly salvific Mysteries for those who
receive them with faith and simplicity, without doubts or misgivings about
their efficacy, and who do not even suspect anything erroneous in the
Sergianist order of the Church. At the same time, however, these Mysteries are
unto judgment and condemnation for those who perform them, as well as for those
who knowingly participate in them—those who are well aware that there is
falsehood in Sergianism and yet do not oppose it, a fact which reveals a
culpable indifference toward the mockery of the Church. For this reason, it is
essential for an Orthodox Bishop or priest to abstain from communion with the
Sergianists in prayer. The same is equally essential for laypeople who conduct
themselves consciously in all aspects of ecclesiastical life.”
(Excerpt
from a letter to an unknown Hierarch, February 1934).
The invalidity of
the Mysteries of heretics who have not been condemned is supported neither by
the teaching of the Saints nor by ecclesiology—regardless of whether someone
holds the right faith or false beliefs, or whether those beliefs have been
proclaimed openly. For, since we do not know the hidden things of men, each
time we perceive or suspect that a certain clergyman has "strange"
ideas, we would have to doubt the Mysteries he imparts to us. Therefore, what
defiles—provided that the person advocating heresy has valid priesthood—is the
heresy he conveys, not the Mysteries. As long as a Synod of Bishops has not
revoked their authority to perform Mysteries, they may perform them.
The faithful (until
the deposition of those who preach false doctrine) have received from the Lord,
the Apostles, and the Synods instruction and Commandments that safeguard them:
not to receive Communion from heretics and to wall themselves off from them;
and this is sufficient and protects them from defilement.
St. Basil the
Great:
"Therefore
we beseech you to obtain ecclesiastical correction and to abstain from
communion with the heretics, knowing that indifference in these matters strips
us of our boldness before Christ."
(To
the monk Urbicius, Epistle 262).
Heretics, of
course—whether openly or secretly—are consciously heretical; they have brought
upon themselves the “anathema” as long as they remain unrepentant. They are cut
off from the Church. However, from the moment they manifest their unbelief, the
Christian soul cannot endure receiving the Mysteries from their hands and
communing, thereby becoming an accomplice in their false belief. Furthermore,
those who know their atheism–heresy, by receiving Communion from them, it is—in
certain cases—doubtful whether they receive Divine Grace and enlightenment, or
the Mysteries become for them, precisely because they are valid, judgment and
condemnation, since they know.
Commands of the
Apostles:
“Listen,
you bishops, and listen, you laity, as God says: ‘I will judge ram against ram
and sheep against sheep,’ and to the shepherds He says: You shall be judged on
account of your ignorance and the corruption brought upon the sheep—that is, I
will judge bishop against bishop, and layman against layman, and ruler against
ruler. For these rams and sheep are rational, not irrational, lest the layman
say: ‘I am a sheep and not a shepherd.’ Just as a sheep that does not follow
the good shepherd is given over to wolves for destruction, so too the one that
follows an evil shepherd clearly faces death, because it will be devoured.
Therefore, one must flee from corrupting shepherds.” (Apostolic
Constitutions 2.19)
After his
punishment–deposition, only THEN does the bishop cease to have the authority to
perform Mysteries. Until that point, he is a bishop—and, due to the heresy, a
false bishop—whose Mysteries have efficacy for the faithful who are unaware—who
have not realized—his heresy. And indeed, such a bishop is a source of
defilement for all because of his false doctrines; but those who have become
aware of his heresy and willingly commune with him not only become defiled, but
also sin, because they tolerate the heretic who abuses and corrupts the
handed-down Faith, because they do not confess the Orthodox faith, because they
commune with him and from him, even though he holds false beliefs. And for this
sin, God will punish them with the ultimate punishment: He will exclude them
from His Kingdom:
“Everyone
therefore who shall confess Me before men, I also will confess him before My
Father who is in the heavens; but whoever shall deny Me before men, I also will
deny him before My Father who is in the heavens.” (Matthew 10:32–33)
Someone who does
not know that a certain clergyman (who has not been deposed) is a heretic and
is in communion with him in ignorance—does he become defiled? Certainly he is
defiled, but not by Holy Communion, rather by the heretical ideas and
practices; yet, because this occurs in ignorance, God will protect him and will
reveal the truth to him, if he has good intent.
The one who knows,
however, it is evident (according to the teaching of the Saints) that he is
both defiled by the teaching of the false shepherd and betrays the faith,
because he “makes peace” with a heretic, because he remains silent and does not
resist, does not confess, and thus—directly or indirectly—identifies with the
heretic; and finally, he is “defiled” by the Mysteries, not because they are
themselves defiled, but because he receives fire and “hell,” since he knowingly
communes and contributes to the dominance of heresy, insofar as he does not
resist in an Orthodox manner (by separation) against the enemies of God (who
are the heretics) and those who accept them, even silently. We would be
speaking literally, then, if we said that he is not merely defiled, but
condemned. For this reason, God cries out from the time of the Old Testament
(but for the post-patristic “anti-Ecumenists,” He cries out in vain!): “Come
out from among them,” “do not even say greetings to them,” etc.
Saint Mark of
Ephesus:
“For
I am firmly convinced that the more I distance myself from him (the Patriarch)
and those like him, the closer I draw to God and to all the faithful and holy
Fathers; and just as I separate myself from him, so do I unite myself to the
truth and to the Saints.” (P.G. 160, 536). (Source: https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/05/blog-post_763.html)
I will begin the
critical examination with the booklet “The Walling-Off of Orthodox Faithful”
(2011), signed by Panagiotis Simatis, Xantha-Nakou Christina, Konstantinos
Georgitsis, which had the blessing of Fr. Euthymios, was published and has been
posted for many years now on the blog “Patristic Tradition” for everyone
to read. On page 54 we read:
“Until,
therefore, a synod has issued a decision and officially condemned the heretics,
the Church considers their Mysteries valid, because otherwise, with every real
or supposed and imaginary heretical deviation, each believer would doubt the
validity of the Mysteries. The validity, then, of the Mysteries is independent
of the reaction of the faithful—a reaction understood, of course, always within
the framework of the Holy Canons.”
Here the position
that is presented as the correct stance of the walled-off is clear—a position
which, I repeat, was read and blessed as a spiritual father by Fr. Euthymios in
2011! The Mysteries are valid and do not depend on whether faithful have walled
themselves off or from what point they consider them invalid. I began with this
quotation because it is said that “Fr. Euthymios always said these things,”
something which, as is proven, is not true—both here and in other texts that I
will present subsequently. Indeed, Fr. Euthymios, in a text of his one year
prior, stated most correctly and publicly in a written response to a monk:
“But
by saying that I doubt the Mysteries of the Old Calendarists, you shift the
issue from the holy Canons to Fr. Euthymios, and in this way you render the
schisms innocent doves—because, after all, who is Fr. Euthymios who doubts the
Mysteries of the Old Calendarists, and what authority does his opinion have
within the Church?”
(Source:
https://paterikiparadosi.blogspot.com/2018/01/blog-post_427.html?m=0)
I believe we all
agree that we cannot tell the people one thing in 2011, another in 2018, and
yet another in 2019, nor say one thing in our published texts, another in the
books, and still another in the lectures; for in this way confusion and
division are stirred among the flock, with the result that today we have
faithful who say, “I am in favor of invalid Mysteries—Fr. Euthymios says so in
his book,” or, “I am in favor of Mysteries valid by Economy—Fr. Euthymios says
so.” In the above text Fr. Euthymios does not consider himself worthy, and
rightly does not proclaim himself to be the Church, so as to pronounce on the
Mysteries of the few schismatic G.O.C., much less on those of the far more
numerous Ecumenists! This is the task of the Church. But then the self-evident
question arises: how can he now assert the opposite?
Of course, a change
of positions is permissible and necessary, provided that an error is
recognized—and then, once it is publicly acknowledged and forgiveness is sought
from the faithful for what is, we hope, an obviously unintentional and not
deliberate deception, and once the new “truth” is established with a now
careful patristic positioning—so that we do not “say and unsay”—and after great
and serious testing of the new position, its announcement may take place.
However, as it appears (always according to the comparison of Fr. Euthymios’
writings with ecclesiastical texts, as he himself has requested), his position
(concerning invalid Mysteries or valid by Economy) is refuted by his own texts,
as an author, as will become evident from the following examination of his
books. And indeed, this self-refutation would hardly concern us, if it did not
affect our holy Patristic Tradition.
I begin with the
book “Venerable Theodore the Studite: Life, Brief Teaching, and Comparison
with the Contemporary Church,” in which, although Fr. Euthymios’
conclusion/interpretation is stated—that according to the Saint the Mysteries
are invalid—at the same time the following opposite points are also presented
and expressed:
Pages 68 to 85:
here Saint Tarasios is presented as not blessing and not performing the
adulterous marriage of Emperor Constantine, but for reasons of Economy,
not deposing and tolerating the adulterous priest Joseph. For this reason,
Saint Theodore walled himself off both from the Patriarch-Saint and from the
synod that recognized the marriage. According to the unfortunate (as is proven)
position of Fr. Euthymios—which he presents as a non-negotiable “dogmatic
principle”—from the moment faithful wall themselves off, then the Mysteries
become invalid.
Question: Since
Saint Theodore walled himself off from him, were the Mysteries of Saint
Tarasios invalid? And if so, why does the Saint’s biographer, as Fr. Euthymios
himself very accurately quotes, write the following concerning Empress
Irene—whom he even calls “most God-loving”:
“Both
acted rightly and in a God-pleasing manner. Theodore, because he resisted in
defense of the evangelical doctrines… and the patriarch, because he managed the
matter with economy for the benefit of the Church… All these things were
confirmed by the God-bearing Tarasios, as recorded by the very champion of the
Savior, Theodore, himself.”
Therefore, for the
biographer—with the agreement of Saint Theodore—Saint Tarasios acted rightly,
and his Mysteries were clearly valid, despite St. Theodore’s walling-off and
despite what Fr. Euthymios publicly asserts. Indeed, in the book on walling off
according to Saint Theodore the Studite (which will be referenced below), while
he quotes the words “...all these things were confirmed by the God-bearing
Tarasios” in bold black font to emphasize Saint Theodore’s recognition by Saint
Tarasios, the words “as recorded by the very champion of the Savior, Theodore,”
which indicate an equal recognition of the stance of Saint Tarasios by Saint
Theodore, are not emphasized—because if they were, it would show that the claim
that all the Saints of that time thought and acted—at least for a certain
period—in the same manner as Saint Theodore is not true, and that when someone
walls himself off, this does not entail the automatic invalidity of the
Mysteries of uncondemned heretics.
Here a
misinterpretation of the Saint begins to become evident concerning his teaching
on the Mysteries. All the Saints, and Saint Theodore as well—on more than a few
occasions—speak (and we too, following them until now) of defilement, not of
invalidity of Mysteries. And we, in order not to be defiled and not to
cooperate so that the Church may come out of heresy, have walled ourselves off.
And as it was written in the aforementioned booklet, “The validity of the
Mysteries, therefore, is independent of the reaction of the faithful.” What,
then, is the need for the division among us, for the claim and support that the
Mysteries are invalid or valid by Economy? It should also be noted that NOT A
SINGLE passage from the Saint has been presented which characterizes the
Mysteries as invalid, but only conclusions drawn by Fr. Euthymios from his
interpretation of other words or expressions—expressions which, in his opinion,
constitute clear proof that the Saint taught about invalid Mysteries!
This incident and
the comment of the biographer were not mentioned in the aforementioned lecture
(10 Nov 2019), although for the sake of truth and objectivity, even as a point
that raises doubts, it ought to have been mentioned. Therefore, the assertion that
all the Saints contemporary with Saint Theodore held the same position as Saint
Theodore on matters of heresy is unfounded or even mistaken.
The same argument
is repeated in the case of Saint Nikephoros. There, it is mentioned—on page
186—that Saint Nikephoros honored Saint Theodore, and that his honor toward him
was not diminished “even during the time in which they had come into
disagreement and had no ecclesiastical communion between them.”
So, at the time
when St. Theodore—and so many others who followed him—walled themselves off
from St. Nikephoros, did the latter not have Mysteries? It is evident that they
had valid Mysteries, but were not in ecclesiastical communion.
And where, again,
is the position proven—that the contemporary Saints of St. Theodore supposedly
held the same opinion as he did regarding the invalidity of the Mysteries (it
will be shown that the Saint did not hold this opinion)—since the two aforementioned,
Tarasios and Nikephoros (and those who obeyed them, recognizing their holiness
during their lifetime), communed, even if by Economy and for a period of time,
with those from whom the Saint had walled himself off?
On page 145, the
position of St. Theodore is stated: “A grievous false doctrine has been
dogmatized in our Church. This is the Moechian heresy…”
If, according to
Fr. Euthymios and those who support the invalidity of the Mysteries, the false
bishops have no Mysteries because they do not belong to the Church, then how
does the Saint say “in our Church”? Was a grievous false doctrine dogmatized
also by Saint Tarasios, who tolerated the act of Joseph? Was Saint Tarasios
outside the Church when—as we saw—St. Theodore acknowledged that Saint Tarasios
had acted rightly (see above)? The same as the Saint—but in contradiction to
the lecture in Stagiates on 10 Nov—Fr. Euthymios himself states on page 218:
“Ecumenism operates within the Church and alters its spirit and character.”
And it is not meant
that it operates as Uniatism, Papism, and the other heresies from the outside,
but it is left to be understood that the Ecumenists operate as members of the
Church.
How can it operate
within the Church if the heretics are outside the Church? Therefore, this
refers to uncondemned by a synod heretical false shepherds (individuals who, in
terms of faith, are indeed outside the Church, but institutionally still belong
to Her as decayed members—this will be demonstrated further below—and who hold
positions within Her), and not to condemned heretics who are outside the
Church, a distinction that, although widely present in ecclesiastical
literature, is unfortunately not accepted by Fr. Euthymios, or is expressed by
him so ambiguously that it causes confusion among the flock and leads to
incorrect conclusions.
On page 160, the
biographer of the Saint, presenting the steadfast position of the Fathers
against the iconoclast emperor, says: “‘For it is of no benefit to us,’ they
say, ‘to associate again with those who have already been condemned.’”
Here the solution
to our questions is clearly shown: the Saints who opposed the emperor took a
stricter stance than at other times because they were speaking to heretics
already condemned by the Seventh Ecumenical Council. However, Fr. Euthymios
stated in his lecture that there is no distinction between condemned and
uncondemned heretics, but that all heretics have neither Mysteries nor a place
in the Church. Then why do the Saints call them that, and why do they emphasize
this fact to the emperor?
On page 259, Fr.
Euthymios writes: “The rest of the bishops, however, if they were Orthodox,
should have immediately ceased ecclesiastical communion with him, awaiting the
ecclesiastical court to depose him. For this is what our Tradition says, and
this is what Saint Theodore the Studite and the other Fathers and Confessors
did.”
Here the agreement
of Fr. Euthymios with the tradition of the Church is evident, and at the same
time his disagreement with his own lecture and with the teaching of the Saint
concerning the Mysteries. Here it is stated very clearly that the one who has walled
himself off fulfills his duty as an Orthodox by avoiding defilement and
awaiting—faithful to ecclesiastical tradition—the court, the synod, to depose
the guilty party. Until then, however, the guilty one remains in his position
as a false shepherd (since the human procedures for the administration of
justice in all its forms are time-consuming).
And naturally, in
the above particularly apt comment of the book, nothing is mentioned about not
recognizing the Mysteries performed by this false shepherd, since—even though
he is considered a false shepherd—he is still regarded as a member, a decayed one
indeed, but a member of the Church.
That is why, as is
very rightly emphasized elsewhere (as we will see many times further on), it is
not permitted to perform parallel ordinations when heretics prevail, until
their condemnation. Because then there would be two Churches in one place. But
if the Mysteries are invalid and the heretics are outside the Church, then why
is it not permitted, and why must we wait for the synod? Therefore, according
to Saint Theodore—as is stated here—the Mysteries are valid, since the
priesthood is a mystery, the false shepherds until their condemnation remain
decayed members, tares, and earthen vessels according to Paul, and only the
Church has the authority to bind and loose, that is, to cut them off synodally
from Her all-holy Body. And indeed, She does not become defiled, precisely
because She repels every innovation through the struggles of the
right-believing. Otherwise, the Church would have ceased to be holy many times,
especially in our days, when all of us were, for decades, organically
integrated into the World Council of Churches/heresies (W.C.C.), communing with
the heretics of Chambésy, Balamand, etc.—and in terms of persons in particular,
dozens of Freemasons or simoniacs became bishops!
Simony constitutes
an extremely serious and enduring problem within the Church, which began at the
very moment of Her foundation and remains unresolved to this day, since in most
cases simoniacs remain known yet unknown, and unfortunately unpunished. (The
following information is drawn from the work of Maria Kampouri, “Simony
according to the Holy Canons,” Thessaloniki, 2011).
The origin of this
heresy is shown in the Acts of the Apostles 8:18–23:
“And
when Simon saw that through the laying on of the apostles’ hands the Holy
Spirit was given, he offered them money, saying, ‘Give me also this power, that
on whomsoever I lay hands, he may receive the Holy Spirit.’ But Peter said to
him, ‘May your silver perish with you, because you thought that the gift of God
could be purchased with money. You have no part or share in this matter, for
your heart is not right before God. Repent therefore of this wickedness of
yours, and pray to God, if perhaps the intent of your heart may be forgiven
you. For I see that you are in the gall of bitterness and in the bond of
iniquity.’”
Peter therefore
responded to Simon, “You have neither part nor share in this matter of the
gifts of the Holy Spirit, which are being spoken of.” Peter’s words are
relentless. And yet, to this day (as will be shown below), even the present-day
supporters of the invalidity of Mysteries, including Fr. Euthymios, have not
questioned either the priesthood or the Mysteries of simoniacs; on the
contrary, it was the Synod that dealt with the issue. That Simony constitutes a
heresy is proven not only by Peter’s words but also by the following: Theodoret
of Cyrus calls it “Christ-trading” (PG 82, 889A).
Researching the
measures taken by the “Byzantine” state against Simony, we read that Emperor
Heraclius adopted measures against Simony “to curb what was regarded in his
time as a heresy” (Panagopoulos, I., Simony according to the Law of the
Orthodox Eastern and Western Church, Athens, 1946, p. 102).
In the era of the
Macedonian Dynasty the same applied: “not only a heresy but an indelible stain”
(ibid., p. 104).
It was recognized
as a heresy by St. Theodore the Studite in Epistle 39 to his spiritual son
Arsenius (PG 99, 1044B) and by St. Tarasius in his Third Letter to Pope Hadrian
(PG 98, 1441B), which in fact, due to its importance, was included in the
canonical texts of the Church. Indeed, St. Tarasius writes concerning the
priesthood of the Simoniacs: “he who is ordained bishop, presbyter, or deacon
for money is alien to the priesthood… the Grace of the Holy Spirit is not in
them” (PG 98, 1444C). Paradoxically, Fr. Euthymios, though an expert on St.
Theodore and aware of this letter, does not accept that Simony is a heresy, nor
that what he now teaches should also apply to it. On the contrary, he separates
it as unrelated to the issue of Ecumenism and the Mysteries—most likely because
in that case his position would not hold.
Simony, as a heresy
“more dangerous than any other,” was also recognized by Joseph Bryennios (Pedalion,
p. 239) and by Gennadius Scholarius, who calls it “the greatest of sins and an
all-abominable impiety,” and the Simoniacs “those suffering from the impiety of
Judas” (Against the Heresy or Unbelief of Simony, PG 160, 731D).
Saint Nikodemos
calls the Simoniacs “the greatest of all heretics” (Pedalion, p. 31) and
Simony a “God-hated heresy” (Pedalion, p. 238). Nevertheless, he writes
that even through the Simoniacs, God acts for the benefit of the people.
Saint Isidore of
Pelusium calls it a “dreadful Priesthood” and the Simoniacs “those who do not
look toward the truth” (PG 78, 280B), and he even condemns the use of resources
from Simony for good works, such as the building of churches, referring to them
as “useless stones” (PG 78, 257C).
Numerous Holy
Canons were enacted against it, which impose deposition and excommunication on
each Simoniac (e.g., Apostolic Canons 62 and 63, Canon 16 of Carthage, Canon 10
of the First-Second Council, etc.).
We see, then, that
even the vocabulary of the Saints against Simony is almost identical to that
used against every heresy, and the punishments of the Holy Canons function in
the same way. However, just as with heresy, no one has questioned the Mysteries
of each Simoniac prior to his synodal condemnation. After such condemnation, of
course, the same applies as for condemned heretics. Even St. John Chrysostom,
who convened the Council in Ephesus to depose Simoniac bishops (see Palladius
of Helenopolis, PG 47, 48) and in his treatise On the Priesthood called
the Simoniacs “not called by the grace of Christ” (PG 48, 1070), did not
question the Mysteries performed by them prior to their condemnation. For all
know that, unfortunately, there have been many Simoniacs, and even more exist
today. The period between 895 and 1073 was characterized as “the golden age of
Simony,” and from the 15th century and throughout the period of Ottoman rule
the phenomenon took on new dimensions (see also the comment by St. Nikodemos in
The Rudder, p. 238). Between 1623 and 1700, 50 Patriarchs were appointed
by the Sultan in exchange for payment (Panagopoulos, p. 73). Also well-known is
the scandal of Simony in the Church of Greece in 1876, which even involved the
government of that time. Most of them were never condemned, and if their
Mysteries were questioned, then no one could be sure they were truly baptized,
married, etc., since Simoniacs existed and still exist. Yet the Church has not
lost, nor does it now lose, Her undefiled character. These pseudo-shepherds too
are the hidden wolves, the enemies of Christ and the Gospel, the tares in the
field of the Lord, who will remain until the final Judgment.
They must therefore
answer us — Fr. Euthymios, Mr. Rizos, as well as all the hardline supporters of
invalidity — how is it that the Simoniacs, who were condemned by the Apostle
Peter himself, who do not have Grace, who, according to the Saints — just like
the Ecumenists — are enemies of the Truth, blasphemers of the Holy Spirit, the
worst of heretics, Judases, alien to the Church, enemies of the Church, subject
to deposition, excommunication, etc., nevertheless have Mysteries until their
condemnation, while the Ecumenists do not. And any possible argument that they
are “hidden” cannot hold, since for many bishops in history we have learned
that they were Simoniacs (see also the relevant study), yet their Mysteries
were not questioned — and as for some today, the phrase applies: “it is a
well-known secret.”
It is worth looking
here at what Neophytos Kavsokalyvites — one of the most renowned scholars of
the 18th century — says not only regarding the Mysteries of the Simoniacs, but
also generally regarding Mysteries, the existence — contrary to Fr. Euthymios —
of judged and uncondemned heretics, and the need for a Synod in such cases, in
his work “On the Potential and Actual Power of the Holy Canons,” edited
and rendered by Monk Damianos:
“1.
Comment: Although the Holy Canons prescribe that if someone commits this or
that offense, he is to be deposed, no one is immediately and securely deposed
before judgment (based solely on the prescription)… with this, those are
refuted who, out of ignorance, claim that clerics who were ordained with money
have been deposed together with the one who ordained them; for it says, ‘he who
ordains for money, together with the one ordained, let him be deposed’; but the
entire body of today’s priests is like this — since there is no one who has not
recently or long ago been ordained for money; consequently, the entire body
would end up being automatically deposed! Upon this opinion, then, certain
Christians have strongly clung, and attack the mystery of the priesthood with
such deceitfulness, that they don’t even want to receive a blessing from the
priests…
Therefore,
to those Christians it must be said that they do not reason correctly… the
sacred prescriptions indeed retain their authority unchanged, but they do not
operate of themselves automatically… Likewise, clerics appointed through money,
until they are judged according to the Canons by the avenging hierarchs and
deposed, are not lacking in being priests by the canonical penalty alone, even
if they have not yet been absolved of their guilt… According to the divine
Chrysostom, the condemnation of those responsible has a twofold character: one
through the decision of the judge rendering the verdict, the other through the
natural and experiential testing of the matter, which will take place in the
future… In this way, then, those priests responsible, who have not been deposed
according to the holy Canons— I say before the judgment takes place— are
essentially undeposed and in reality remain merely under accusation, by reason
of the decision of the Canon. For how does St. Basil the Great threaten in his letter
the bishops of his province who ordained for money, that if they are found
doing this a second time, he will no longer spare them?…
Whatever
may agree with the doctrine of the accuser of the clergy, those are it; we,
however, must respond as far as possible, firstly, to those arguments which are
considered to be opposed to the truth... Thus, the deposing voice of the holy
canons, without a co-actor, by itself, certainly cannot depose that person
under indictment, by reason of its potential power toward deposition… there
must precede the ecclesiastical condemnation, which in their view will be
brought about by those in the Church who are competent to judge ecclesiastical
matters (i.e., the synod of the living bishops), and then afterward the one who
disobeys that synod may be to us “as the heathen man and the publican”… What
they cite from the First Epistle to the Corinthians of Paul, namely: ‘let him
be anathema,’ does not support them at all; since it was not said in the form
of a decree, but rather as a curse to instill panic and fear, according to the
divine Chrysostom… Those who ordain and are ordained for money are more ungodly
than Macedonius and those Pneumatomachoi who follow him, more impious
than Simon the magician, and worse than the traitor Judas… and yet, says the
divine Chrysostom, through those who unworthily perform the sacred rites, even
if their life is greatly defamed, God acts, just as through the pure ones, in
all things that pertain to Him. Therefore, from among the unworthy, those who
are unjudged are not deposed automatically by the canons; for then God would
not act through them in His matters, as He does through the pure ones—since He
says, ‘God does not ordain all, but through all He works,’ even if they are
unworthy… From what rank then, I say, and from which ecclesiastical communion
or episcopal operation and power shall he again be excommunicated by the synod
of (living) bishops, those judging after the ecumenical synod, one who has
already once and for all been excommunicated by that ecumenical synod (which
issued the canon)? Since it is not he who is outside, but he who remains within
the rank, who is excommunicated… We believe that there remains no recourse for
the accusers of the clergy, nor in general any excuse for thinking that even
before a specific ecclesiastical trial has taken place, those who insolently
approach the things of the priesthood by giving or receiving money have already
been deposed."
(Full
text: https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/06/blog-post_911.html)
Here we see
Neophytos clarifying matters in an ecclesiastical and patristic manner and
making it clear that:
a) The Simoniacs
are, for the Church, the worst heretics, but their Mysteries, up until their
deposition—if, of course, a deposition occurred—were not questioned, as was
written above. Indeed, we read with astonishment that in the time of Neophytos
there were so many Simoniacs, that if we were to question their Mysteries, then
nothing would remain. Is it different today?
b) There is a clear
distinction between condemned and uncondemned heretics, and prior to the
synodal condemnation of the latter, the Mysteries they perform are valid.
c) The highest
organ of the Church for the condemnation of heretics, Simoniacs, etc., is the
episcopal synod. No one in the Church has the right on his own to invalidate
the Mysteries of clerics under accusation.
d) Neophytos calls
the supporters of the delusion of invalid Mysteries “accusers of the
priesthood,” “deceitful,” “blasphemers,” and “those who oppose the Truth” (let
the reader understand concerning certain ones who so easily accuse), that is,
very severe charges.
e) Therefore, the
saying of Chrysostom, “God does not ordain all, but He acts through all, for
the salvation of the people,” applies not only to unworthy sinful clerics, but
also to uncondemned heretics, as was proven in the case of Simony.
I ask the reader
not to forget the above arguments throughout the reading of the study, since,
even if only these existed, they overturn the positions of Fr. Euthymios.
I continue with the
citation of patristic sources.
I present the
example of the heretic Dioscorus and the Fourth Ecumenical Council, and I limit
myself to the minutes of the First Session and to his condition after his
condemnation.
Minutes. First
Session: In the episcopal lists we read:
"Beginning of
the Council of Chalcedon… Anatolius, the most devout Archbishop of New Rome
(who had been ordained by Dioscorus), Dioscorus, the most God-beloved
Archbishop of the great city of Alexandria, …Maximus of Antioch… The most
illustrious rulers and most eminent senators said: ‘What specific accusation is
brought against the most devout bishop Dioscorus?’" And after he sat in
the appropriate place, the word was taken by “Eusebius, the most devout bishop
of the city of Dorylaeum,” and among other things, he said: "…the good
Dioscorus, disregarding the word of justice and the fear of God, being of the
same mind and opinion as Eutyches, the vain-minded and heretical one… confirmed
the heresy of Eutyches… (…) we beseech and appeal to our authority to decree
that the most devout bishop Dioscorus (note: despite the grave accusation, the
address to the hierarch remains) respond to the charges we bring against him…,
through which we are able to demonstrate that he is both alien to the Orthodox
faith and has strengthened a heresy of impiety, and unjustly deposed us."
Dioscorus is
included in the list of bishops, though he was both a proponent of heresy and
had synodically recognized the heresy two years prior. Therefore, the Council
considers him a bishop in the list, with a valid episcopate.
And so that we are
not accused of cherry-picking and isolating expressions, the same thing that
the Council did will be done centuries later by the holy Kalothetos, who refers
to Kalekas—who was inclining toward heresy but not yet condemned—as “your divinity”
and “your holiness ordered.” The titles “divinity” and “holiness” clearly
demonstrate that Kalothetos still considers Kalekas a member of the Church.
That brave defender of the Faith could not have called someone outside the
Church in such terms. Nor would he have pleaded with someone outside the Church
and without Mysteries to convene a Council. (Here: https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/05/blog-post_989.html)
In contrast to the
above, however: In the Acts of the Council, after the deposition of Dioscorus,
a circular letter to the people, which clarifies the matter of the deposition,
states:
"Preface
against Dioscorus
The
holy and great and ecumenical council, by the grace of God, according to the
decree of the most pious and God-beloved… Dioscorus, who had formerly been
bishop of the great city of Alexandria, came to the holy and great council as
one who had been removed from the priesthood according to the divine canons,
and was attempting, through commotion, to receive again the priesthood which he
formerly held."
We
read here that the Fathers received the information that Dioscorus wishes to
acquire again the priesthood which he previously had and which he lost through
the decision of the Council:
"Not
for the healing granted by Christ, but for injustice and violation of the
divine canons and of ecclesiastical order he made use of it. Therefore, in
order that all the nourished ones of the pious faith may have without doubt the
just decision of the holy and ecumenical council regarding his deposition, we
have approved this letter to be set forth, declaring that he, by the Master God
and by such a great multitude of bishops, on account of the unforgivable deeds
he committed, has been deprived of the grace of the priesthood…"
The statement of
the Council is clear: for his unforgivable actions and heretical teachings, the
grace of the priesthood was taken away from him by the Lord God and by the
multitude of Bishops. These, therefore, as members of the Council, have the
right to decide when someone loses the Grace and from when the Mysteries he
performs are invalid — not individual persons, whether they are robed clergy or
laypeople. When, finally, was the priesthood removed from him? Synodically,
through the deposition on October 13, 451.
The above synodal
declaration does not constitute a confirmation, as those of the “invalid
Mysteries” claim today, of a priesthood already lost when Dioscorus proclaimed
the heresy or when he synodically acknowledged it in August of 449. For, as we
read above, he is listed in the register of the Bishops of the Council — even
despite the strong objections of the representatives of the Pope of Rome — as
“most God-beloved Archbishop of Alexandria.” It constitutes an irrevocable
removal of the priesthood, determined after synodal examination, which took
place by the Lord God and “the multitude of the bishops” in a specific act
within the Council. “The whole has no hope of restoration, since with his
expulsion even the scandals have ceased. The second session of the holy and
blessed Fathers assembled in Chalcedon is completed” (T.L.G., Concilia
Oecumenica (ACO): Concilium universale Chalcedonense anno 451: Tomevolumepart
2,1,2, page 42, line 20, p. 230). This is why the aforementioned Fathers
responded in such a manner to the emperor.
The deposition by
the Council signifies the removal of the priesthood, which he held until then,
because you cannot remove something that does not exist, and from that moment
the invalidity of the Mysteries, because you cannot invalidate something that does
not exist. Dioscorus, after the removal of the priesthood, no longer
constitutes a false shepherd, but a layman. This is evident in another part of
the Acts, when some Archimandrites appeared before the Council to intercede on
behalf of Dioscorus and said, among other things: “...we beseech your Holiness
to proceed in all things accordingly and allow to be present at this synod the
most holy Archbishop Dioscorus...” Then the bishops of the Council, now
indignant, interrupted them: “...the most devout bishops cried out: Anathema to
Dioscorus. Christ has deposed Dioscorus. Cast these men out. Remove the insult
to the Council... The Council cannot hear these petitions. They dared to name
as bishop the one who has been deposed by the whole Council — why are the
canons being trampled?” (T.L.G., Concilia Oecumenica (ACO): Concilium
universale Chalcedonense anno 451: Tomevolumepart 2,1,2, page 117, line 9,
p. 300).
But even Fr.
Euthymios himself, in his response to Seraphim of Piraeus in 2013, wrote
regarding Nestorius—similar to what was said about Dioscorus:
"Here,
for the first time, the Fathers call him 'most impious,' whereas before he was
deposed, even though he was heretical, they called him 'most devout.' This
title 'most devout' was used by the Fathers for Nestorius many times in the
discussions before his deposition, evidently because he had not yet been
punished. The local Synods neither condemned Nestorius nor anathematized him,
because they did not have such authority. They simply condemned and
anathematized his heretical teachings. This is clearly shown from the twelve
anathemas of St. Cyril, which are included at the end of his third letter. For
this reason, every anathema begins with 'If anyone does not confess' or 'If
anyone dares to say' or 'If anyone says,' etc. Nowhere in the anathemas is the
name of Nestorius mentioned."
And here we are
saddened by the development. Fr. Euthymios seems not to have clarified within
himself the matter concerning invalid Mysteries in relation to St. Theodore,
and for this reason, in his writings, these conflicting positions existed,
which he tried to balance by speaking of Mysteries “valid by Economy”. Lately,
however—and strangely—he chose as “patristic” truth the position of certain
Athonites and some laymen, who insist without evidence on the invalidity.
Before I begin with
the second book, I would like to present something regarding an argument from
the homily of 10 Nov 2019:
“Why
is it wrong? [ed. Fr. Euthymios asks—regarding the position that uncondemned
heretics are still as putrid members within the Church and that their Mysteries
are valid]. Because first and foremost it comes into contradiction with Holy
Scripture. Whatever contradicts Holy Scripture is wrong. Not because the
Fathers said something wrong, but because we interpret the Fathers wrongly.”
The position that
whatever comes into contradiction with Holy Scripture is wrong is undoubtedly
correct. The issue is to prove that this position regarding invalid Mysteries
is in contradiction with Holy Scripture; and unfortunately, Fr. Euthymios takes
as a given that which he must prove; and at no point in his homily does he
prove it. It is entirely his own interpretation, which no contemporary Saint or
theologian has expressed or allowed to be implied—certainly not any Saint of
past ages either.
I will mention two
or three scriptural passages and their interpretations, which show that in Holy
Scripture there are also passages that must be considered together with those
that Fr. Euthymios has in mind, so that the spirit of Holy Scripture may be understood
in its full scope. Then, I think, the proofs upon which the above position is
based take on different dimensions and, in any case, show that Holy Scripture
does not lack expressions that allow it to be understood that even the
not-yet-condemned heretics are members of the Church, albeit decayed–rotten
ones. Patristic sources will also follow that demonstrate that the view which
is often heard—that many (including Fr. Euthymios) regard as wrong the position
that the Church is the field of the Gospel with the tares and that they claim
the field refers only to the world—is a mistaken and unpatristic view (compare
also Euthymios Zigabenos, Commentary on the One Hundred and Fifty Psalms of
the Prophet-King and God-Father David, pp. 336–337).
In the New
Testament, there is the parable of the Kingdom of Heaven as a net that gathered
all kinds of fish, both good and useless (Matt. 13:49–52); and as a field with
wheat, but also with tares (Matt. 13:24). The two parables resemble each other.
I quote the interpretation of St. John Chrysostom on the parable of the tares:
"In
the parable of the Sower, Christ did not speak to us about tares, but here He
does. What are these tares? — They are the heretics, who at first accepted the
seed of the Gospel, but later became corrupters and instruments of the devil.
It is astonishing how Christ explains to us the timing of the heretics'
activity: 'while men slept.' Error follows truth. After the prophets came the
false prophets, after the apostles the false apostles, and after Christ the
Antichrist. But what is the difference between the seed that fell by the
wayside and the tares? The former was immediately snatched away, while in this
case it took root (i.e., within the Church), and in order to be uprooted,
intrigues are required. Therefore, Christ tells us all this so that we may never
be complacent, but always remain vigilant. Now notice the care and diligence of
the farmers (i.e., the shepherds of the Church): After they saw the tares, they
immediately wanted to uproot them. But first, they asked the Lord: 'Do you will
it?' They did not act on their own initiative. But He refused. Why? Because
Christ does not desire wars and bloodshed. Besides, along with the heretics,
many Orthodox might have been slain, or perhaps some — who until then belonged
to the faction of the tares — might have eventually turned into wheat."
The following
passage is important (On the Gospel of Matthew 46, 2; PG 58, 477):
“If,
then, by forestalling them you uproot them, you injure the grain that is going
to become wheat, destroying those whom it is possible to change and to become
better. He therefore does not forbid holding back heretics, silencing them,
cutting off their freedom of speech, and dissolving their assemblies and
gatherings, but [He forbids] eliminating and slaughtering them.”
The ever-memorable
Fr. Georgios Kapsanis writes on this matter:
“Indeed,
heresies are the tares that the Evil One sows in the field of the Church in
order to thwart the salvation of human beings. In the Church’s struggle against
heresies, the contribution of monasticism has been significant.”
The same is stated
by St. Cyril of Alexandria, in his explanation of “I am the true shepherd” and
the parable of the vine (Cyril of Alexandria, Commentary or Exposition on
the Gospel according to John, P.G. 74). Further on, and more specifically
in the third part of the study, we will see that St. Basil the Great teaches
the same. Moreover, the Encyclical Reply of the Council in Constantinople of
1895 to Pope Leo XIII states among other things the following:
“Every
pious and Orthodox soul, sincerely zealous for the glory of God, is deeply
grieved and overcome with great sorrow when seeing that the hater of good and
murderer of man from the beginning, driven by envy at the salvation of mankind,
does not cease at every turn to sow various tares in the field of the Lord, so
as to obscure the wheat. Hence, from the beginning, heretical tares have sprung
up in the Church of God, which in many ways have ravaged and continue to ravage
the salvation in Christ of the human race, and which, as evil seeds and decayed
members, are justly cut off from the healthy body of the Orthodox Catholic
Church of Christ.”
Isaiah 5:4: “What
shall I yet do to My vineyard that I have not done to it? For I looked for it
to bring forth grapes, but it brought forth thorns.” (What remains for Me to do
more for this vineyard, and what have I not done for it until now? I did everything
so that it might bear grapes. But it brought forth thorns!) This saying,
according to the Fathers, does not refer only to the Jews but also to
Christians who deviate from the Faith. This fact was often emphasized in his
sermons by the ever-memorable Fr. Athanasios Mitilinaios.
Saint Ignatius the
God-bearer warns:
“Wherever
the shepherd is, there you should follow as sheep; for many wolves in sheep’s
clothing take captive those who are running toward God by means of evil
pleasure. But in your unity they shall find no place. Therefore, keep away from
the evil herbs, which Jesus Christ does not cultivate, but the man-killing
beast does, because they are not the planting of the Father, but the seed of
the evil one.” (Ignatius of Antioch, To the Philadelphians, TLG, Epistle
6, chapter 2, section 1, line 1)
The tares, that is,
“the evil herbs,” are the sowing of the evil one. Until their cutting off from
the Church, they may remain members—members, however, from whom good
Christians, the wheat, must distance themselves so as not to be corrupted
(“evil communications corrupt good manners,” 1 Corinthians 15:33), not to be
defiled, not to be choked by their teaching.
It is important to
note that the same is evident in the Lord’s letters to the Churches of Asia
Minor in the Book of Revelation. The Lord addresses the bishops of the
Churches—even though they do not do everything according to His commandments
(except for those of Smyrna and Philadelphia) and allow within their ranks the
growth of tares/heretics, mainly Nicolaitans and false prophets (the last of
the seven, the bishop of Laodicea, has entirely strayed from the true
teaching)—as “angels,” and He nevertheless grants them a time for repentance,
on the condition that they will correct themselves and uproot from the field
the tares that have grown. Therefore, they were still, for the Lord(!!!),
within the Church; the Lord gave them time to remain in His body, but in the
end, He removed their lampstands, and they perished (cf. also the related
homily of Fr. Athanasios Mitilinaios, Interpretation of Revelation).
But also according
to the holy Dositheus of Jerusalem (Dodecabiblos), “a heresy that
arises, if it spreads, is judged and condemned by the Ecumenical Council,”
which is “greater than the Local Councils” and is “the ultimate tribunal of the
entire Church” (Dodecabiblos, book 4, chapter 10, §3, pp. 456–457, and
book 3, chapter 15, §19, p. 171). The Saint clearly says that Councils set
forth the Orthodox teaching and called the heretics to repentance. In the case
of the heretics’ persistence in their views, the Fathers condemned them and cut
them off from the body of the Church in order that “the Church of God might
remain pure, having nothing mingled with her of tares.”
In the Tome of
Joy (1705, p. 42) by the same author, we read from the Acts of the Council
of 879/880 under Photios the Great: “First, we are to admonish them and exhort
them, and if they are not willing to obey us, then we are to cut them off as
putrefied members, so that the healthy body is not also destroyed through
them.”
The following
passage from the Acts of the 4th Session of the Seventh Ecumenical Council is
also characteristic. There it is said that the holy Fathers fulfill the word of
Christ, namely, to place the lamp of divine knowledge “upon the lampstand” so
that it may shine upon all those who are in the house and not hide it “under
the bushel.” In this way, those who confess the Lord with piety are helped to
walk the path of salvation without stumbling. The holy Fathers
“drive
away every heretical delusion, and if the putrefied member happens to be
incurably diseased, they cut it off, and, holding the winnowing fan, they
cleanse the threshing floor and store the wheat — that is, the nourishing word
that strengthens the heart of man — in the storehouse of the Catholic Church,
but the chaff of heretical false doctrine, having cast it outside, they burn
with unquenchable fire.”
How then, according
to Fr. Euthymios, are there no tares and decayed members in the Church—that is,
uncondemned heretics—who must be cut off? Has the Church ceased to be undefiled
because of their existence? Did the Fathers of the Seventh [Ecumenical Council]
perhaps question Her undefiled character by accepting their existence? Of
course not!
I also quote a
libellus addressed to Patriarch Menas. In it, the monks thank the Patriarch (as
well as Emperor Justinian) because they proceeded with the examination of the
case of the heretical Patriarch Anthimos and, since he was “disobedient,” they
condemned him. We also thank, they write, God, because through the Council He
was pleased “to cleanse His Church and to present it to Himself, as always,
glorious, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing of heretical tares”
(T.L.G., Concilia Oecumenica (ACO): Synodus Constantinopolitana et
Hierosolymitana anno 536: Tome 3, page 38, line 31).
Therefore, the
Council cleanses the Church from the decayed members, the heretics, without Her
ever losing Her undefiled character, even though some of Her members disobeyed
and apostatized. The 13th Canon of the First-Second Council writes:
“The
utterly evil one, having sown the tares of heretics in the Church of Christ,
and seeing these being cut out from the root by the sword of the Spirit, turned
to another method, attempting to divide the Body of Christ through the madness
of schismatics.” (Pedalion, Canon 13 of the First-Second Council, ed. V.
Rigopoulos, Thessaloniki 2003, p. 357).
The Canon tells us
that one method of the evil one is the sowing of tares in the field of the
Church, with the aim of thwarting the salvation of the faithful. But when the
tares are cut off with the sword of the Spirit, which is expressed through the
councils, then the devil resorts to other methods.
The above—that is,
that only the council has the right to cut off the tares, the branches, the
decayed members, and that until their cutting off they are considered members
of the Church—is summed up by St. Nektarios, while at the same time emphasizing
the duty of the shepherds. A duty which today has ended up as a subject of
lectures, literary discussions, and press releases devoid of substance:
"The
shepherd is obliged to protect his sheep from the mouths of wolves; when they
wander away from the fold, he must arduously run after them to bring them back.
If one is lost, he must enter into the forests and groves, climb mountains and
hills, tread upon thorns and brambles to find it; and when he finds it,
joyfully and gladly place it upon his shoulders, bringing it back to the flock
together with the others. He is obliged to guide the entire flock to saving
pastures, keeping it far away from the poisonous plants [i.e., weeds] of
heresy, away from the muddy waters of false doctrine. In this way, he guides
the flock, urging the sheep forward or calling them back, encouraging or
deterring, moving or comforting, threatening or charming, with the spiritual
flute of salvific teaching, which must never be absent from his mouth. It is
therefore evident that such shepherding becomes even more difficult and painful
where unhealthy and foul waters abound, or poisonous and harmful plants
flourish, or ravines are steep, wooded, and wild, or wolves and other
bloodthirsty, ravenous beasts lurk... When neither these nor those methods
help, what remains is the abandonment and despair over the stubborn one, and
finally the turning away and withdrawal from him as from one who is impure and
profane, cutting him off from the body of the Church as a member already dead
and decaying, so that he does not spread contagion and corruption to the
remaining healthy members."
(from
Vlassia D. Kaskanioti, Church, Schism, and Heresy according to Saint
Nektarios, doctoral dissertation, Thessaloniki, 2015.)
And St. Cyril of
Jerusalem in his Fourth Catechetical Lecture writes, among other things:
"Wickedness
imitates virtue, and the tare endeavors to be thought wheat; in form, indeed,
it resembles the wheat, but by taste it is exposed by those who have
discernment. And the Devil transforms himself into an angel of light, not in
order to return to where he once was—for having acquired a heart like an anvil,
he now has an unrepentant will—but in order to surround with the darkness of
blindness and the plague-bearing condition of unbelief those who conduct a life
equal to the angels. Many wolves wander about in sheep's clothing, possessing
indeed the garments of sheep, but not their claws and teeth; but having clothed
themselves in a gentle skin and deceiving the guileless by appearance, they
pour forth the destructive poison of impiety from their teeth. Therefore, we
have need of divine grace, of a sober mind, and of watchful eyes: lest eating
the tare as if it were wheat, we be harmed out of ignorance; lest taking the
wolf for a sheep, we be hunted; lest mistaking the destructive Devil for a good
angel, we be swallowed up. For he goes about as a roaring lion, seeking whom he
may devour, according to the Scripture. For this reason the Church admonishes,
for this reason the present teachings take place, for this reason the readings
are done… and having founded a single heresy full of blasphemies and every
lawlessness, he ravages the Church."
All the above
scriptural examples and the patristic interpretations of the Fathers speak of
heretics/those advocating heresy as tares and as decayed members within the
Church, however this may be understood. Therefore, contrary to what Fr.
Euthymios supported in his homily, there are scriptural passages which imply
that heretics, until their condemnation, are indeed decayed members, yet
nonetheless members of the Church; and consequently, those who support this
view are not opposing Holy Scripture. And these are not arbitrary personal
conclusions of mine, but interpretations of Saints and enlightened elders and
theologians.
I conclude with one
more addition. With this, I believe it will become clear that until the
convocation of a Council, the Church has tares/heretics in her ranks. Her
undefiled and all-pure character is shown in the fact that she does not accept,
and condemns, their false teachings and ultimately, through a Synod, uproots
them from the field of the Lord, casting them outside of Herself. I present
these without commentary, because they speak for themselves.
Zygabenos [+1120]
writes:
"Just
as the tares resemble the wheat in the stalk, but differ in the fruit—and they
are harmful to the wheat—so also the heretics resemble the Orthodox in outward
appearance, but differ in virtue, which is the fruit. And virtue and fruit,
above all, is the truth of the dogmas. And just as the tares grow up together
unnoticed until the time of fruit-bearing, and then are recognized, so also the
heretics, until they begin to teach, live unnoticed together with the others.
But when they gain great boldness, then they pour out their poison and are
recognized. Therefore, He said beforehand: 'By their fruits you shall know
them.' And furthermore, when Christ was sowing, the heretics did not appear;
but when the Orthodox grew, then they appeared."
(Euthymios
Zigabenos, Commentary on the Four Gospels, vol. 1, part 1, ch. 13:26)
And again,
Chrysostom shows us the Church’s teaching concerning the tares and the
necessity of a synod that will judge and cleanse the field of the Lord—that is,
the Church, not the world in general ("Discourse on False Prophets and
False Teachers and Godless Heretics..."):
“But
let us return to the subject at hand; for the discourse concerns the end times,
and about false prophets, and false teachers, and about godless heretics, who
have flooded everywhere like torrents and are leading many astray. And how has
this come to pass? Clearly, from the ignorance and inexperience of the leaders;
for where there is inexperience of shepherds, there the sheep are lost. What
then shall I say first...
Nevertheless,
for the present it is necessary to demonstrate from the Holy Scriptures that
these men are enemies of Christ and wolves of His flock, driven about
everywhere and cast out from the sheep of Christ. For this reason, they have
rightly been called wolves by the prophets, by the Master Himself, and by the
blessed Apostles; and not only wolves, but also pestilent, ungodly,
adversaries, enemies, plotters, blasphemers, hypocrites, thieves, robbers,
abominable, false prophets, false teachers, blind guides, deceivers, evil men,
antichrists, scandals, sons of the evil one, tares, and atheists… Jude, the
brother of James, said: “Certain men have crept in secretly, who were long ago
written about for this condemnation, ungodly men, turning the grace of our God
into licentiousness, and denying the only Master and Lord, Jesus Christ.” And
again he says: “In the last times there will be mockers, walking according to
their own ungodly desires.” These are they who feed themselves without fear,
waterless clouds carried about by every wind, wandering stars, for whom the
blackness of darkness has been reserved forever. These and more than these does
the excellent Jude exhort us.
Come
then, Paul, vessel of election, tell us also, according to the grace given to
you by God—tell us about this present evil age; reveal the hidden wolves,
triumph over and expose the thieves of the holy flock of God. Paul said: I know
that after my departure grievous wolves will enter in among you, not sparing
the flock.
Do
you see everywhere the theologians agreeing with the Teacher concerning the
ungodly heretics, calling them dogs and wolves? As Paul also says elsewhere: Beware
of dogs, beware of evil workers, beware of the concision... Do not receive
a heretical man after the first and second admonition; and again: Be not
carried about with various and strange doctrines...
And
do not be amazed if the shepherds become wolves. For to bishops and presbyters
the Apostle Paul, speaking, said: From among your own selves shall men
arise, speaking perverse things. So let no one deceive you, having an
angelic appearance outwardly, but inwardly demonic. For this reason Jesus said:
See that no one deceives you. And I likewise say the same: see that no
one deceives you—neither from within nor from without—whether bishop,
presbyter, deacon, reader, or whoever might be, if he speaks perverse things.
These are they who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are
ravenous wolves—who have a form of godliness, but deny the power thereof. But
you, beloved, do not be led astray, but as you have received our Lord Jesus
Christ, so walk in Him; and the God of peace shall be with you.
Who
will have an excuse of negligence, having heard so many commandments? And
elsewhere again: Do not receive a heretical man after a first and second
admonition; and Heretical men will proceed to worse, deceiving and being
deceived... Hear again, you who make love-feasts (i.e., Sunday meals within
the Church) with them: how will you flee from the wrath that is coming upon
you, who are defiled by these men in food and in drink? How do you dare to
approach the divine and fearful Mysteries of Christ? And the Prophet David
(says): There is no truth in their mouth... And Isaiah the
prophet—rather, the Lord through the prophet—says: There is no peace for the
ungodly, says the Lord.
And
the philanthropic God… inclined the heavens and came down, and arranged all
things for the salvation of our race, and showed everything by doing and
teaching. Then, wishing to teach how those who are going to preside over the
Churches should drive out the heretics, He made a scourge of cords, and
entering in, cast them all out of the temple, and thrust them away, and
expelled them...
Hear
this, you who preside over the Churches. For to you He showed the good example,
that you might follow in His footsteps, paying close attention in all things
and driving out the wolves and guarding the flock. And after Him… the holy
synods held from time to time, having uprooted those who remained unrepentant,
handed them over to destruction, according to what is written: You will
destroy all who speak falsehood…"
And St. Theodore
the Studite agrees with Chrysostom, both regarding the weeds/heresies and the
necessity of a council to expel them:
“For
the meaning of having neither spot nor wrinkle, to say it once more, should be
understood as not accepting impious dogmas and unlawful undertakings. And not
only these, but also the forbidden mindsets held by those who perpetrate them,
as the divine Basil says somewhere; to such people the great Paul does not even
permit us to share a meal. Since from the time of the Apostles and thereafter,
many heresies have been grafted onto her in various ways, and unlawful and
irregular pollutions have prevailed, just as now; nevertheless, she has
remained and will remain, in the aforementioned manner, undivided and without
blemish unto the ages, by removing and expelling from herself all who think or
act wickedly—just as waves crashing upon a firm and coastal rock are cast off.”
(Fat. 28, 79, 123 – P.G. 99, 1001/04).
St. Theodore
therefore confirms that heretics are removed and expelled from the Church. Not,
of course, by themselves, but synodally. It is also well known that the Saint
is grounded in the teaching of St. Basil the Great.
“The
so-called darnel, and all other spurious seeds mixed in with the nourishing
ones, which the Scripture customarily calls tares, do not arise from a
transformation of the wheat, but came forth from their own origin, having a
distinct nature. These fulfill the image of those who corrupt the teachings of
the Lord and do not genuinely become disciples of the word, but, having been
corrupted by the teaching of the evil one, mingle themselves with the healthy
body of the Church in order to secretly inflict harm upon the more sound
members through their own deceptions.” (PG 29, 114)
(End
of Part 1)
And apart from the
subject of the Tares: Where does St. Basil the Great speak of invalid Mysteries
of the not-yet-condemned heretics? Let us look at the following passages, where
it is evident that he considers the heretics to be within the Church (who, of
course, must be neutralized by the right-believing faithful) and as tares; and
he also appears to make a distinction between those who are ignorant—as weaker
believers—and the conscious Pneumatomachians (a significant distinction for the
present condition of the faithful).
St. Basil the
Great, Epistle 113:
“In
this way, the condition of the Church generally resembles a ‘worn-out garment’
which is torn with the slightest cause and is impossible to restore to its
original state. Under such circumstances, great zeal and lively concern are
certainly required, so that the Churches may reap some benefit. And benefit is
that those who have been divided until now be united. But union could take
place only if we are willing to treat the weaker ones in such a way as not to
harm souls at all.
Since
then many mouths have been opened against the Holy Spirit and many tongues have
been sharpened in blasphemies against Him, I require—as far as it depends on
you—that you limit the blasphemers to a small number and receive into communion
only those who do not call the Holy Spirit a creature. In this way, the
blasphemers will be isolated, and either they will be forced by shame to return
to the truth or, if they persist in sin, they will become, on account of their
small number, unworthy of trust… Those who call (the Holy Spirit) a creature
must not be received into communion."
St. Basil the
Great, Epistle 114:
"Receive
the Symbol of Faith," and "to this confession of Faith add also that
the Holy Spirit must not be called a creature, and that there must absolutely
be no communion with those who call Him a creature, so that the Church of God
may remain pure and have no weeds (*) mixed within it."
"...That
you confess the faith set forth by our Fathers who once assembled in Nicaea…
and that the Holy Spirit must not be called a creature, and moreover, that
there must be no communion with those who say such things, in order that the
Church of God may be pure, having no weed mixed with itself."
(*)
Weeds are the heretics.
Consequently,
heretics are not, according to St. Basil the Great, “brothers” with a different
understanding of the one Gospel, but “seed of the Devil” (cf. Matt. 13:24–30).
(Commentary and interpretation by the late Nikodimos Bilalis, vol. 4, pp.
24–28).
It is absolutely
clear that the Church, according to St. Basil the Great, resembled in his time
an old garment and had weeds within Her ranks. Nevertheless, She remained
undefiled and pure, since there were those who resisted and remained in the
Truth.
I believe it has
been clearly demonstrated that both in Holy Scripture and in its interpretation
by the Fathers there are passages that explain why and how God permits the
existence of uncondemned heretics/weeds/rotten members in the all-holy body of
the Church until their conciliar removal from it.
I will now begin
the examination of the book on walling off according to Saint Theodore the
Studite (The Confrontation of the Heresy of Ecumenism according to Saint
Theodore the Studite: the Cessation of Commemoration).
I have divided the
examination and the positions of the book into three thematic sections:
a) Concerning
invalid Mysteries
b) Concerning
uncondemned and condemned heretics, and concerning the Synod
c) Concerning
the question of whether the Ecumenists, until their condemnation, are within
the Church, and concerning ecclesiology.
Before presenting
the points of the book under examination in each chapter, I will first present
patristic positions, so that the examination may be understood.
a)
Concerning invalid Mysteries
I again quote a
passage from the homily of 10 Nov 2019, which naturally also expresses what Fr.
Euthymios expresses in his book:
"Basic
theological–ecclesiological positions of Saint Theodore the Studite, about
which we today have objections. That is why we must transfer everything to our
own time. We today have objections concerning the theological and
ecclesiological positions of the Saint, despite the fact that, as I said, these
were the positions of all the confessing Fathers of that period (at 32:05). He
would say regarding the heretics of his time—the adulterers and the
Iconoclasts—who in his day had not yet been condemned. When Saint Theodore fell
asleep, the restoration of the Holy Icons had not yet taken place. The heresy
still existed when he reposed—there were still Iconoclast Patriarchs. He would
say, then, that the Mysteries of the heretics are invalid. And he said this in
many letters, and he aptly characterized them with many epithets, and he even
called them demonic."
It must be pointed
out here that I discern that the position of Saint Theodore (if we assume that
we accept Fr. Euthymios’s interpretation) is not identical with the position of
Fr. Euthymios. That is, if we accept the position that, according to Saint Theodore
the Studite, the Mysteries are invalid, Fr. Euthymios teaches that—due to the
circumstances of the times—they are valid by Economy. This economy,
however, was neither taught by the Saint nor does it have any basis as a
position. For the question remains unanswered: If indeed the Mysteries of the
Ecumenists are invalid because they are outside the Church—since the Church,
being undefiled, cannot contain heretics—then
a) we may apply economy,
but we can never alter ecclesiology, and
b) if we consider
them valid by Economy, are we not thereby reintroducing the heretics into Her
and rendering Her defiled?
And if we do this,
what examples do we have in our ecclesiastical Tradition, and by what authority
do we do so—according to what St. Justin Popović says must happen, namely:
“through the visible operation of the God-manly authority of the Church (i.e.,
the Councils), or through the invisible Judgment of God”? Neither has a Council
taken place, nor do I believe we are within the invisible judgment of God.
I extend the above
question with two additional sources. St. John Chrysostom, in his
interpretation of the Apostle on the Sunday after Theophany, says: “For there
are two ways of being cut off from the body of the Church: one is when we grow
cold in love, and the second, when we dare to do things that are unworthy to be
done in that body; for by both of these ways we separate ourselves from the
body of the Church.” Therefore, according to the Saint, not only heretics, but
also all kinds of sinners and those who do not love Christ and do not live in
Christ do not constitute members of the Church. Fr. Athanasios Mitilinaios
calls such people forerunners or expressions of apostasy. Do they have
Mysteries? Do priests and bishops who received ordination through simony,
homosexual clergy, Christ-traders, profiteers, fornicators, etc.—who, like
heretics according to St. Chrysostom and also according to the Apostle Paul,
are not truly members of the body of the Church—have Mysteries? If not, then we
are all condemned, for such individuals existed and unfortunately still exist.
If yes, then not being a member of the Church—because I trample on the law of
God—does not mean that I cease to have Mysteries until I am condemned.
The above is also
proven by St. Justin Popovich, whose theology no one can dispute, when he wrote
to the Holy Synod of Serbia in the 1970s that we cannot claim to be members of
Christ while belonging to the W.C.C. (World Council of Churches). He writes: “As
Orthodox, we are ‘members of Christ.’ ‘Shall I then take the members of Christ,
and make them members of a harlot? God forbid!’” Nowhere in his books is there
even a single passage in which the Saint and great theologian Justin—who also
knew well St. Theodore the Studite (and although he says that as members of the
W.C.C. we are not members of Christ)—declares the Mysteries of the Ecumenists
to be invalid. If the Saint is wrong and the Mysteries are invalid, then they
must have been invalid since 1970, when those words were written, or even
earlier—and we are not even Christians, but unbaptized, unordained, unmarried,
etc. Was Chrysostomos of Smyrna, who was a heretic and a Freemason, invalid in
his Mysteries? If yes, why is that not clearly written in the relevant book by
Fr. Euthymios? And if not, why should there now be a change of position? If
anyone claims that at that time no faithful had walled themselves off, then
ecclesiologically the Mysteries ceased to function with the power of the Holy
Spirit, and therefore function demonically? Thus, it becomes clear that Fr.
Euthymios invokes ecclesiology at will and forgets it when it does not agree
with his conclusions—which he alone draws from the study of St. Theodore.
Unfortunately, it did not trouble him at all that none of the other Saints and
theologian-students of the Saint reached his conclusions concerning the
Mysteries—whether invalid or valid by oikonomia. This will become evident
below.
St. Anastasios of
Sinai, in his 20th Response, writes concerning the energy of the Holy Spirit
even among heretics:
“Various
signs and wonders and prophecies often occur also through unworthy individuals,
according to some necessity or oikonomia, as happened with Balaam and the
ventriloquist. And elsewhere, when the Apostles found a certain unbeliever ‘who
was casting out demons in the name of Christ,’ and they prevented him and
reported it to Christ, Christ said to them: ‘Do not forbid him, for whoever is
not against you is for you.’ Therefore, when you see a miracle being performed
even by heretics and by unbelievers, do not be astonished nor be moved away
from the Orthodox faith. For many times, the one who works the miracle is the
faith of the one who approaches, and not the worthiness of the one performing
it. After all, John, the greatest among those born of women, does not appear to
have performed a miracle, whereas Judas certainly did, since he was among those
who were sent to raise the dead and heal lepers.”
And St. Athanasius
the Great agrees. They once asked the Great Athanasius, “How is it that some
heretics often perform signs?” And the great Father answered as follows:
“This
should not astonish us. For we have heard the Lord saying, ‘Many will say to Me
on that day: “Lord, did we not cast out demons in Your name, and do many mighty
works in Your name?”’ And He will say to them, ‘Truly I say to you, I never
knew you; depart from Me, you workers of lawlessness.’ For often it is not the
way of life of the one working wonders that brings about the healing, but the
faith of the person who comes to him. For it is written, ‘Your faith has saved
you.’ Yet this also must be known, that many times some who are of ill faith
have offered many labors to God through asceticism, and they have received
their reward in this present age from God — the gift of healings and of
prophecies — in order that in the age to come they may hear, ‘You have received
your good things and your labors; now nothing is owed to you’” (P.G. 28, 665).
Does the Holy
Spirit perform demonic actions in the above examples, according to the Saints?
Of course not.
Specifically,
regarding the matter of Holy Communion (the other Mysteries will be discussed
alongside the examination of the positions), it appears that the terminology of
the Saint, as presented in the books of Fr. Euthymios, agrees with the double
nature of valid Holy Communion, which enlightens those who partake worthily and
condemns those who partake unworthily—and not with the position of invalid
Mysteries, which, being invalid, neither condemn nor enlighten:
“So
then, whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will be
guilty of the body and blood of the Lord. But let a man examine himself, and so
let him eat of the bread and drink of the cup; for he who eats and drinks
unworthily eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord’s
body.” (Apostle Paul, 1 Corinthians 11:28–29).
Paradoxically, Fr.
Euthymios himself used the same argument as I do in an earlier homily, which he
now appears to have silently renounced:
“The
same is implied by the Apostle Paul when he speaks about the evil disposition
with which we approach the Mystery: ‘Let a man examine himself, and so let him
eat of the bread and drink of the cup; for he who eats and drinks unworthily
eats and drinks judgment to himself, not discerning the Lord’s body’ (1
Corinthians 11:28–29).”
http://www.paterikiparadosi.blogspot.gr/2014/09/blog-post_18.html#more
And:
“Therefore,
always when we speak about the defilement of the Holy Things, we mean our own
profane participation and guilty disposition, and not the Holy Things
themselves, as if they are defiled or polluted in the essential sense, such
that this defilement is transmitted to all who partake, even if they disagree
or have an Orthodox mindset.”
http://www.paterikiparadosi.blogspot.gr/2014/09/blog-post_18.html#more
When and why did
Fr. Euthymios change his mind?
In the service of
Holy Communion we entreat God:
“Grant
me, the wretched one, to partake of Thy spotless and dread Mysteries, O Master,
not unto condemnation… For if I dare to approach Thee with those who are
worthy, the garment reproves me, for it is not of the Supper, and I shall cause
condemnation for my much-sinning soul… And let not the communion of Thine
immaculate and life-giving Mysteries be unto me for judgment, nor may I become
weak in soul and body, from partaking of them unworthily… not unto damnation,
not unto an addition of sins… And vouchsafe me, until my last breath, to
receive without condemnation the sanctification of Thy spotless Mysteries.”
The holy Chrysostom
writes:
“The
easiest way for the devil to take hold of the Christian is his unworthy
participation in Holy Communion. Not, of course, that such a Christian becomes
demon-possessed (hypostatically), but he becomes like the devil: proud,
disobedient, envious, insensitive, indifferent to his salvation. Judas partook
in the Mystical Supper unworthily and, departing from there, betrayed the Lord,
so that you may learn that the devil always especially enters into those who
partake unworthily of the Holy Eucharist and thus render themselves worthy of
greater punishment. I do not say these things to frighten you, but to make you
more secure. For just as bodily food, when it enters a stomach with harmful
fluids, worsens the illness, so also spiritual food, when one partakes of it
unworthily, brings greater condemnation upon him. Thus, he who eats and drinks
unworthily of Holy Communion eats and drinks judgment unto himself.”
(Eléni
Papadopoúlou, The Mystery of the Holy Eucharist according to the teaching of
Saint Chrysostom, a liturgical and theological approach, 2015)
And Saint Innocent
of Moscow:
"Whoever
partakes of the Body and Blood of the Lord unworthily, with an impure soul...
not only does not receive the Holy Spirit, but becomes a traitor, like Judas,
and crucifies Christ once again..."
And Saint John of
Kronstadt:
"When
Holy Communion enters a soul full of evil, then it is the soul that
self-destructs and is condemned all the more—not because the Holy Gifts cause
this by their nature, but because of the illness and wickedness of the soul
that receives them. Whoever communes unworthily, without sincere repentance and
unwavering faith, becomes a plaything of Satan."
And Saint
Theophylact of Ohrid (Works 192, 27):
"The
Body of Christ is distinct from participation in It… he who receives unworthily
becomes the cause of many evils."
We read:
"Unworthiness
regarding participation in the mystery of the Divine Eucharist renders the
mystery a slaughter rather than a sacrifice, and condemns those who approach
it, instead of sanctifying them—just like the ungrateful servant in the
parable, like those who did not receive the God-man with faith when He
condescended to become incarnate, and like those who crucified Him and pierced
Him and shed His Blood, not to partake of it, but to reject it. The comparison
of those who approach the Holy Gifts unworthily with the crucifiers of Christ
and with Judas is frequent. When we commune without being worthy, 'we perish in
the same way as the murderers of Christ' (On the Gospel of John, Homily
47, PG 59, 268. See also On the apostolic saying: ‘For there must also be
heresies among you, that they which are approved may be made manifest among
you’, PG 51, 249). So that this comparison does not appear excessive to
many, and the likeness in punishment unbearable, the great rhetorician of the
Church explains using the example of the royal purple: whoever either defiles
or tears it is considered to have committed an insult against the king who
wears it; in the same way, those who 'defile' the Body and Blood of the Master
Christ, receiving it into their defiled soul, commit an outrage equivalent to
that of those who 'tore' and killed the Lord upon the Cross."
("The
Mystery of the Divine Eucharist according to the teaching of Saint John
Chrysostom")
For all the
Fathers, unworthy is not only the sinner but also the heretic. Therefore, the
Divine Communion of the Ecumenists, as long as they institutionally remain
within the Church, is valid, but it brings defilement and condemnation upon
those who commune from them, knowing that they are heretics (we have seen this
in the letters of Saint Metropolitan Cyril of Kazan, it is stated repeatedly by
the Fathers, and it will be shown further below in the texts), and for this
reason, the Orthodox must avoid it.
Here I will also
express another thought that requires careful study. Saint Justin Popovich
clearly uses the expressions of Saint Theodore — concerning communion with
heretics — referring to the condemned heretics, the Papists and Protestants,
and not to the Ecumenists. So perhaps the question was not examined in detail
as to when exactly the letters of Saint Theodore were written regarding Divine
Communion with heretics. Perhaps the Saint is referring — if our interpretation
is mistaken — to the post-Seventh Ecumenical Council condemned heretics, the
Iconoclasts, in which case their mysteries are indeed invalid, since after
their conciliar condemnation they are no longer members of the Church?
(Although the issue becomes more complicated, since another council, the
Council of 815 — heterodox according to the Orthodox — decided differently,
causing confusion among the faithful).
The above is
demonstrated in the book, although a misunderstanding of certain terms becomes
evident. On page 24 we read:
“Regarding
the Mysteries of the heretics, the Saint taught that not only do they not
impart any grace, but on the contrary they cause darkness and damnation… and
even the mere commemoration of the heretical bishop renders the mystery defiled
and powerless to transmit any benefit to the participants, even if the
officiating priest holds an Orthodox mindset.”
Here it becomes
clear that this is not about an invalid mystery, but rather a mystery through
which the faithful is defiled due to heresy. The effects of Communion from
heretics — “defiled mystery and powerless to transmit benefit” — are identical
to those described in the Prayer of Holy Communion and by St. John of Kronstadt
— “he is self-destroyed and condemned,” who, however, clarifies: “not that the
Holy Gifts themselves cause this by their nature.” Thus, the Mystery is not
invalid, but also the expression “defiled mystery” is not accurate, as St. John
of Kronstadt makes clear in agreement with the Holy Fathers.
On page 73, Fr.
Euthymios writes: “However, in regard to the time at which the cessation of
commemoration of the heretical bishop must take place, it is perhaps necessary,
in some cases, that an economy be initially employed.”
This is a correct
position—but only for those who accept the validity of the Mysteries of
ecumenists not yet condemned by a council, since all the Saints made use of economy,
some for a longer, others for a shorter time, without of course questioning the
Mysteries.
However, for
someone who considers the Mysteries invalid, this position is problematic,
contains a contradiction, and essentially negates itself, since it makes the
validity or invalidity of the Mysteries depend, according to Fr. Euthymios, on
whether someone has walled themselves off or not—on each person’s will to apply
economy or follow exactitude—and creates contentions among the ranks of
the opposing faithful, since both those who follow economy and those who
follow exactitude claim to be acting in accordance with the Holy Fathers. And
naturally the question arises: if the Mysteries during the period of economy
are invalid, then how can it be that some follow exactitude and others economy?
And who determines the chronological limits of validity? And how many must be
walled off for the Mysteries to be considered invalid? A few hundred, as is the
case today, or a few thousand, with bishops, archimandrites, abbots, monks, and
thousands of faithful, as was the case then?
And if, for
example, Fr. Theodoros Zisis had walled himself off in Thessaloniki in February
with a large number of faithful, and then a month later (in March) Fr.
Euthymios walled himself off in Volos for his own reasons, and in April Fr.
Maximos walled himself off in Ptolemaida, and in May a certain priest walled
himself off in Germany for his own reasons, then those who communed after
February—did they receive valid or invalid Mysteries? And how could they have
walled themselves off if until that moment they were receiving and celebrating
invalid Mysteries, without Grace?
The above may
concern a hypothetical scenario, but I believe it highlights the essence of the
erroneous position of the supporters of invalid Mysteries, as well as of those
who speak of “valid by Economy.”
Because on page 79
we read:
“Thus,
naturally, as soon as the distancing of the Orthodox takes place and separation
and walling off occurs, those persisting in heretical teaching are regarded as
heretics and consequently cut off from the diachronic Church. Before this
separation takes place, those who hold heretical views are not considered
outside the Church (that is, the Mysteries performed by them are valid by
Economy), even if there is resistance on the part of the Orthodox… conversely,
those who react in this way are not considered outside of heresy, so long as
they have ecclesiastical communion with the heretical bishops.”
I have been
informed that in the past Fr. Euthymios used to say that there must be a
Synaxis of the walled-off, which would decide such matters, and that it is not
enough for a few isolated walled-off individuals to make such major decisions.
Has such a Synaxis taken place today? Have such decisions been made? Since we
all know that it has not, how is the teaching “valid by Economy” justified (as
the only truly patristic teaching, in fact, and how is the denigration of those
who do not accept it justified, since they are supposedly in opposition to Holy
Scripture and are ‘murderers of the truth’!) and its practical application by a
single priest?
However, the
following reasonable questions also arise: If things stand this way, then St
Tarasius and St Nicephorus ought—from the moment when the Saint walled himself
off from them—to have possessed invalid Mysteries, since, by economy,
they continued to commune with the heresy. The answer to the above question is
found on p. 167, though it seems to have been forgotten in the lecture of 10
Nov 2019: “That is, there is a merely outward separation, yet a deeper union
with regard to intention, purpose, and love for the Church and the salvation of
souls.” Therefore, intention and love for the Church play an immense role, and
consequently someone who possesses such sentiments cannot have invalid
Mysteries simply because he did not wall himself off.
The above is also
demonstrated in the letters of the Saint to the Pope of Rome, which the book
presents in such detail. I quote a passage from the well-known book on the
Saint by Professor Tsinkos, which, even if it is not acceptable in many parts,
contains significant references:
“In
the letters of Saint Theodore to the Popes of Rome, Leo and Paschal, the writer
appears to beg persistently for the convocation of an Ecumenical Council, in
order for the issues that concerned him—namely, the Moechian controversy and
Iconoclasm—to be resolved. This, in other words, means that, with the deep
ecclesiological awareness that characterized him, he understood that great and
serious issues are not resolved by local and 'limited-composition' councils.
For precisely this reason, he sought the universal condemnation of heresies by
the whole Church” (pp. 326–327).
Here, therefore,
certain questions arise again regarding the subject under examination:
How are the
Mysteries of the adulterers and the Iconoclasts rendered invalid once a portion
of the faithful walls itself off, at a time when they have not yet been
condemned by the other Churches through a Synod?
Does the Saint
write this to the Pope and the other Patriarchs? In his letters, the Saint
pleads for the convocation of a Synod and not for the condemnation of the
Mysteries of the heretics. Is there a document from any of the other local
Churches stating that the Mysteries of Constantinople are invalid? Or did the
other local Churches content themselves with a cessation of communion? And
which ones? All of them or only some?
As many as, and for
as long as, were in communion with the heretics of Constantinople, did they
have invalid Mysteries? Are there sources from other Patriarchates that prove
this? The Latin faithful (and those of the other Patriarchates) who happened to
be in Constantinople at that time, and had not received instructions from their
Church not to commune from those in communion with the adulterers—did they have
valid or invalid Mysteries?
The interpretation
regarding invalid Mysteries expressed on page 79 in a rather absolute manner
lacks patristic proof, since in the sources presented in the book, the
Venerable [Theodore] does not mention anything about invalidity of Mysteries,
but rather about defilement, about the necessity of walling off, about who is a
heretic, and about his stance during the period of economy (“that we
commemorated at that time when no Council had yet taken place, nor had the
heretical dogma been synodically proclaimed”; “not to mention anyone of those
who participated in the Council or are likeminded with its decisions,” p. 77;
and “It is just to call them transgressors and violators of the commandments of
God and of the sacred canons, and profane,” p. 80).
It also lacks
ecclesiastical proof, since no source is mentioned from another Patriarchate or
Saint of another Church—even a fellow ascetic of the Venerable One—that
demonstrates that other Saints or, collectively, the other Patriarchates held
the view of invalid Mysteries and, of course, that they followed the Venerable
in his teaching about invalid Mysteries (if we assume that Fr. Euthymios is
correct), nor that they rejected it, nor even that the matter was discussed.
And if we suppose that his interpretation can be inferred from the words of the
Venerable, nevertheless, such a detailed/one-sided interpretation on such a
serious, most serious issue is not justified without clear proofs, especially
when no one until now has understood/interpreted it in that way.
On pages 87–88 we
read:
“The
position of the Venerable one, also, as it concerns the Mysteries of the
heretics of his time, is extremely interesting and constitutes perhaps the
central point of the present study. It is characteristic that he considered the
Mysteries of the heretics invalid and non-existent. Also, that they conveyed no
grace or help to the participants, but rather condemnation, darkening, and
damnation… when the heretical bishop is commemorated, the validity of the
Mystery is automatically lost.”
Here we must ask:
where does the Venerable one speak about invalidity of Mysteries? The phrase
"he considered the Mysteries of the heretics invalid and
non-existent" (and of course we are not dealing here with the Mysteries of
condemned heretics, which are indeed non-existent, but with those of the
uncondemned) is not the Saint’s, but a conclusion of Fr. Euthymios. For,
contrary to the author’s conclusion that he speaks of invalid and ineffectual
Mysteries, the Venerable one speaks of valid and therefore effectual
[Mysteries] which condemn, since (as has been demonstrated up to now), invalid
Mysteries do not condemn!
But see the correct
interpretation that Fr. Euthymios himself gave some years ago, before he
arrived at the one he now teaches publicly in the Church, with which of course
I fully agree:
"Here
the Venerable one does not speak about defilement of the Mystery or about its
validity, but obviously focuses on the intention of the one approaching, who,
even though he knew the heretic and the clearly slandered one in life,
approached and communed from him. For the Mystery of Holy Communion does not
unite us with the devil when it is invalid—that is, when it is not the Body and
Blood of Christ—but heresy unites us with the devil, through which one is cut
off from the Body of Christ and which is the cause that renders also the
Mystery invalid. Therefore, when the Mystery is valid, it is our evil intention
with which we approach—and especially the knowledge of the heresy which we
recognize liturgically and into which we are mystically incorporated—that
unites us with the devil."
http://www.paterikiparadosi.blogspot.gr/2014/09/blog-post_18.html#more
And:
"Here
again the Venerable one speaks about heretics, who had not been condemned but
were moving within the realm of the Church. This, among other things, is
evident from the fact that he parallels the heretic with the one who is clearly
slandered in life, who also moved without having been deposed within the realm
of the Church."
http://www.paterikiparadosi.blogspot.gr/2014/09/blog-post_18.html#more
That is, here Fr.
Euthymios—in contrast to the interpretation of his two books and his latest
sermon—speaks both of the existence of uncondemned heretics in the Church and
of valid Mysteries.
I will now
juxtapose the words of the Saint with the teaching of the other Saints
previously mentioned, who speak about the nature of valid Mysteries when
someone partakes unworthily (and the Saint himself emphasizes the
"unworthily" in the same source: "even though he knew he was
doing wrong, nevertheless he knowingly sinned").
St. Theodore:
“Thus
also the heretical bread makes those who partake of it communicants… it
presents one body opposed to Christ… and the bread is a communion of the
adversary… not fearing Him who kills both soul and body by casting into
Gehenna… for to communicate from a heretic alienates from God and unites to the
devil (p. 358).”
Other Saints:
“Likewise we perish with the Christ-killers,” “for the Christian himself
becomes demon-possessed (hypostatically), and becomes like the devil,” “and I
would bring condemnation… and may it not be unto judgment for me… nor may I
become weak in soul and body, from partaking of them unworthily… not unto
damnation, not unto the addition of sins.” Is not the agreement of the Saints
manifestly evident? And can we claim that Holy Communion causes ‘damnation’ for
a liar but not for a heretic, a denier of God?
The above becomes
even clearer from the Saint’s epistle (footnote 37), referenced on page
90. There the Saint says plainly:
“Communion from the heretics is not common bread but poison (a drug), not that
which harms the body but darkens and blackens the soul.”
We all know that an
invalid mystery of Holy Communion means simple bread and wine. But the Saint
emphasizes “not common bread” and enumerates the elements of condemnation for
the unworthy communicants and celebrants, underlining in both sources the notion
of defilement: “not common bread.” And all that I am quoting—strangely
(strangely, because other things are presented as his main position)—is also
acknowledged by Fr. Euthymios on page 93: “The Saint… mentions that the
Orthodox Communion differs from that of the heretics. The Orthodox one
illumines the partaker, whereas the heretical one darkens him; the one gives
life, while the heretical one puts to death.” And on page 92: “the mystery has
been defiled solely by the commemoration of the heretical bishop,” where he
speaks of defilement—unfortunately, of the mystery—because, if it is invalid,
there is no defilement; if it is valid, then the expression is impious.
On page 227 we
read:
"That
is, his spirit is that only in matters of faith there can be no compromise and
concession, whereas all other things, such as the absence of a Synod,
Mysteries, monasteries, etc., can be appropriately dealt with by economy
by the persecuted confessing Fathers."
And again here,
when one reads the original text of the Saint referenced in the footnote, it is
evident that the Saint does not speak of invalidity of Mysteries, but of when
one is permitted to commune, after first repenting because he had communed with
heretics. Also, I believe a reasonable question arises: how can something be
dealt with by economy if it does not exist? If the Mysteries are
invalid, how can this restoration of validity be achieved by economy?
But even if this were possible, can a single Hieromonk do this on his own, as
Fr. Euthymios has done for years?
On pages 261–262,
Fr. Euthymios returns to the subject of contamination:
“The
teaching of the Saint was, after all, that all are contaminated by heresy, even
those who have a sound mindset, by ecclesiastical communion and commemoration…
For we are contaminated by ecclesiastical communion with heretics.”
And on page 357
again on the invalidity of the Mysteries:
“Here
the Saint teaches that after the walling off of the confessing Orthodox, the
Mysteries of the heretics are invalid.”
Here, forgive me if
I repeat myself, but I must emphasize that the Saint does not state anywhere in
the sources presented by Fr. Euthymios such a position, neither literally nor
interpretively. His position is the one consistent with all the Saints: “do not
commune with those of corrupt doctrine” (footnote 206), and consistent with the
15th Canon concerning false shepherds: “not truly to be ministers of God those
whom they ordain” (i.e. not... truly = false). There is no mention
whatsoever of invalidity of Mysteries.
As proof of the
above, I present the letter of St. Basil the Great, Epistle 265 TO EULOGIUS,
ALEXANDER, AND ADELFOCRATIANUS, BISHOPS OF EGYPT IN EXILE, from chapter 2:
2.
The report of your zeal concerning the uprightness of the pious faith greatly
strengthened in us the desire for communion with you… On the one hand, you
recognized those who innovate contrary to the apostolic teachings, and on the
other, you did not tolerate to simply suppress the harm done by them with
silence. Indeed, among all those who are devoted to the peace of the Lord, we
have encountered great sorrow because of the various innovations of
Apollinarius of Laodicea, who grieved us all the more because at first he
appeared to belong to us (the Orthodox). And indeed, to suffer something from
an open enemy, even if it be exceedingly painful, is somewhat bearable to the
one who suffers it, as it is written: “For if my enemy had reproached me, I
could have borne it.” But to suffer some harm from one of like mind and your
own, this is utterly unbearable and admits no consolation.
Indeed,
the one whom we had hoped would be a fellow defender of the truth, we have now
found in many respects to be a hindrance to those being saved (in Christ), in
that he unsettles their minds and draws them away from the Orthodox teaching.
For what zealous and reckless act was not committed by him? And what novel and
dangerous teaching was not devised by him (beyond the handed-down doctrine)?
Was not the entire Church divided against itself, especially since he sent men
into the Churches governed by the Orthodox in order to tear them apart and
attempt to establish his own separate gathering (parasynagogue)? Is not “the
great mystery of godliness” mocked, since bishops have become wanderers without
people or clergy, bearing merely the name (of bishop), without achieving
anything for the advancement of the Gospel of salvation?
Are not his words concerning God full of impious teachings, since by his
writings the old impious heresy of the vain-minded Sabellius has been revived?
For if what the Sebastians are spreading was not fabricated by enemies, but are
indeed his own genuine writings, then (in comparison to Sabellius) Apollinarius
has left no excess of impiety uncommitted, since he says that the same person
is both Father and Son, and likewise the Son is the Father, and other such dark
and impious words, which we could not even bear to hear with our ears, because
we desire (and pray) to have no fellowship with those who have uttered such
words.
(Then) is not the doctrine of the Incarnation confused in him? Is not
the saving Economy of our Lord considered doubtful by many on account of his
murky and obscure speculations concerning the Incarnation (of the Word)? Yet to
gather all these things and submit them to examination requires much time and
discourse. Moreover, who has darkened and utterly erased the matter of the
promises as much as his own mythology? For he at least dared to interpret the
blessed hope — which is reserved for those who have lived in accordance with
the Gospel of Christ — in such a base and lowly manner that he turned it into
(senseless) talk of old women and Jewish myths.
Thus he preaches from the outset a renewal of the temple and a faithful
observance of the legal worship, and again a symbolic high priest after the
true High Priest, and a sacrifice for sins after “the Lamb of God Who takes
away the sin of the world,” and particular baptisms after the one Baptism,
and... generally speaking, since already “the law of commandments in ordinances
(and precepts)” has been abolished, it is evident that likewise the teaching of
Christ will be nullified in the form of legal prescriptions.
Because of these things, on the one hand shame and disgrace have
covered our faces, and on the other hand, great sorrow has completely filled
our hearts. Therefore, we implore you—since you are learned physicians and have
been taught with gentleness to bring to soundness those who are of contrary
opinion—to try to restore him (Apollinaris) to the orderliness of the Church
and to persuade him to scorn (and abandon) the verbosity of his writings [for
indeed he has confirmed the word of Proverbs, namely that “it is not possible
for one to avoid sin through much talking”]. But also to expound to him
precisely the dogmas of Orthodoxy, so that both his correction may become
manifest and his repentance known to the brethren.
3. Moreover, it is a fitting opportunity to remind your reverence also
concerning the followers of Marcellus, so that you may not decide anything
regarding them rashly or easily. On the contrary, since he went out from the
Church on account of his impious teachings, it is necessary for his followers
first to anathematize that heresy, and then to be received into communion. (And
this) in order that they may be accepted by all the brethren who are united
with us through your mediation, since at least for the present the majority
were not a little saddened when they heard that, when these Marcellians came to
your reverence, you immediately received them and offered them ecclesiastical
communion.
(Nikodimos Bilalis, Collected Works of the Holy Fathers, Collected
Works of St. Basil the Great, “Ofelimos Vivlios” Publications, vol. 7, pp.
130–139).
Here
we see St. Basil the Great regarding Apollinarius—notwithstanding that he had
broken ecclesiastical communion with him and called him a false bishop—not as
an enemy, but still as an Orthodox member of the Church who needs healing,
which he entrusted to the two bishops/doctors of Egypt. The Mysteries of
Apollinarius are not questioned by St. Basil in any way, since he had not yet
been condemned by a council. And all this while St. Basil himself had walled
himself off. Regarding Marcellus of Ancyra, however—who had been condemned and
deposed at the Council of Constantinople (335/336)—St. Basil speaks
differently: he considers him outside the Church and his followers to be in
communion only if they anathematize the teaching of Marcellus. That is to say, it
becomes evident that walling off from a false shepherd does not mean the
invalidation of the Mysteries he performs—at least not until a council deals
with his case. Therefore, Fr. Euthymios and those who profess the same or
nearly the same are not correct when they teach the opposite.
I
believe that after these references, it must be emphasized that it is necessary
for a discussion to be held again with all the walling-off priests, based on
the patristic teaching and especially the consensus of the Fathers and
ecclesiastical history, concerning the validity of the Mysteries of those
heretics who have not been condemned, and of course their condemnation. For
those who have already been judged, no discussion is needed, since they neither
have Mysteries nor even constitute a church.
b) Concerning uncondemned and condemned heretics and concerning a
council
Before
we begin the commentary, an extremely important source must be cited. Dorotheos
of Bouleimas, a profound knower of the Holy Canons, whom St. Nikodemos
consulted in the composition of the Pedalion, writes in his
correspondence with St. Nikodemos (Christophoros Prodromites Kanonikon,
publ. MYGDONIA, Thessaloniki 2009, p. 184):
“To accept the ordination of heretics at the Fourth Council, as the
interpreter mentions by the example of Dioscorus who ordained Anatolios the
Patriarch of Constantinople, is not fitting; for Dioscorus was not a manifest
heretic, nor synodically deposed at the time when he ordained Anatolios. Thus,
by this reasoning, the Seventh Council accepted ordinations from heretics only economically
and due to circumstances; for neither the Fourth nor the Seventh
[Council] accepted ordination from manifest and synodically deposed heretics,
but from those who were not exposed and not examined. For this reason, the
error must be corrected concerning the term and criterion of ‘manifest’ and
‘unexposed’ [heretic]. [...] For the one who has received spiritual oversight
does not correct such matters according to those who have been revealed and
convicted.”
And
he continues (p. 188):
“For what agreement is there between the apostolic and patristic canons
and your own opinion? For they [i.e., the apostles and Fathers] do not accept
ordination, nor baptism, nor sacrifice, nor the other [mysteries] from those
heretics who have been convicted, but even those who have fled from them to the
Catholic Church — some, according to the principle of exactness, they order to
be rebaptized and reordained, as the Fathers of the First Council of Nicaea
define in their 19th canon; others, according to the principle of economy,
they accept from heresy, if there is no evil cause in them, upon the giving of libelli
[written confessions], as in the first act of the Council of Nicaea with the
Eastern and Illyrian bishops. Not, however, as having been ordained by
convicted heretics, nor as born heretics and having advanced [in heresy], but
as Orthodox ordained by Orthodox, or by heretics who had not been examined, and
then later drawn into the delusion of heresies.”
Therefore,
“…before Dioscorus was deposed, the priesthood was inalienable to him, even if
he made use of it badly and unlawfully.” Boulismas accepts that Dioscorus
indeed ordained Anatolius of Constantinople (449–458) and Maximus of Antioch
(450–456)—in reality, the latter was ordained by Anatolius—but at that time,
when he was performing the Mysteries, he had not yet been “exposed, proclaimed,
and condemned synodally” (“ἐλεληγμένος” = had ceased to be in force [i.e., as
bishop], “ἐκκήρυκτος” = cast out [i.e., from the Church]).
Indeed,
Boulismas, seeing that St. Nikodemos did not warmly accept his advice, wrote
him a letter on July 4, 1792 (Pantokratoros manuscript 513, pp. 429–435), in
which, using stern language, he says among other things the following:
“If even Thomas and John and Constantine were accepted, although they
had been ordained by Sergius and Pyrrhus and Paul and Peter, teachers of the
Monothelite heresy, they were nevertheless accepted before these teachers were
anathematized by the Sixth Council.”
And
the author of the aforementioned book Kanonikon notes:
“All that we have said gives rise to the suspicion that St. Nikodemos
possibly corrected or improved the original formulation of the comment on the
68th Apostolic Canon in the direction of the positions of Boulismas” (p. 192).
And
the unbelievable:
“Boulismas had undeniably a different position from that of the two
Athonites. In his rebuttal, he does not appear to be merely a proponent of
strictness, and for this reason he opposed the views concerning the economy-based
acceptance of the ordinations of heretics… His positions, expressing this
principle, are formulated through rhetorical questions: ‘How, by accepting the
ordinations of condemned heretics, can the synods be reconciled with the
apostolic canons, which do not accept the ordinations of heretics?’” (p. 203).
That
is, Boulismas expresses the akribeia (strictness) of the Church,
distinguishing between judged (κεκριμένων) and uncondemned heretics, and
applying the apostolic prohibitions only to the judged — the “condemned”
(ἐλεληγμένων) — heretics.
In
his homily of 10 Nov 2019, however, and in contrast with the above, Fr.
Euthymios said that there is no distinction in the teaching of St. Theodore
between uncondemned and condemned heretics, and that a synod is not necessary
for the Mysteries of heretics to be declared invalid.
However,
we see that this position is mistaken; it is not shown to be valid in our
ecclesiastical Tradition. What saddens us is that Fr. Euthymios previously held
this correct ecclesiastical position, before certain individuals influenced him
to replace it with the erroneous view regarding invalid Mysteries. Behold,
then, what Fr. Euthymios himself surprisingly admits in a text of his from 2018
and in contrast to his homily:
“We know that the Orthodox Tradition requires that, when certain
Bishops fall into error and heresy, a Synod be convened by the other local
Churches, that the heretics be condemned, and that Orthodox Bishops be
canonically ordained in the places of the heretical ones... I must first and
foremost state that it is one thing to return from heresy, especially when
someone was born and raised in it, and even when the heresy has not yet been
condemned by an Orthodox Synod with all the necessary consequences (i.e.,
replacement or repentance of the heretical bishops), and it is another matter
entirely, completely different, to return from denial and betrayal... If
therefore the Church accepts heretics returning to Orthodoxy without penance,
much more, I believe, will She accept those returning, when the heresy is being
spread within the Church and has not yet been definitively condemned with all
the necessary consequences.”
https://paterikiparadosi.blogspot.com/2018/01/blog-post_427.html?m=0
We
see here that in the above published text, in which Fr. Euthymios admonishes a
monk, not only is it accepted that there are heretics who have not been
condemned, not only that they canonically hold their position until their
condemnation, but also that they are within the Church. That is, an
inconsistency appears here between written texts and spoken words, which causes
confusion and leads to false conclusions.
And
in the book in question as well, there does not appear to be consistency
between the text and its interpretation regarding this position.
Let
us then examine what the book presents.
So
then, as we have seen, Fr. Euthymios said that in the teaching of St. Theodore
there is no distinction between heretics who have not been condemned and those
who have been judged, and that a council is not needed in order for the
Mysteries of heretics to be declared invalid—here, paradoxically, he again
contradicts himself (just as he did in his 2018 text), and on page 61 he
writes: "The resurgence of Orthodoxy means the restoration of the Orthodox
faith and the ecclesiastical and synodal condemnation of heresy."
Here
it becomes clear that until the resurgence of Orthodoxy, the heretics are
unjudged and within the Church, since something that does not exist within a
body cannot be expelled and restored to its former condition. The synod must
cut off the rotten member which, until judgment, remains by the Church’s
condescension as a member—rotten indeed, but still a member—within Her.
Therefore, the heretics are within the Church, as pseudo-bishops yet presidents
of the priestly assembly—the local Church (as the 15th Canon says)—and for that
reason they are even more dangerous, as they are not distinguishable from
priests of Orthodox mind, and neither ecclesiastically by those protesting or
walling themselves off has the heresy and the heretics been condemned, nor
synodally, since no synod has yet been convened for that purpose.
On
page 85 he writes:
“In the case where the groups of heretics live separately from the
Orthodox, have different churches and a different priesthood, things are
simpler, and it is easier to avoid all ecclesiastical communion with them.
(Note: And it is exactly about such people that St. Nikodemos speaks in the Pedalion:
about condemned heretics, or about heretics who have been cut off from the
Church and form their own group, which is not the case with the Ecumenists,
with whom the Orthodox are intermingled—and with the blessing of Fr. Euthymios
himself, since there he permits them to be married, something that was not
done, for example, with the Donatists in the Pedalion). The only problem
in this case is when Orthodox ecclesiastical leaders, abandoning the truth,
slavishly resort to the heretics for selfish interests, as is happening in our
days with the heresy of Ecumenism.”
Here
we see that Fr. Euthymios very rightly makes a distinction between condemned
heretics—for example, the Papists—and uncondemned heretics within the Church,
namely the Ecumenists. And he correctly points out that for the faithful it is
very difficult to discern the latter in relation to the former, precisely
because until their condemnation they still function as “Orthodox
ecclesiastical leaders.” Why, then, did he express in his homily a position
contrary to what he wrote as a conclusion from the teaching of the Saint? Did
he perhaps forget? In any case, it is a fact that he did not always say the
same things, as some claim.
Let
us not forget also that the same view as the above was expressed before St.
Theodore by St. Basil the Great. In his letter To the Westerners, St.
Basil writes:
“So then, the bold and shameless faction of the Arian heresy, having
been clearly cut off from the body of the Church, remains in its delusion, but
harms us little, because their impiety is evident to all. But those who are
clothed in sheep’s skin and display an outward life that is gentle and meek,
while inwardly they mercilessly tear apart the sheep of Christ—especially
because they originally came from among us—these cause harm more easily to the
simpler ones; these are the truly dangerous ones and difficult to guard
against. [Those who are clothed in the fleece of the sheep and exhibit the
appearance of gentleness and meekness, but inwardly mercilessly tear apart the
sheep of Christ, and due to having originated from among us, easily cause harm
to the simpler ones—these are the grievous and hard to guard against.] These,
precisely, we ask from your excellency to make known publicly to all the
Churches of the East, so that if they walk rightly [in the truth], they may
truly belong with us [proof that they still belong to the Church], or if they
persist in their perversion, they may confine their harm to themselves alone,
without being able—because of unguarded communion [with them]—to transmit their
disease to those who approach them.” “But it is also necessary for us to name
them explicitly, so that you yourselves may know who causes turmoil among us,
and so that you may also make this known to your Churches. For our own account
appears to many as suspect, as if we supposedly display a petty and quarrelsome
attitude towards them on account of some personal differences.”
(St. Basil the Great, To the Westerners, Epistle 263, ed.
“Ofelimos Vivliou,” trans. by Nikodimos Bilalis, op. cit., ch. 2, pp. 124–125.)
And
in another letter, St. Basil writes in the same spirit:
“So then, the things long plotted against the Church by the Arians,
though they are many and great and spread throughout the whole world, are
nevertheless bearable for us, because they come from open enemies and
adversaries of the word of truth. When they do not act as usual, we are
amazed—rather than when they dare something outrageous and youthful against
piety. But what grieves and troubles us are the things done by those who are of
one mind and belief with us.”
(St. Basil the Great, To Peter, Bishop of Alexandria, Epistle
266, ch. 1, lines 12–20, p. 136)
The
interpretation (by N. Bilalis):
“So then, all that the Arians have deceitfully plotted from the
beginning against the Church—although they are many and great and trumpeted
throughout the whole world—are nonetheless bearable for us, because they come
from open enemies and adversaries of the word of truth. Indeed, we are amazed
at them when they do not do what they usually do, and not when they dare
something serious and audacious against the pious faith. On the other hand, we
are grieved and troubled by what is done by those who are of one mind and
belief with us (editor’s note: again, proof that they still belong to the
Church).”
(from the book The Patristic Attitude toward Theological Dialogues,
by Panagiotis Simatis)
I
continue with the book of Fr. Euthymios. The same is stated on pages 114–115:
“A time of heresy is understood to mean every historical period during
which a heresy emerges, until it is definitively condemned by an Orthodox
synod… The heresy to this day has not only not been condemned, but continues to
spread like a contagious disease and tends—through the bishops and by means of
the clergy—to prevail even among the laity.”
The
same argument is presented also on page 132. Here again, the very correct
observation is made that Ecumenism is an unjudged and uncondemned heresy, with
priests inside the Church who defile the flock. For precisely this reason we
separated (walled ourselves off), as the Church teaches, in order to preserve
ourselves and the Truth unadulterated. Yet the question arises: Why does Fr.
Euthymios change the meaning of these words and—in other places—speak of no
distinction between heretics and no existence of them within the Church?
Because if that were so, then they would belong to the first category of
heretics, like the Papists. Is this not a case of massive inconsistency? Does
this not, in this way, cause confusion in the flock?
On
page 138 it is repeated what the biographer of the Saint reports (book, p.
160), presenting the steadfast stance of the Fathers against the iconoclast
emperor: “For it is unprofitable for us,” they say, “to converse again with
those already condemned.”
I
repeat: here the stance of the Church is made clear—the Saints who spoke
against the emperor held a stricter position than at other times because they
were addressing already judged individuals (“τοῖς ἤδη κατεγνωσμένοις,” meaning
those already condemned by the Seventh Ecumenical Council). Fr. Euthymios,
however, I repeat, said in his talk that there are no judged and unjudged
(heretics), but that this distinction is one of our times and is not meant in
the Patristic sense. Therefore, this is to be reckoned as a doctrinal error on
the part of those who, based on the acknowledgment of the existence of
uncondemned heretics in the Church, support the validity of Mysteries relying
on Patristic texts.
He
also said:
“He was speaking, then, about the heretics of his time, the Moechians
(those who upheld adulterous unions) and the Iconoclasts, who in his day had
not yet been condemned. When Saint Theodore reposed, the restoration of the
Holy Icons had not yet occurred.”
According
to the above words of the Saints, this position of his does not hold, for
although the restoration of the icons was indeed the final victory of Orthodoxy
and took place decades later, nevertheless the adulterous one had already been
deposed by Saint Tarasios, and there existed the condemnation of the Seventh
Ecumenical Council against the Iconoclasts.
On
page 169 he writes:
“But the Church remained without schism and defect and will remain so
until the end, because all those who think or act in a perverted manner are
cast out and removed from it.”
So
then, just as it is for us, likewise here (!) for Fr. Euthymios, the synod is
that very expression of the Church which casts out/cuts off and removes its
decayed members, in order for them to be burned in the fire (clearly referring
to the fire mentioned by the Lord), and thus for the Church to remain
undefiled. How, then, does he now defend the opposite? How does he call
“murderers of the truth” those who accept what he himself rightly accepted just
a few years ago? Who persuaded him, or why did he change his mind? Did he
perhaps discover some other clear text from the Saint? If so, he ought to
present it to us.
The
fact that heretics, until their condemnation, are within the Church is stated
even more clearly on page 178. I quote the text without comment, because it is
in itself thoroughly demonstrative:
“It must be emphasized that we are not speaking about unity with the
heretics who are condemned and cut off from the Church… but about the heretics
who appear within the Church either as Bishops… or as clergy or laity who
follow them and recognize them… These heresies which arise within the space of
the Church are perhaps the worst, because they alter the Orthodox mindset and
Tradition from within and because they are difficult to combat.”
The
same is stated on pages 210, 211, 212, 213, 217 (“until… they are judged by an
Orthodox Synod”), 221, (“When again heresy prevails, and it has not yet been
officially and definitively condemned by an Orthodox synod… within the
Church”), 222, (“until the presence of an Orthodox Synod”), 236, (“the
gatherings of the Fathers are not the canonical Orthodox Synod because the heretical
bishops were still seated on their thrones”), 272, (“but synodally, in a lawful
and ecclesiastical manner”), 344, 347, 352, (“a Synod must be convened, which
will publicly and ecclesiastically condemn the heresy”), 353, 354.
Let
us now consider the teaching of St. Nikodemos the Hagiorite. St. Nikodemos
writes:
“We must know that the penalties which the Canons prescribe, namely the
‘let him be deposed,’ ‘let him be excommunicated,’ and ‘let
him be anathematized,’ these, according to grammatical art, are in the
third person imperative, in the absence of the subject. In which case, for this
command to be transmitted, it is necessarily required that a second person be
present. I explain this more clearly: The Canons command the Synod of the
living Bishops to depose priests, or to excommunicate, or to anathematize the
laypeople who transgress the Canons. However, if the Synod does not in fact
carry out the deposition of the priests, or the excommunication or anathematization
of the laypeople, those priests and laypeople are neither actually deposed, nor
excommunicated, nor anathematized. They are, however, liable here to
deposition, excommunication, or anathematization, and there to divine judgment…
Therefore, those foolish people greatly err who say that, in our present times,
all clergy ordained contrary to the Canons are in fact already deposed. That is
a slanderous tongue which foolishly chatters such things, not understanding
that the command of the Canons, without the actual implementation of the second
person, that is, of the Synod, is ineffective—immediately and prior to
judgment, it does not operate of itself. The divine Apostles themselves clearly
interpret themselves in their 66th Canon, for they do not say that any Bishop
or Presbyter who accepts heretical baptism is already in fact deposed, but
rather, ‘we command that he be deposed’—that is, that he be brought to
judgment, and if it is proven that he has done this, then let him be stripped
of the Priesthood by your own decision; this we command.”
(Footnote 1 to the Third Apostolic Canon)
And
so that it may not be thought that these apply only to other sins, I present
the opinion of a Saint, who applies them to heretics. St. Athanasios of Paros
writes (and let us also recall here the previously mentioned and relevant words
of Boulesmas, as well as the related matters concerning Simony):
“For those who are liable to deposition are not deposed in actuality,
but possess, equally with the innocent, the operative power of the Priesthood.
For according to the axiom of Chrysostom, ‘God does not ordain all, but
works through all.’ And this is shown also by what follows. For the things
they bind remain bound, and the things they loose appear loosed. And the waters
which they sanctify are seen to remain unspoiled for many years. These indeed
become irrefutable proof of the truth of our faith in contrast to the heterodox
religions.” (Epitome of the Divine Dogmas of the Faith, Leipzig, 1806,
p. 378).
Therefore,
in agreement with St. Nikodemos, St. Athanasios tells us that those guilty of
deposition are not literally deposed and still have the operative power of the
Priesthood—just as the innocent do—until the synodal decision for their
deposition, even though they are not innocent.
c) On the question of whether the Ecumenists are within the Church
until their condemnation and concerning ecclesiology.
The
third paragraph of this critical examination is directly related to the two
preceding ones. For if the Ecumenists do not have Mysteries, then they are not
within the Church, since outside of Her there are no Mysteries, and it no
longer matters whether they are synodally condemned or not condemned. But if
they do have Mysteries, then they exist as putrefied members within the Church
until their synodal judgment and condemnation (a point which, as we saw
earlier, Fr. Euthymios has written more than once), without, of course, the
Church ceasing to be infallible and unblemished, since the existence of
Orthodox faithful who do not accept the Ecumenists’ heresies, and the walling
off of the faithful from heresy, preserves the Truth and isolates the defiling members,
until either their healing or their removal.
Walling
off, therefore, preserves the truth. It does not render the Mysteries of the
Ecumenists invalid, nor does it expel them in the form of a synod from the
Church. It isolates them, walls them off so that they do not defile the
faithful, until they are judged by a Synod and, if they do not repent,
condemned.
I
will again begin with some examples from Church history and teaching.
The
father of Saint Gregory the Theologian, Saint Gregory Bishop of Nazianzus, had
signed, out of simplicity, a document containing heretical positions. Then “the
monks of the region, not tolerating ecclesiastical communion with him, cut off
ecclesiastical communion with him (they walled themselves off) along with a
portion of the laity” (RESPONSE–COMMENTARY TO THE SERMON OF THE ARCHPRIEST
OF EORDAIA, FR. AUGOUSTINOS AUXONIDIS… WRITTEN BY IOANNIS RIZOS).
Therefore, the following questions naturally arise with self-evident answers:
Did Saint Gregory, from the moment when monks and laypeople walled themselves
off from him, have invalid Mysteries? Had Saint Gregory ceased, because of his
signature on the document and the walling off by the monks and laypeople, to be
a member of the Church? Was anyone who did not wall themselves off from the
Saint also outside the Church? We will answer the self-evident: of course not!
The
following is characteristic: a passage from the Acts of the Fourth Session of
the Seventh Ecumenical Council. There it is said that the Holy Fathers fulfill
the word of Christ, that is, to place the lamp of divine knowledge “on the
lampstand” so that it may shine upon all who are in the house, and not to hide
it “under the bushel.” In this way, those who confess the Lord piously are
aided in walking unimpeded along the path of salvation. The Holy Fathers
“cast out every heretical delusion, and the decayed member, if it be
incurably diseased, they cut off; and holding the winnowing fan, they cleanse
the threshing floor, and the wheat—that is, the nourishing word which
strengthens the heart of man—they gather into the storehouse of the Catholic
Church, while the chaff of heretical false teaching they cast out and burn with
unquenchable fire.”
And
in the hymnology of the Church we read:
“With the sling of the Spirit, they cast out those who had fallen as if
unto death from the fullness of the Church, as incurably diseased,” “with the
sword of the Spirit they cut off, as decayed members, from the wholeness of the
Orthodox,” “the impious and heretical Arius and those of like mind they
anathematized, and as decayed members they cut off from the entire body of the
faithful”
(from the Horologion, p. 399).
In
the Matins service for the feast of Saint Gregory the Theologian we chant:
“Having cultivated with your tongue, O God-bearer, you enriched with
the divine seed of Theology, in the furrows of hearts, the entire fullness of
the Church with the highest Theology; from there, you burned with the fire of
the Spirit the tares of heresies, being nourished by the love of divine
philosophy, father of fathers, shepherd of shepherds, and glory of the
faithful, lamp of priests, boast of the world, all-blessed Gregory.”
Here
we see that the hymnographer speaks both of the tares, that is, heresies, and
also of the fact that these tares belonged to the fullness of the Church (“from
there”), and which the Saint burned with the flame of the Holy Spirit—naturally
as president of the Second Ecumenical Council.
From
the above, it becomes clear that within the Church there have appeared from
time to time—through Her adversary, the devil—heretical individuals who sought
to alter or annul Her theanthropic character. The Church tolerated them,
according to the will of God, for a certain time, aiming at their healing and
salvation, but also for the testing of Her flock and the manifestation of Her
Saints. However, when that time reached the limits appointed by God (“it seemed
good to the Holy Spirit and to us”), then by synodal ecclesiastical decision
these members were cut off / cast out from Her all-holy body, were rendered
dead, and only through true repentance can they again be received.
The
Patriarch of Constantinople, St. Nicephorus, wrote to Pope Leo III of Rome
informing him of the results of the Seventh Ecumenical Council as follows:
“[We] cast out from the Church those who, by the overlooking of God,
had assumed hieratic thrones” (PG vol. 100, col. 193C / S.M.P.S. vol. B, p.
914a).
Therefore,
until their expulsion by the Council, the iconoclasts were decayed members of
the Church, “having assumed hieratic thrones by the overlooking of God.”
Let
us again reconsider the above by taking once more as examples St. Nektarios and
St. Nicodemos the Hagiorite.
St.
Nektarios writes:
“The shepherd is obliged to
protect his sheep from the mouths of wolves; when they wander away from the
fold, he must arduously run after them to bring them back. If one is lost, he
must enter into the forests and groves, climb mountains and hills, tread upon
thorns and brambles to find it; and when he finds it, joyfully and gladly place
it upon his shoulders, bringing it back to the flock together with the others.
He is obliged to guide the entire flock to saving pastures, keeping it far away
from the poisonous plants [i.e., weeds] of heresy, away from the muddy waters
of false doctrine. In this way, he guides the flock, urging the sheep forward
or calling them back, encouraging or deterring, moving or comforting,
threatening or charming, with the spiritual flute of salvific teaching, which
must never be absent from his mouth. It is therefore evident that such
shepherding becomes even more difficult and painful where unhealthy and foul
waters abound, or poisonous and harmful plants flourish, or ravines are steep,
wooded, and wild, or wolves and other bloodthirsty, ravenous beasts lurk.”
(“Essay on Religious Tolerance,” p. 22)
The
final emphasized expressions of the Saint refer to those who are heretical or
deluded while still (for the time being) within the Church, which is precisely
why the work of the Orthodox shepherd is extremely difficult.
The
above teaching of St. Nektarios is in complete agreement with the timeless
teaching of the Saints, as will be shown by the following text concerning
Nestorius and his treatment by St. Cyril and St. Celestine:
“Nestorius has already preached his heresy publicly in church and
persists in it; he has been denounced by laypeople, monks, and other clergymen;
Patriarchs have already intervened with their letters, and they too condemn the
heresy. One of them is the Bishop of Rome, Celestine, who writes him a letter.
In it, he initially addresses him as brother, since Nestorius canonically holds
the throne of Constantinople as a Bishop, and indeed possesses Mysteries and
episcopal authority. At the same time, however, in that same letter, he speaks
to him with great severity and portrays in dark terms the tragic consequences
of his false teaching, and describes therein the character of a pseudo-bishop.”
The
first thing he points out is that, whereas the duty of the true shepherd is to
provide pure evangelical spiritual nourishment to the faithful, he provides
them with POISON! Proceeding further, he writes that, while the good shepherd
cares for the sheep, he, as a false shepherd, not only neglects the sheep, not
only abandons them to the predatory will of heretical wolves, but he himself
has become a wolf to the sheep entrusted to him by Christ and devours them. And
he asks: Where can the faithful flee for protection from the heretical ideas
and to be saved, when they are attacked by these ideas and perish within the
“ecclesiastical” environments, in their own parishes? It is entirely evident
that here he speaks of canonical ministers with heretical ideas. And where can
they find safety, when instead of protectors and helpful shepherds, they have
inside their house a predatory wolf—the Patriarch—and naturally the priests
under his authority who obey him? And whereas the Lord speaks also of other
sheep that were not then in the fold but were also going to be brought into the
Church to be saved, you (Nestorius) not only fail to care for them, but even
those you already had are being lost—devoured or persecuted—by you yourself?
It
is dreadful, he continues, that in your case the prophetic words of the Apostle
Paul are fulfilled—who said that from among the ranks of the Shepherds, who
belong to and function as canonical priests of the Church (and for this reason
are more dangerous than heretics outside the Church), there will arise
“grievous wolves” who will not care for the faithful, will not be concerned for
the flock, but rather will teach them things contrary to the Gospel, heretical
and perverse, with the aim of making them their followers and leading them to
perdition.
These
are the things we would wish you to say (Nestorius, as Archbishop), that you
would say them about others, in order to protect them from the wolves—and not
that they would be said by others about you. Who does not suffer and grieve
upon seeing your case? That is, instead of a bishop teaching others, he himself
must be taught that he ought to be a Christian! Therefore, pay close attention,
realize which (Christ-fighting) heresy and in what manner you are serving it:
you provoke, you slander, you accuse the Orthodox. Do such things befit one who
holds the rank of the priesthood? Or do you think that we will pity you, when
you do not even care for the salvation of your own soul? That we will pity you—you—who
seek to rob both those now living and those who shall live of their salvation
through the dissemination of your heresy?
Here
it is necessary to note that indeed Nestorius followed teachings professed by
Apollinaris, and the heresy of Apollinarianism had been condemned: by local
Synods in 377, 378, and 379 in Alexandria and Antioch, and of course by the
Second Ecumenical Council of 381…
That
the condemnation of a heresy does not mean that the heretic immediately ceases
to have his priestly status is also shown by the fact that “at the local synod
of Rome (430), the teaching of Nestorius was condemned, and its renunciation
was demanded under the threat of deposition” (V. Feidas, op. cit., p.
607). How much more, then, when a heretic remains a member of the Church until
the moment he utters a heretical position—even one already condemned by an
earlier council…
In
another letter now, again from Celestine to the Patriarch of Antioch John, we
see that he refers to the heretic Nestorius as a priest, because he had not yet
been deposed by a Synod. The distress, he says, is less for heretics who are
outside the Church, compared to when heretics are within the Church. When
heresy exists inside the “holy Church of God” and is taught by an active
clergyman, the grief is greater. It is even a “double lament,” he specifically
writes, when this heretical teaching is taught in Constantinople, “in the
greatest city,” because “a multitude of people” gathers there (from all parts
of the empire). And the Bishop of Rome, Celestine, returns to emphasize again
that the case is far worse when the heretic is within the Church, performing
the sanctifying and teaching work of a shepherd, but in reality is a false
shepherd. Then things are worse even than civil war, because there is confusion
among the faithful, since a heretic “has the place of a shepherd within the
very flock” and “within the very house of God the spears of impious religion
(that is, of heresy) are being hurled.” For this reason, “our inner being is
shaken,” because the heretical bishop Nestorius, “who seems to hold the Church
of Constantinople,” pours the poison of heresy into the souls of the faithful.
Since,
then, as long as Nestorius continues to blaspheme against the holy Virgin
(teaching the people that she is Christotokos/bearer of a man and not
the Theotokos), it is not safe for the faith and the people to continue
the exchange of letters with Nestorius (thus maintaining communication with
him), because this ongoing discussion with a blasphemer and the repetition, in
the course of debate, of his blasphemies (necessarily in order to refute them),
this—says Celestine—is a crime! For this reason, we break ecclesiastical
communion with Nestorius and those who follow him. And we will not be in
communion with the Archbishop of Constantinople Nestorius, until he condemns in
writing the heresy which he teaches openly and publicly in the Church. As for
those Orthodox whom Nestorius has excommunicated or deposed, we will continue to
have communion with them... I (i.e., St. Cyril) therefore sent him a first and
a second letter and “as a brother I entreated” the heretic Nestorius to cease
following his heretical notions and to follow the apostolic faith that has been
handed down to us. But this well-intentioned act of mine did not help at all.
On the contrary, he continued to defend and propagate his heresy. Since
Celestine of Rome also wrote letters to Nestorius, I inform you of all these
things, wishing to stir you to pious zeal, so that we (the Patriarchs) may all
unite in the struggle against his heresy... He then emphasizes the harm done by
the heretics, and—as we will see in all the texts of this collection concerning
the period of the Third Ecumenical Council—NOWHERE is there any mention of
invalid Mysteries of the heretics. Always and everywhere it is only the harm
and defilement caused by the heretics and received by those who commune with
them that is repeated. The saint writes: “For the inventors of heresies,
digging pits of vanity for themselves and also for others, bring themselves and
their followers to such a downfall of understanding…” (ibid., p. 11).
After
this first letter of Saint Cyril, another letter follows addressed to
Nestorius. And how does he call the heretic Nestorius, who is teaching a heresy
condemned by at least three Synods and by the Second Ecumenical Council?
“Concelebrant”! So, did Nestorius have or not have Mysteries, even though he
was preaching a condemned heresy? Saint Cyril writes: “To the most devout and
God-fearing concelebrant Nestorius, Cyril in the Lord sends greetings” (ibid.,
p. 21). And he continues: “How is it possible to remain silent when the Faith
is being wronged and so many distortions exist? Or shall we not appear before
the tribunal of Christ, nor give an account for such untimely silence, even
though we are appointed by Him to speak what must be spoken? … Or does your
piety suppose that only a small uproar has arisen in the Churches from such
speeches? We are all in struggle and toils, seeking to move those who are
otherwise minded—persuaded otherwise—to the truth.” And why, he continues, do
you not correct your teaching, “so that the universal scandal may cease?” Call
the Holy Virgin Theotokos, “that we may heal those who are grieved, and
possessing a right opinion among all, in peace and concord of the people, we
may celebrate the assemblies” (ibid., p. 22).
It
is evident that the entire concern of Saint Cyril is that Nestorius cease
teaching heretically. Nowhere is there mention of invalid Mysteries. He speaks
only about a break in communion. As long as Nestorius teaches heresy as a
bishop, being Saint Cyril’s “concelebrant,” there is no concord and peace,
since the faithful people do not commune with him.
But
also in his second letter, Saint Cyril again calls Nestorius his
“concelebrant”: “To the most reverent and God-fearing concelebrant Nestorius,
Cyril greets you in the Lord” (ibid., p. 23). He then calls him “brother
in Christ” and tells him that he will remind him of “the word of evangelical
teaching and that, concerning the faith, one must act with all certainty toward
the people, and understand that to scandalize even one of the little ones who
believe in Christ brings unbearable indignation. And if there is such a
multitude of those grieved, how are we not in every need of skillfulness to
prudently remove the scandals and to establish the sound word of the faith for
those seeking the truth?” (ibid., p. 24).
Nevertheless,
at the end of his second letter, Saint Cyril conveys a greeting through
Archbishop Nestorius (the heretic who is teaching a condemned heresy!) to the
Church of Constantinople under him: “Greet the brotherhood with you. She, who
is with us in Christ, greets you” (ibid., p. 26).
In
the third letter of Saint Cyril to Nestorius (ibid., p. 27), after again
addressing him with the same greeting, “To the most reverent and God-fearing
concelebrant Nestorius, Cyril greets you in the Lord,” even though it is
evident that Nestorius persists in heresy, he reminds Nestorius that these
heterodox assertions of his “are either of a mind deceived according to the
Greeks, brother, or of the mad Apollinaris and Arius and the other diseased
heresies, or even something heavier than those” (ibid., p. 29). He reminds him
that what he teaches has been condemned by synods and bluntly tells him that he
is a deceived pseudo-bishop: “Know yourself to be deceived by those here who
have been deposed by the holy synod, as holding views like those of the Manichaeans.”
And despite the fact that he reminds him he is following an error condemned by
a synod, he still concludes by regarding him as a brother and bishop of
Constantinople: “To all the brotherhood with you in Christ, both I and those
with me send many greetings. May you continue in good health, praying for us,
most honorable and God-fearing master!” (ibid., p. 30).
In
another letter, which is composed by Saint Cyril and the Synod convened in
Alexandria, in which again the heretic Nestorius is called their
“concelebrant,” we read:
We cannot remain silent at the moment when you are blaspheming the Lord
with your teaching. “And if indeed (with your blasphemies) you were only
wronging yourself by thinking and teaching such things, the concern would be
less; but since you have scandalized the whole Church and introduced into the
people the leaven of lawless and foreign heresy… what reason could still
suffice for our silence… [Editor’s note: Again, there is no mention here of
harm from invalid Mysteries. The problem is the leaven of heresy, that is, the
defilement]. For when faith is wronged, let the reverence toward parents be
cast away as outdated and unsafe… and for the pious, let death be better than
life, so that they may obtain a better resurrection according to what is
written” (ibid., p. 31).
And
here now, they remind him that they will apply the ecclesiastical Tradition: “A
heretical man, after a first and second admonition, reject.” They advise him,
saying,
“to renounce such coarse and distorted doctrines, which you both hold
and teach… and if your reverence does not do this within the appointed time…
know yourself to have no share with us, nor place or voice among the priests
and bishops of God. For it is not possible for us to overlook the Churches so
disturbed, the people so scandalized, the right faith being annulled, and the
flocks scattered by you, who ought to be saving them… And to all those who have
been separated from your reverence for the sake of the faith or deposed—whether
laymen or clergy—we all are in communion. For it is not just that those who
have come to right belief should be wronged by your judgments, because they
have rightly opposed you.” (ibid., p. 32)
And
here the Synod under Saint Cyril tells him that he despises and misinterprets
the Nicene Creed; therefore, his heresy is also condemned by the First
Ecumenical Council:
“It will not suffice your reverence to merely confess the Creed of the
Faith formulated at the time by those gathered in Nicaea (for you have
misunderstood and misinterpreted it not rightly, but rather perversely, even if
you verbally confess its wording), but you must also, in written and sworn
form, confess in accord that you anathematize your own impure and profane
doctrines.” (ibid., p. 32)
The
Pope of Rome, Celestine, writes to Saint Cyril and compares him with the “most
devout” Nestorius…:
“Just as you are a good shepherd, so that man is not even worthy to be
accused as a wicked hireling, who is not denounced for abandoning his own
sheep, but because he was found to be himself tearing them apart.” (ibid.,
p. 74).
What
is the evil of the heretic? Is it that he performs invalid Mysteries? Saint
Celestine does not teach us this either… Our decision, therefore, is
“either within ten days, counted from the day of this admonition, he
shall revoke his wicked teachings by a written confession… or if he does not do
this, your Holiness must at once take measures that he be removed in every way
from our body, he who would not even consent to receive healing from those
offering it and is being held as a plague-bringer, to the destruction of both
himself and all those entrusted to him.” (ibid., pp. 74–75)… And these things
(which I write to you, Cyril, concludes Celestine’s letter), I have also
written to the other Patriarchs so that “our decision regarding him may be
manifest, or rather, the divine decision of our Christ,” namely the removal of
the episcopal rank from Nestorius through deposition."
(Panagiotis Simatis) https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/06/blog-post_92.html
In
this context, I also add some excerpts from the Pedalion of Saint
Nikodemos in order to clarify both the previous chapters and the new one
regarding the Church.
The
first excerpt is naturally well-known, but I include it here because it is
evident that it does not refer to those not yet condemned, but to condemned
heretics, who are not within the Church, either because they were condemned by
the Church or because they themselves were cut off from it and formed their own
group. Please pay attention to the terminology of the Saint, which is in
complete agreement with everything previously cited. He writes:
"Those baptized or ordained by heretics cannot possibly—indeed, it
is impossible—that they be either Christians or clerics. Following, I say,
these Canons, they established a Canon by which they reject both the baptism of
heretics and that of schismatics. Proving this also from many other scriptural
passages, especially from that of the Apostle: ‘One Lord, one Faith, one
Baptism’ (Eph. 4). For if, he says, the Catholic Church is one, and one is the
true Baptism, how can the baptism of heretics and schismatics be true, at a
time when they are not within the Catholic Church but have been cut off from it
through heresy? If the baptism of heretics and schismatics is true, then the
baptism of the Orthodox and Catholic Church is also true. Then there is not one
baptism, as Paul cries out, but two—which is most absurd. They further add that
this opinion—not to accept the baptism of heretics—is not new or recently
invented by them, but ancient and approved by their predecessors. The holy
Sixth Ecumenical Council also ratified the Canon of this Synod (Canon
II)."
This
is also evident from what the Saint says in the footnote to the same Canon.
Referring to St. Basil the Great, the Saint writes:
“For setting out in his first Canon to explain which baptisms are
acceptable and which are not, he divides them into two, saying: ‘That the
baptism of heretics, namely of those entirely separated from the Church and
differing from the Orthodox even in the very faith, and whose difference
directly affects the faith in God, was deemed by the ancients to be entirely
invalid. But the baptism of the schismatics was likewise deemed invalid by the
synod of our own, concerning Cyprian and Firmilian, as the schismatics—those
called Cathari, and Encratites, and those clad in sackcloth, and
Hydroparastatae, and others—separated at the beginning from the Church, and
having separated no longer had the grace of the Holy Spirit with them, since
its transmission was interrupted; wherefore, having become laymen, they had
neither spiritual grace nor authority to baptize or ordain, and thus those
baptized by them, being baptized by laymen, were ordered to be baptized with
the true Baptism of the Catholic Church. But since it also seemed reasonable to
some of the Fathers of Asia to accept the baptism of the schismatics out of
some economy for the many, let it be accepted.’” (Pedalion,
footnote, p. 52)
A
little further down in the same footnote, referring again to the Latins, the
Saint notes that they themselves “were cut off” and departed from the One
Church (something the Ecumenists have not yet done, who—even though they
espouse heresy—consider themselves to constitute the Church, since no Council
has yet presented them with the dilemma or deposed them). The Saint writes:
“So then, it being acknowledged that the Latins are long-standing
heretics, in the first place they are unbaptized, according to St. Basil the
Great above… Because having become laymen by cutting themselves off from the
Orthodox Church, they no longer have with them the grace of the Holy Spirit,
through which the Orthodox priests perform the Mysteries… Secondly, the Latins
are unbaptized because they do not observe the three immersions upon the one
being baptized.” (Pedalion, footnote, p. 55).
Let
us note here once again that the Latins were cut off from the Orthodox One
Church by formally condemning it synodally. That is, by considering that they
had formed their own Church, a different, separate Church—in other words, they
had by themselves been severed from the One Church.
(End
of Part 2)
Let the following
position of Saint Nikodemos also be a cause of concern for those who teach
absolutely about invalid Mysteries. According to this, those who were baptized
Orthodox, even if they fall into heresy, are not re-baptized when they return.
Specific acts of repentance are sufficient for them to be re-integrated into
the Church. He writes:
“It
is therefore not correct what Balsamon says in his interpretation of the 19th
Canon of the First Council, nor perhaps others of like mind with Balsamon, that
those who were formerly baptized Orthodox, and later became heretics, and
afterward return to the Orthodox faith, ought to be baptized a second time.
They bring forth as testimony the present Apostolic Canon and the 19th of the
First [Council], which says that the Paulianists, when they come over to the
Catholic Church, must be re-baptized. These do not speak correctly, I say, for
three reasons:
a)
Because with this re-baptism which they advocate, they introduce two baptisms
into the Catholic Church, which in the Symbol of Faith confesses one baptism,
taking the occasion for such confession from Paul who said, ‘One Lord, one
Faith, one Baptism.’ And inasmuch as, according to them, they crucify again the
Son of God with the re-baptism, and render His Cross and death a second time,
which is most impious and impossible… and ‘those who were once enlightened and
have fallen away (that is, to Judaism or simply to heresy, according to
Chrysostom), it is impossible again to renew to repentance, crucifying again to
themselves the Son of God’ (Heb. 6).
b)
Because this Apostolic Canon which they bring forth as testimony to their
opinion does not speak about those who were previously baptized Orthodox, but
about those who were heretics from birth and were defiled by them, and then
came to Orthodoxy. Wherefore it does not say that we are to re-baptize them as
if they were previously baptized, but to baptize them (for if, it says, he does
not baptize) as not having ever been baptized Orthodox. And the 19th of the
First [Council] that says Paulianists are to be re-baptized — ‘Paulianists’
means those who from birth had the heresy of Paul and not those who later
became such (even if the term ‘to Paulianize’ seems to mean such), since the
Sixth Ecumenical Council in its 95th Canon, recalling this very Canon of the
First [Council], changed it from ‘Paulianized’ to ‘Paulianists,’ just as with
‘Donatists’ and ‘Montanists,’ which names clearly indicate a heresy from birth
rather than one acquired later. And this is how both Balsamon himself and
Zonaras interpret the Canon, as we will see in the interpretation of that
Canon. And though the Canon uses the word ‘re-baptize,’ which implies a second
baptism, it uses it not properly but improperly: referring our baptism in
relation to the baptism of the heretic Paul. Likewise, the great Basil in his
77th Canon used the same word ‘re-baptism,’ not as if that was a true baptism,
but as the heretics themselves named it…
c)
That if it were permitted to re-baptize those Christians who became heretics or
denied the faith, why did the very same first council in its 11th and 12th
Canons prescribe that those who denied the faith in time of persecution should
spend so many years as hearers and so many as kneelers, at a time when it would
have been possible to baptize them again and thus cleanse them of denial, and
the Church be spared so much toil and concern over their spiritual correction?
For
these reasons, therefore, it is not permitted to baptize again one who has
truly been baptized, according to this 77th Apostolic Canon and the 55th of the
Council of Carthage, even if he has been defiled by heretics, because the first
baptism remains, for the gifts of God are without repentance. That is why the
35th of Carthage does not permit re-baptism of clergy deposed for crimes and
their return to clerical rank. One is purified from the defilement of heresy by
anathematizing that heresy, by worthy repentance, by the order of the
penitential prayers of Patriarch Methodios, which the Church reads over the
renouncers, and finally by the seal of Holy Chrism. After the proper trial and
the canon appointed by the spiritual father, and with the Body and Blood of the
Lord — ‘for the blood of Christ cleanses us from all sin’ (1 John 1). As for
the children of the Hagarenes who are baptized in our baptism not for pious
reasons but so their bodies not become diseased or foul-smelling, it was
synodally decided, under Patriarch Lord Loukas, that they are to be baptized a
second time, if they come to our faith, since in their baptism there was no
agreement in faith from their impious parents. Likewise, those who were
baptized by someone profane but falsely made to appear to be a priest must also
be baptized.” (Pēdalion, footnotes, pp. 55–58)
But even if we
hypothetically accept the “Mysteries valid by Economy,” a necessary condition
for the Mysteries that are invalid according to strictness to be valid by
Economy is that those who will make use of them must have repented for their
communion with heresy! What repentance, however, exists in them, since this economy
comforts them and, invoking inability, family or professional obligations,
etc., they continue to commune with the excommunicated Ecumenists? It must also
be emphasized that economy is a short-term deviation from the teaching
of the Church with the aim of returning to Exactness. We must therefore ask Fr.
Euthymios, as we have asked other priests and monks in the past: You, Fr.
Euthymios, how long will you apply economy? You have already surpassed
fifteen years. And when you return to Exactness — because you will have to,
rather, you should already have returned — after so many years of economy,
will you not then say that the Mysteries are invalid? Let those who will object
to this critique understand this, because one day they will wake up unbaptized
and unmarried due to the stance of one and only person whom they now follow as
an Elder. If, on the other hand, he remains in economy indefinitely, he
comes into sharp contradiction with what he has written — namely, that economy
lasts only a minimal amount of time — even accusing clergymen who apply economy
in matters of practical nature and not ecclesiological-dogmatic.
I present a libellus
addressed to Patriarch Menas of Constantinople. In it, the monks thank the
Patriarch (as well as Emperor Justinian) because they proceeded to examine the
case of the heretical Patriarch Anthimus, and after he "disobeyed,"
they condemned him. “We also thank,” they write, “God, because through the
Council He was pleased ‘to cleanse His Church and to present it to Himself as
always, glorious, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing of heretical
tares’” (T.L.G., Concilia Oecumenica (ACO): Synodus Constantinopolitana et
Hierosolymitana anno 536: Tome 3, page 38, line 31). Therefore, the Council
cleanses the Church of rotten members — the heretics — without the Church ever
losing Her undefiled character, even if some of Her members disobeyed and fell
away.
Extremely important
for all that we are discussing is the following explanation by St. Theophan the
Recluse concerning what the Church is and how she behaves toward heretics:
"What
is the Holy Church? It is a community of believers, united among themselves
with a unity of confession of divinely revealed truths, with a unity of
sanctification through divinely established Mysteries, and with a unity of
governance and guidance by shepherds given by God.
The
unity of confession, of sanctification, and of governance constitutes the
regulation of this community, which is obligatory for anyone who joins it. The
status of being a member of this community depends on the acceptance of this
regulation and agreement with it; remaining in this community depends on its
observance. Let us see how the Holy Church was formed and how it continues to
develop.
The
preachers preach. Some of the listeners do not accept the preaching and depart;
others accept it, and as a result of that acceptance, they are sanctified by
the holy Mysteries, follow the guidance of the shepherds, and thus are
incorporated into the holy Church – they are made members of the Church. This
is the way by which all members of the Church are introduced into It. Upon
their entrance, they are mingled with all Its members, united with them, and
they remain in the Church only as long as they continue to be one with all of
them.
Every
community has foundational regulations…
The
example of Arius.
Therefore,
for what reason can one criticize the holy Church when it acts in a similar
manner? In the end, an “anathema” is precisely a separation from the Church, or
an exclusion from it of those who do not fulfill the conditions of unity with
Her and begin to think differently from the way She thinks—differently from the
way they themselves promised to think at the time of their entrance into Her.
Remember
how it happened! Arius appeared, who maintained impious opinions concerning
Christ the Savior, so that with those views he distorted the very act of our
salvation. What happened to him? First, he was warned—and warned many times by
every possible means of persuasion and appeal. But since he obstinately
persisted in his opinion, he was condemned and became excommunicated from the
Church—that is: “he is expelled from our community. Take care not to have
communion with him and with those like him. Do not yourselves hold such
opinions, and do not listen to or accept those who do.” This is what the holy
Church did with Arius; this is what she has done with all other heretics; and
this is what she will also do now, likewise, if someone appears somewhere with
impious opinions. So, tell me, what is blameworthy here? What else could the
holy Church have done? And could she have continued to exist if she had not
applied such strictness and had not warned her children with such care against
those who might corrupt and destroy them? After all, robbers and thieves are
not allowed to continue freely and to go unpunished anywhere. And when they are
bound and handed over to the law and punishment, no one considers this to be
inhuman or a violation of freedom. On the contrary, people see in this very
action equally an act of love for mankind and a protection of
freedom—concerning all the members of society.
If
you judge thus in this case, judge likewise with regard to the community of the
Church. These false teachers, like thieves and robbers, plunder the property of
the holy Church and of God, corrupting her children and destroying them. Does
the holy Church err in judging them, binding them, and casting them out? And
would it truly be love for mankind if she were to look upon the actions of such
men with indifference and allow them the freedom to destroy everyone else?
Therefore, the Church declares them excommunicated, banishes them from her
ranks (when it is said, “Anathema upon so-and-so,” it means the same as
“So-and-so, out from here!”), or anathematizes for the same reason that any
community would do so. And she is obligated to do this in order to preserve
herself and to protect her children from destruction."
In all this, before
I begin, I want to add something else I thought of while reading all these
sources. Many times we rightly use the Pauline verse for walling off: “Even if
we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel other than the one we
preached to you, let him be anathema.” This passage is now used by the
supporters of invalid Mysteries, e.g., by Monk Makarios [of Koutloumousiou],
but also by Mr. Rizos, as proof of the invalidity of the Mysteries and of the
condemnation of the Ecumenists without a Synod. But even Fr. Euthymios himself
wrote in relation to this passage:
“One
of the most important passages of Holy Scripture, which speak clearly and
unambiguously about walling off and ecclesiastical separation from heretical
shepherds and Bishops, is also this teaching of the Apostle Paul. For here the
Apostle of the Gentiles does not require from the Orthodox only ecclesiastical
separation (walling off), but he goes even further to the anathematization of
every heterodox teaching and heresy and every heretic.
Anathematization,
at first, means both the temporary and the eternal separation, and the complete
severance and removal now and unto the ages of ages from Christ.
Anathematization differs from excommunication in that excommunication means
temporary and primarily pedagogical removal from the Church, from the
Mysteries, and from the assembly of the faithful for a certain period of time,
with the aim of repentance and correction, so that the eternal separation of
condemnation and punishment may be avoided. One therefore understands that
anathematization is the gravest and most severe condemnation, because it does
not have only a temporary dimension, but an eternal one.”
But Paul also says
in his First Epistle to the Corinthians 16:22: “If anyone does not love the
Lord Jesus Christ, let him be anathema.”
According to the
reasoning, then, of Fr. Euthymios, we must wall ourselves off, consider their
Mysteries invalid, and consider them outside the Church—all those who have weak
faith, do not love the Lord, do not keep His commandments, and may even, in a moment
of weakness, have lost their faith. But do we not thus become Montanists, and
do we not exclude from the Church every weak Christian? Are we perhaps strong?
Perhaps we need to reconsider how Paul understands the term anathema?
For St. Chrysostom advises us not to anathematize either the living or the
dead, and all Orthodox theologians clearly say that anathematization is solely
the prerogative of an Orthodox Synod.
St. Nikodemos, in
his interpretation of the Second Canon of the Sixth Ecumenical Council, writes:
“That is, if the Canon contains and prescribes excommunication, or deposition,
or anathema, these are also to be incurred by the one who corrupts and annuls
it” (p. 221).
It is clear here
that all three without distinction (as St. Nikodemos tells us) are imposed by
the Synod and not by just anyone or by the heretic himself. This means that the
general excommunication of the Apostle Paul or any anathema pronounced by a believer
has a different meaning (as the above texts mention), and not that these
anathemas cast the anathematized out of the Church.
I present yet
another example: In Fr. Euthymios’ reply to an Athonite monk on the P.P. blog,
and referring to St. Augustine, he wrote the following:
“Here,
St. Photius overturns certain arguments of the Latins, who presented some
Western Fathers (Ambrose, Augustine) as advocating and supporting the
procession of the Holy Spirit from the Son (Filioque). He thus states
that in this way the Latins dishonor their own Fathers, because they refer them
to the eternal anathema of the Apostle Paul, insofar as they legislate and
teach contrary to the evangelical proclamation. He states that the authority of
the Apostle Paul to bind and loose extends unto the kingdom of heaven, insofar
as he anathematizes even the angels, if they should teach men anything contrary
to the evangelical proclamation.”
So then, let me
understand: with these words, does the holy Augustine fall under Paul’s
anathema? If he made this mistake, is he under anathema?
The Fifth
Ecumenical Council accepted the writings of Augustine and Ambrose of the
West—not simply, but only those concerning the right faith, and they were set
forth for the refutation of the heretics (Pedalion, p. 221).
Since the above
excerpt cites St. Photius the Great as the basis of Fr. Euthymios’ preaching,
the truly Great Photius also wrote the following:
"Those
who are nourished in the Church and are not forgetful of sacred teachings know,
like Shem and Japheth, how to cover the shame of their father, and, condemning
the imitators of Ham, they turn away from them. For how many circumstances have
compelled many to say some things improperly, or to speak according to oikonomia,
or, being opposed by those who disobey, or, having slipped out of ignorance, as
is human. One contends against the heretizing, another yields to the weakness
of the listeners, another is occupied with some other matter and, having the
occasion that demands often a softening of precision for a greater end, said
and did things which it is not lawful for us either to say or to do… But if
they have spoken improperly, or for some reason now unknown to us have deviated
from the right path, and yet no investigation has been brought against them,
nor has anyone invited them to learn the truth — we will still call them
Fathers, even if they did not say this rightly, because of the brilliance of
their life, the reverence of their virtue, and the unblamable nature of their
piety otherwise; but the words in which they went astray, we will not follow…
And we, since we also find that some of our blessed Fathers and teachers in
many other matters deviated from the precision of right dogmas, do not accept
the deviation, but we embrace the men. Likewise, if any have happened to say
that the Spirit proceeds from the Son, we do not accept the statement contrary
to the Lord’s own words, but we do not exclude them from the company of the
Fathers."
And once again,
therefore, the need for a reexamination of this important issue is
demonstrated.
As an example of my
exhortation toward the reexamination and study of this specific subject, I cite
as a source also a study-position by Fr. Athanasios Siamakis, “The Being
Anathematized in the Canons.”
"At
first, it causes astonishment and eventually a headache for the interpreters
that many canons of the councils, in which the imposition of the two gravest
penalties is ordered—the ultimate and the penultimate—for the same offense it
is prescribed that laypeople be anathematized, but clergy be deposed; or at
other times, when it concerns only a cleric, it is ordered that for some
offense he be anathematized, but if he persists, he be deposed: 'If he persists
and continues to sin incorrigibly, then let him be deposed.' Why is it that for
the same offense, the layman—who, it is understood, is less responsible—is
anathematized (=ceases to be a member of the Church?), while the cleric—who is
more responsible—is only deposed from office, without ceasing to be a member of
the Church? And why is the cleric, at the first commission of some offense,
anathematized (=ceases to be a member of the Church?), and yet, upon
unrepentant continuation in his transgression, only deposed from his office?
And how is he deposed from the office, if he had already ceased to be a member
of the Church beforehand? As if we are speaking of imprisonment after the
execution of a death sentence (layman: 'let him be anathematized'; cleric: 'let
him be deposed'; Apostolic Canons 63, 64, 65, 66, 69, 70, 84; Seventh
Ecumenical Council, 5, 9, etc.: 'let him be anathematized, but if he persists,
let him be deposed'; Apostolic Canons 5, 30, 45, 58, 59, etc.).
And
just the overall meaning of the context allows us to understand that in these
canons the term "to be excommunicated" does not have the
meaning with which we use it today. In any case, to be excommunicated,
both in the Bible and in post-biblical Christian literature, has multiple
meanings. When Scripture says that Paul in Ephesus excommunicated the
disciples (Acts 19:9), it means that he separated the Christians from the Jews
after three months of joint gathering in the Jewish synagogue, where he had
entered with the aim of converting as many Jews as he could, and he
disconnected them from Judaism. When Paul says that the Lord set him apart
from his mother’s womb … so that he might preach Him (Gal. 1:15), or he
introduces himself as set apart for the gospel of God (Rom. 1:1), he
means that “he was chosen and marked out” for this work. When he says that
Peter in Antioch made the mistake of separating himself from the
uncircumcised Christians (Gal. 2:12), it means that Peter, on his own, with
certain incorrect distinctions that he suddenly began to make, “separated
himself from those Christians and avoided them.” When Christ in the Gospel of
Luke says, Blessed are you when men hate you and when they excommunicate you
(Luke 6:22), He means the word in the sense we understand it today—but of
course in reverse (when the wicked “excommunicate” the good). So the verb in
itself always has the same meaning of “to separate,” but within the surrounding
syntactic context it functions differently each time and serves a different
meaning. Sometimes it means that someone excommunicates (= separates) something
for good or for evil, sometimes that the good excommunicate (= cut off) the
wicked from the good, or the wicked excommunicate the good (to their own harm,
of course), sometimes that the good excommunicate themselves from the wicked,
sometimes that some excommunicate others temporarily or permanently, and for
abstention from one thing only or entirely, etc.
And
this latter case is exactly what occurs in the canons in question. The term “to
be excommunicated” in contrast with “to be deposed” means something
lighter—that is, for the layperson, it means “to be barred from the Divine
Eucharist for a period of time or until the eve of death, without ceasing to be
a member of the Church, even though punished”; for the clergyman, it means “to
become again non-communing, like the layman, and of course also inactive (in
his function), without being deposed from his rank, which will naturally again
be active and liturgical after serving his penance, with his repentance and
correction.” Thus, we understand how in these canons to be excommunicated
is spoken of as a lighter penalty than to be deposed, and therefore we
understand also that for the same offense the clergyman, as more responsible,
is punished more severely than the layman by being deposed, and how there is
mention of deposition after excommunication. This interpretation is also
found in Canon 6 of the Third Ecumenical Council, where the first expression is
found elaborated and verbally altered as: “if they be bishops or clerics,
let them be wholly deposed from their degree; but if laymen, let them be out of
communion.” And in Canon 8 of the Fourth Council, where it similarly says: “if
they be clerics, let them be subjected to the penalties of the canons; but if
monks or laymen, let them be out of communion.” And there is also the
enlightening formulation in the so-called Quinisext Council (Canon 27): “let
him be excommunicated for one week.” Finally, I must add that this to be
excommunicated is elsewhere also called to be anathematized, being
understood with the same temporary force, in Canons 7 of the Third and 27 of
the Fourth Ecumenical Councils. In one of these two canons it says: “let the
bishop be alienated from his episcopacy and be deposed, and let the cleric
likewise fall from the clergy, but if it be a layman, let him be anathematized”;
and in the other canon it says: “if they be clerics, let them fall from
their rank; but if laymen, let them be anathematized.” And the being
anathematized is understood as a temporary state of excommunication.
However,
since the canons were formulated over a period of approximately one thousand
years—within which fall the years 284–610, when the official language of
Byzantium was Greek for ecclesiastical use but Latin for state affairs, which
greatly altered the vernacular Greek—among other things, the meaning of “to
be excommunicated” became divided and limited; and in later ecclesiastical
texts it is found only with the meaning we are accustomed to today, which is
indeed already found in the Gospels (Luke 6:22)" (Symbolē 12, 2006).
Let us now begin
the examination of the passages of the book related to our subject.
On page 66 it
states: “All these legislate unlawfulness, institute another Gospel, and
consequently introduce us into another Church… or, as the Saint says in another
passage, they make the Church from spotless and undefiled, defiled and
polluted.” And on page 69 Fr. Euthymios returns to the subject, writing: “4.
The ‘Church’ (the quotation marks he uses are not understandable, since the
Saint did not use them nor did he intend them) ‘through the alteration of the
commandments, from spotless and undefiled, becomes defiled and polluted (this
is the spiritual defilement of the Church as the Body of Christ, that is, the
fornication of the Church)’.” Now Fr. Euthymios no longer uses quotation marks,
and the faithful no longer understand what he means by “Church.” Here arises
the logical question: how do the heretics make the Church defiled and polluted,
if they are outside the Church, as Fr. Euthymios says, and without valid
Mysteries? And how does the Saint say that the Church becomes from spotless and
undefiled, defiled and polluted, when the book claims that the Church is always
undefiled—though here Fr. Euthymios speaks of the Church’s fornication? Is this
not clearly a contradiction and a difference between the interpretation of the
author and the words of the Saint, but also between the two senses of the term
“Church” used by Fr. Euthymios? And naturally it must be repeated: How shall we
restore—assuming he is correct—and by what authority those who are committing
fornication against the Church, back into Her by economy, while they
have not repented, with “Mysteries valid by Economy”?
Concerning this,
St. Basil the Great writes in his commentary on the Prophet Isaiah:
“1.28:
You shall no longer trample My court.” A fearful threat to those who are aware.
But some from within the Church are insensible to this destruction, and those
who are able to resist it are negligent; while others, condemned on account of
sins, are indifferent. The passage indicates the insolent entrance of the
accused, as if they trample the holy things. The one who is perfect reaches
even into the Holy of Holies, beyond the veil—that is, having passed through
bodily things, he converses with the divine meanings through naked
contemplation; the lesser one, within the house of God, touches the sanctuary
according to the bodily worship; the one just now being introduced into piety
is permitted to be only in the court; and the one rejected even from this is
outside the places of piety. How great, then, is the danger—that even what one
seems to possess may be taken away. The Saint, however, who loves God
exceedingly, defends all the symbols of God, saying: “My soul longs and faints
for the courts of the Lord.” For he knows that otherwise it is impossible to
blossom forth and to begin to bear fruit, unless one is found in the courts of
the Lord. And God, in His beneficence toward them, removes them from the Jewish
court so that they may take refuge in the court of Christ’s sheep, and so there
may be one flock, one shepherd... As long as we are branches remaining in the
vine, in Christ, bearing the fruits expected of us, we have God as a
cultivator; but if we depart from the life-giving root—which is faith in
Christ—then drying up, we are cast out and burned. And the building up of our
edification through teaching is destroyed if we live contrary to duty. For if
we do not remain upon the foundation of the Apostles, building upon it precious
things, then being without a foundation, we are torn down, and our fall becomes
great; as if wantonness were devouring chastity, and greed the simplicity in
giving, and hatred the love of neighbor. It is therefore pitiable that the
soul, flourishing in the fruit-bearing of good things, becomes a prey to
opposing forces, who are not satisfied with merely desolating us unless they
also bring about our complete destruction. Destruction takes place through evil
teachings, as though the soul of those led astray were being razed to the
ground; whereas desolation is the deprivation of previously acquired virtues.
And this happens easily in regard to the human soul. Behold, for example, a
certain young man brought up from childhood in a modest life, diligently
frequenting houses of prayer, not neglecting acts of kindness to the extent of
his ability, mindful of eternal judgment, holding fast to the word of teaching.
Then, having slipped into fornication—how, after the annihilation of chastity
and the desolation of his fruits...
It
is sometimes said even concerning the Church (which may it never be said of
ours), “How has the faithful city Zion become a harlot?” When, casting
off the word of faith (to whom from the beginning, according to the tradition
of the Fathers, she was betrothed—those who presented her as a pure virgin to
one Husband), she receives many and various seeds of word from those who have
prostituted the modesty of the mysteries, and who scatter the doctrines of
impiety for the corruption of souls. It shall be said even of her, and justly
so: “How has the faithful city Zion become a harlot?” For the holy
Angels, entrusted with the protection of the Churches, knowing the former
things and observing also the present, shall say in astonishment: “How has
the faithful city become a harlot?” From her harlotry, having also gathered
murderers—not murderers of bodies but of souls—who, with deceit and fraud, take
away the life of the simple, as it were with a sword, the word sharpened by the
wisdom of the world for persuasion, they inflict deadly wounds upon souls. Then
comes the rendering of the cause—on account of which reason the formerly
faithful became a harlot." (M. Basil, Interpretation on the Prophet
Isaiah, Prologue, PG 30, pp. 117–668)
Here we see the
Saint teaching that—contrary to the preaching of Fr. Euthymios, as well as of
the supporters of invalid Mysteries—the vineyard of the prophet Isaiah also
refers to the Church, whose branches, when they do not bear fruit and stray
from the correct teaching of the Lord, wither, are cast out of Her, and are
burned. By whom are they cast out, if not by the synod? For if every believer,
whether in cassock or lay, begins to anathematize and consider the
heretical-leaning or heretical shepherd as being outside the Church and without
Mysteries, then chaos would prevail in the Church.
The Saint also
tells us that when members of the Church—and especially Her shepherds—accept
teachings that oppose Her dogmas and murder the souls of the simple faithful,
then “she who was formerly faithful has become a harlot,” yet without the Truth
and Her undefiled character being lost, as long as there are confessors of the
Faith. God does not accept these violators of His teaching—not only the
heretics but also the unrepentant sinners. These shall not enter into the Holy
of Holies. They remain in the court as branches not bearing fruit, dried up.
Here we can understand how the Saints mean the phrase “you are not the Church”
concerning those who are heretics not yet judged. Nevertheless, the Grace of
God does not disappear—by the Economy of God, and not of any one of us—for the
aid of the weak, as we will read further below from the prologue of the same
homily of St. Basil the Great.
“There
is also prophecy in foreknowledge through dreams, as was shown to Joseph in
Egypt and to Daniel in Babylon. But how, then, also to Pharaoh and to
Nebuchadnezzar? Because those who held power over worldly affairs needed to
foresee them, so that it would be believed. And how is it that Balaam and
Caiaphas also prophesy? Because they too had people who were persuaded by
them—the one as high priest, the other as a diviner. For here it is not a
matter of purity of soul, nor the clarity of a mind that sees God and draws
power from there, but the word [of prophecy] occurs in them by economy, not
according to their worthiness, but according to the occasion.”
So then, it is not
from purity of soul or from knowledge of God that God allows the unworthy to
prophesy (as a sign of grace), but by His own Economy (and not by the arbitrary
economy of any Priest, whoever he may be), the reason for which is known only to
God, and according to the circumstances of the times.
The same
contradiction between the words and writings of Fr. Euthymios appears on pages
70 and 71. Fr. Euthymios writes: “Heresy through the shepherds became the line
of the Church” and “These heresies in the practical realm and in the life of
the Church.” When I read these things, I do not understand the supporters of
invalid Mysteries, nor Fr. Euthymios himself—why do you disagree and consider
the supporters of valid Mysteries to be opposed to the scriptural and patristic
Tradition, when in fact both sides say the same thing: namely, that heretics,
of course, do not express the truth and spirit of the Church—on this point, of
course, they do not belong to the Church—but until their synodal judgment (this
is where we differ), they remain members of Her both institutionally and
essentially, though they defile Her, and that is why we wall ourselves off.
St. Basil the
Great, in his 66th epistle to St. Athanasius the Great, writes—describing the
condition of the Church and admitting the opposite of what Fr. Euthymios
claims:
“…Many
times, gathering myself together, I have wondered: if the deviation of our
Churches is so tearfully evident, how can it not be felt by anyone who has a
deep knowledge of the former stability and concord in the faith, which adorned
the Churches of God?…
Order
in the Church of Antioch, however, depends on your God-revering disposition—so
that you may guide some, calm others, and restore strength to the Church
through concord… And among the Churches of the world, what is more urgent and
more serious than Antioch? If it happens to return to unity, nothing would
prevent it—as a vigorous head—from imparting health to the whole body. And
truly, the ailments of that city need your wisdom and evangelical compassion.
For it has not only been torn apart by heretics, but is also divided by those
who say among themselves that they are of the same mind…
(1).
The East in general was deeply shaken in the past by Arianism, now by the
pro-Arian policy of the emperors and the internal schisms, especially the
schism of Antioch, in which four bishops were claiming the throne…"
(Epistles and other texts, publ. Apostoliki Diakonia , 1980)
Reading this
epistle, many conclusions related to our subject emerge:
Saint Basil the
Great speaks of deviation, weakness, sickness, and the fragmentation of the
Churches. Did he perhaps question the infallibility of the Church? Did he
degrade the Church by characterizing it as not being a God-man body? Did he
question Her ultimate victory? Of course not. His entire struggle was centered
on the victory of the Church. However, he did not speak of invalid Mysteries of
those not yet condemned heretics. Yet he knew that within Her there were rotten
members, who had to be expelled synodally and in unity. This is what he
pursued. Gerasimos Konidaris writes:
“b)
From the Westerners he requested intervention and cooperation with the Orthodox
of the East for the support of Orthodoxy, through meetings and especially
synodical ones. The first letter, the 70th, written in the autumn of 371, that
is, one year after Basil’s ascent to the metropolitan throne of Caesarea, bears
the characteristic title ‘Untitled concerning a Synod.’ The letter is
considered to be addressed to Damasus of Rome, whom he calls in his 239th
letter to Eusebius of Samosata in the year 376 the ‘chief of the West.’ Basil
requests serious assistance, which should take the form of a visit by envoys
from the West to investigate the conditions of life of the Orthodox, a renewal
of the ancient patristic bonds between East and West and of the old love for
the restoration of peace, since the Churches of the East were being shaken by
the dreadful storm caused by the spread of the Arian heresy supported by
Valens. In the West, the orthodox Valentinian I (364–375) was reigning as
Augustus. ‘The Westerners had to make clear to themselves the cause of the
disorder in the East and to know precisely who were the Orthodox in the East
with whom they could have “communion”’—he meant of the Divine Eucharist. He
requested nothing new, but a return to the ancient tradition of Orthodoxy and
the philanthropy of Dionysius of Rome, who at that time, in the third century,
communicated with the Metropolis of Caesarea. Basil believed that it was the
final hour for coming to aid and rallying the Orthodox of East and West.”
(Gerasimos Konidaris, The Second Ecumenical Council (381): Triumph of the
Ecumenical Ecclesiastical Policy of Saint Basil the Great (+378), p. 70)
Saint Basil the
Great speaks of the existence of four bishops in Antioch: two Orthodox (Saint
Meletius and Paulinus), one Arian (Dorotheus, successor of Euzoïus), and one
Apollinarian (Vitalius).
Here we must
reasonably ask both Fr. Euthymios and all the supporters of invalid Mysteries:
with which bishop—or, in any case, where—was the Church, and whose Mysteries
were valid? With one, with two, with three? With Saint Meletios, whom Saints
Basil and Athanasius supported? With Paulinos, whom the Western bishops
supported—many of whom were Saints—who even led Saint Athanasius astray? Later,
with Lucifer, who did not recognize valid Mysteries among the
"Meletians"? But even later, with Flavian, whom the Second Ecumenical
Council chose, or did it remain with Paulinos, who did not recognize Flavian
(as also the Church of Rome and of Alexandria did not)?
Is it not evident
that only the synod (after many discussions) finally resolved the matter, while
previously many personal choices had made its resolution more difficult?
The same applies in
the case of Saint Gregory the Theologian or of John Chrysostom: Was Saint
Gregory the Church and did he have valid Mysteries, or was it Saint Ambrose of
Milan, who did not even recognize him as archbishop? Was it Chrysostom or Saint
Cyril of Alexandria, who did not accept and did not commemorate Saint
Chrysostom for so many years?
Naturally, all were
members of the Church, and the various unhealthy situations were resolved by a
synod, which settled misunderstandings, restored the Orthodox, and expelled the
heretics.
The solution that
was proposed to Fr. Euthymios and his circle was so accommodating: although all
those who had walled themselves off (except for those influenced by Makarios,
Nektarios, and the clergy and laity who follow or agree with them) consider the
Mysteries of the heretics to be valid, it was practically evident that they
avoided engaging in the discussion about invalid Mysteries. The dominant
tendency (even within the circle of Fr. Euthymios) was that our responsibility
is the walling off, through which we avoid the defilement of communion with the
heretical ecumenists, we offer our confession, and we contribute as much as
possible to the awakening of the faithful, so that a Synod may be demanded. All
of this functions as an informal pre-synodal preparation within the body of the
faithful, clergy and laity. The rest are matters for a Synod. Besides, whether
the Mysteries are valid or, supposing they are invalid, this (as already
stated) is of no concern to those who have walled themselves off, but only to
those who commune with the ecumenists. And the objection that is heard — that
if we accept them as valid, we prevent people from walling themselves off — is
from the evil one! The faithful never compromise on a doctrinal-ecclesiological
issue out of fear of scandalizing! The practice and teaching of the Saints is
more than sufficient for the well-disposed faithful, and it is repeatedly
demonstrated: communion with heretics defiles and contributes to the dominance
of heretics. Those who are not convinced of this are worthy of the consequences
of communion with heretics!
We continue with
the examination of the book.
On page 111, it is
admitted that there is heresy in the Church:
“But
when we Orthodox today teach that there is heresy in the Church, that is, there
is a deadly, infectious disease…”
And here the above
still applies.
On page 163:
“(The
Venerable one) pleads (with the magister Stephanos) to assist in the
restoration of the local Church, which, due to heresy, is ‘lying on the
ground,’ that is, it has fallen and is no longer a Church.”
Here again is
presented an interpretation which, I regret to say, is cut and tailored to the
author's opinion. For the Venerable one, in the source cited, does not even
remotely state that the Church lying on the ground is no longer a Church, but
vividly conveys to the Magister the ailing condition of ecclesiastical
affairs—just as St. Basil the Great did in the passages we saw above, or as St.
Gregory who described the Church as a ship leaking from all sides—both of them
seeking help, e.g., from Western bishops or imperial officials. In the same
way, St. Theodore pleads with the Magister: “stretch forth your hand to the
Church among us, lying on the ground, as much as possible.”
Also, how is it to
be explained that the Venerable One writes a supplicatory letter asking for
help from someone who not only—if I remember correctly—had taken part in the
synod of 809 which acquitted Joseph (“with the participation of the three
highest-ranking officials,” ep. no. 4891-92; see also ep. no. 3425), but who,
according to Fr. Euthymios, was outside the Church, since he was in communion
with the members of that synod?
A similar answer
must be given to the question of how the Ecumenists are outside the Church,
when in Fr. Euthymios’ dialogues with the G.O.C. he rightly accused them of
having a parallel synod, which is not permitted by the Holy Canons and
constitutes a schism, since first “the previous heretical synod must be
lawfully abolished” (p. 186). [sic] Has the synod been abolished?
The same is also written
on page 187:
“we
create another Church, which may preserve the Orthodox faith, but not Orthodox
ecclesiology.”
And in the two
previous examples it is confessed in writing that the heretics belong to the
Church until their synodal condemnation, and that the issue of Orthodox
ecclesiology is above the issue of Orthodox faith, and for this reason the
schismatic G.O.C. are in error. [sic]
From page 197, a
presentation begins of the description of the Church’s condition during the
time of the Saint by the Saint himself, which again proves that the heretics
still belong to the Church and that the Church has not ceased to be the Church:
“fierce wolves have leapt into the flock (Church), and a wild boar has torn it
apart… the shepherds have been overcome by folly… the priests are acting
unlawfully and the monks likewise.”
On page 199, an
important confession of the Saint is mentioned:
“The
storm of heresy is in full fury and constantly growing, and there is no one to
awaken Christ so that He may rebuke this evil sea of heresy.”
It is truly
frightening. The Saint here confesses indirectly but most clearly that Christ
is asleep. Therefore, this saying of the Saint does not align with what has
been proven through so many pages up to now: that Christ, for a reason known
only to Him, permits heretics to exist within His Church. So then, who are we
to place the heretics — whom He permits — outside the Church and without
Mysteries, until Christ awakens? Isn’t such a position a misinterpretation of
the Saint’s words?
In order not to be
long-winded, I will mention the pages where the same contradictions continue:
203, 211, 212, 224, 225, 242, 245, 261, 269, 273, 313, 318, 319, 323, 338, 346,
352, 353.
In fact, on page
339 it is written:
“This
new Church has one thing in common with the timeless Orthodox [Church], which
is likely to lead many to identify it with her — namely, it has the apostolic
succession of the priesthood.”
If this is so, then
how does Fr. Euthymios maintain that this Church has no Mysteries, when the
priesthood is itself a Mystery and when apostolic succession is cited by St.
Nikodemos as a primary condition for the validity of the Mysteries?
With these critical
remarks I conclude this work, which, I repeat, was written out of obedience in
the pursuit of truth and out of love, for true love is always founded upon and
has as its common point of reference the truth. I have written the same to other
respected priests, offering them criticism not out of disrespect, but for the
above reasons.
I conclude with the
sermon of an enlightened elder of our century, Fr. Athanasios Mitilinaios. In
it, each one of us will observe that the Synod is the highest authority in the
Church, that we are not misinterpreting but professing what we were taught by
Orthodox priests, that if those who insist on the position of invalid Mysteries
persist—which, apart from the Matthewites, not even the G.O.C. support anymore,
only they support it—they proclaim not only us as being outside the spirit of
the Church but also recognized figures, and they turn the Church into a
collection of individuals where each one says and believes whatever he wants,
and that the only one who ultimately expresses it is one together with the
00.1%.
For they cannot
deny—it is not possible to deny—that neither St. Justin Popović, nor St. John
Maximovitch, nor the Synod of ROCOR that condemned Ecumenism, nor Fr. Seraphim
Rose, nor Fr. Athanasios of Mytilene, nor Fr. Georgios Capsanis, nor Fr. Daniel
of Katounakia, nor St. Paisios, St. Porphyrios, St. Iakovos Tsalikis, Fr.
Philotheos Zervakos, P. Chrestou, S. Papadopoulos, P. Trembelas, Fr. Theodoros
Zisis, I. Kornarakis—to mention only a few Saints, or enlightened or at least
recognized theologians of our century who exposed Ecumenism as a pan-heresy and
dealt with its nature, condemned it, and warned us—none of them taught what
these people are saying: that there are no uncondemned heretics and that the
Mysteries of the Ecumenists are invalid or only valid by oikonomia
before their synodal condemnation. In fact, they present no other interpreter
for what they claim besides themselves. Therefore, for them, no one, however
enlightened or knowledgeable over the past hundred years, spoke the truth
except they themselves. Only they understood St. Theodore the Studite. Only
they clearly present the Patristic teaching.
Let it be noted
especially that the position regarding “Mysteries valid by oikonomia” is
even more erroneous, because, although it is ecclesiologically untenable, even
if it were tenable, it would have to be decided by an Ecumenical Council, since
it changes the dogmatic teaching of the Church and is not a matter of oikonomia.
However, it has not even been decided by a synaxis of those who have walled
themselves off, but only by a single priest. And although in his last homily he
said that it constitutes his proposal to be decided by a synaxis, he has been
expressing and applying it for years, presenting himself as something beyond a
Council—just as unfortunately other priests do in many matters—fragmenting the
anti-heretical struggle and scandalizing the unfortunate flock!
Fr. Athanasios
Mitilinaios writes in Homily 158 (arnion.gr, 13 Oct 91, Acts 15:15–20):
“‘For
it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us’ means: for it seemed good to the
Holy Spirit and to us men, etc. It is not a matter of contradiction—that is,
that what was decided was divinely inspired in relation to the personal opinion
of James—but the decision may resemble that of Saint James. That is, what Saint
James said, that is what was done. Pay attention to this phrase I will tell
you: the decision ‘is in the Holy Spirit in the conciliar form.’ Of course,
someone proposes something… Saint Athanasius the Great said ‘such and such’ at
the Ecumenical Council. His opinion had no authority. When the Council accepted
what Saint Athanasius said, then it acquires canonical status, canonical
authority. Therefore, what Saint Athanasius the Great said may have been
divinely inspired, BUT ONLY IN THE CONCILIAR FORM COULD IT STAND WITHIN THE
CHURCH.
It
may have been divinely inspired, what Saint James said at the Apostolic
Council, but only insofar as it would enter into the conciliar form. And what
did he say? The wording is not “it seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to me,
James,” who was probably the president of the council, but to us. You see? To
us. That is how important this is.
O
beloved ones, this thing I now tell you, so very important—if it had been
observed throughout the history of the Church, WE WOULD NOT HAVE HAD QUARRELS
until today, until today, until today! I underline and emphasize this.
(…)
The
Church is infallible; the persons are not infallible. The Church is infallible.
Often in the Fathers of our Church we encounter some personal interpretations.
This does not mean that the Church is bound to accept them. Holy Fathers may
have an interpretation which is not correct—if you like, even heretical. The
Church never accepted their opinion. They are Saints because they did not say
“we want to be outside the Church.” It was an erroneous position. I told you
this so that you may understand how: “when the Church accepts the positions of
the Fathers, then that is infallible.” Because I repeat, there are opinions of
Fathers that are not very correct, or not correct at all, or only slightly
correct. Yes! In order to understand what ‘Conciliar form’ means, what in other
words ‘Church’ means.
And
what does the marvelous Saint James now judge? “Wherefore I judge that we
trouble not them, who from among the Gentiles are turning to God” (Acts 15:19).
If the synod accepts this, it is within the conciliar form and then it is
infallible. If the Church in synod does not accept it, then it is set aside.
The
conclusion of Saint James is based, as I already told you (homily 157 Acts –
arnion.gr), on the prophecies and on the events, which were set forth in detail
by the Apostles Peter, Paul, and Barnabas."
It has been
demonstrated, I believe, that the books (as well as his homily concerning St.
Theodore the Studite, concerning the Ecumenists and concerning the Mysteries)
of Fr. Euthymios, and the teachings he bases upon them regarding the Mysteries,
need reexamination and correction on this matter of the Mysteries, as it has
become evident that St. Theodore the Studite did not teach as the author
erroneously and without other patristic proofs interprets—causing confusion and
division in the flock—and he did not depart from the agreement of the Fathers,
who distinguished between condemned and not-yet-condemned heretics, spoke of
tares and those committing fornication, rotten members of the Church, with whom
we ought not to have ecclesiastical communion and who, if they do not repent,
must be cut off from the all-holy Body of the Church. Until then, however, and
in contrast to the condemned heretics and schismatics, they have valid
Mysteries which bring defilement and condemnation to those who knowingly
commune with them.
I hope that this
study will help in the manifestation and the defense of the Truth! I also hope
that this study will help Fr. Euthymios to correct that which led him to uphold
his erroneous position concerning the Mysteries, so that—he as well as all the
struggling fathers and brethren, laying aside our individual views—we may unite
(after meeting and agreeing, as the Church commands) upon the line of the Holy
Fathers and thus show, as the Lord wills, that we are His disciples, that “we
are one,” because then we shall also draw His Grace.
Greek
sources:
Part
1 https://web.archive.org/web/20231121100932/https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/06/blog-post_764.html
Part
2 https://web.archive.org/web/20231121101400/https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/06/blog-post_279.html
Part
3 https://web.archive.org/web/20231123190736/https://eugenikos.blogspot.com/2020/06/blog-post_176.html
