
The Synod of Bishops of the
Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia observes with sorrow the
ever-increasing attacks in the press upon lawful ecclesiastical authority in
connection with certain measures taken by the Church concerning its cleric,
Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe), and certain institutions with which he was
associated.
Not wishing to provoke
controversy in the secular press over matters of a purely ecclesiastical and
administrative nature, the Church has hitherto refrained from making public the
documents and facts in its possession concerning the case of Archimandrite
Anthony. However, in view of the ever more widespread rumors circulating among
our flock, apparently originating from circles hostile to the Holy Church, and
wishing to protect our God-loving flock from spiritually harmful
misinformation, the Synodal Chancery is compelled to bring the following to the
attention of the clergy and faithful children of the Russian Orthodox Church
Outside of Russia:
1. At its meeting in Mansonville, Quebec, Canada, in September
1985, the Council of Bishops, after hearing a report from the Head of the
Russian Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem, Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe),
appointed a Commission consisting of Archbishop Anthony of Los Angeles and
Southern California, Archbishop Laurus of Syracuse and Holy Trinity, and Bishop
Hilarion of Manhattan, to audit Archimandrite Anthony’s financial and
administrative affairs as Head of the Mission.
2. At the end of October 1985, the members of the Commission
visited Jerusalem for three weeks, during which they began an audit of the
financial accounts of the Russian Ecclesiastical Mission, examined the
available documents, and personally questioned Archimandrite Anthony on various
matters relating to the audit.
3. The Commission found the financial records of the Russian
Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem to be in a chaotic state, despite the fact
that the Auditing Commission of 1973 had given Archimandrite Anthony precise
instructions on how to rectify the accounting procedures. For example, there
was no income-and-expenditure ledger at all, and certain very large sums of
Church money went directly into Fr. Anthony’s personal account. There were also
numerous deficiencies relating to other financial matters and the sale of land
belonging to the Mission. The Commission’s report on Fr. Anthony, which
detailed clear breaches by Archimandrite Anthony of his obligations to
safeguard Russian Church property (known in American legal terminology as
fiduciary responsibilities), was presented to the Council of Bishops of the
Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia, held in New York City in the latter
half of January 1986. On the basis of this report, and after prolonged
discussion, the Council asked Fr. Anthony to resign from his duties in the
Russian Ecclesiastical Mission in Jerusalem and the Orthodox Palestine Society
and, by its resolution of January 21/February 3, relieved him of those duties.
4. At its meeting on March 14/27 of this year in Montreal, the
Synod of Bishops continued its examination of Archimandrite Anthony’s case and
issued a resolution setting forth in detail his violations of a number of
canons and ecclesiastical regulations. In that resolution, the Synod requested
its President, His Eminence Metropolitan Vitaly, under whose authority
Archimandrite Anthony was serving, to suspend him from priestly ministry until
Fr. Anthony had fully resolved all the matters set forth in the Synod’s
resolution.
5. After Bright Week of this year, Metropolitan Vitaly suspended
Archimandrite Anthony from priestly ministry pending a decision in his case by
an ecclesiastical court.
6. Meanwhile, Archimandrite Anthony, without the blessing of his
ecclesiastical authorities, flew to Belgrade to petition Serbian Patriarch
German to receive him into the jurisdiction of the Serbian Orthodox Church. The
representative of the Serbian Church in the United States, Bishop Christopher,
in a letter to Metropolitan Vitaly dated May 7 of this year, expressed his
willingness to receive Archimandrite Anthony into his diocese, provided that
the latter obtained a canonical release from his ecclesiastical superiors. In a
letter dated May 23/July 5 of this year, Metropolitan Vitaly replied to Bishop
Christopher that, so long as Archimandrite Anthony remained under suspension
and was subject to an ecclesiastical investigation, the Synod could not issue
him a letter of canonical release.
7. At the same time, Archimandrite Anthony submitted a petition to
His Eminence Metropolitan Vitaly requesting his transfer to the Serbian
Orthodox Church. The petition was considered at a meeting of the Synod of
Bishops held in Mansonville on May 16/29 of this year, and Archimandrite
Anthony was given the following instructions:
a) As long as you remain under
suspension, there can be no question of your release to another Local Orthodox
Church.
b) The Synod of Bishops considers the
explanations submitted by you on May 9/22, 1986, unsatisfactory, since they
neither constitute a substantive response to the resolution of the Synod of
Bishops of March 14/27, 1986, nor remedy the violations enumerated in that
resolution.
c) As a monk and cleric bound to
obedience to your ecclesiastical authorities, you are instructed to relinquish
your duties as Director of St. Sergius Gymnasium at the conclusion of the
academic year (in June 1986).
d) You are temporarily placed under the
authority of His Grace Bishop Mark, to serve as custodian of Church property in
Wiesbaden, and are to reside in the Church house there, to which you are
instructed to relocate within one month after the conclusion of the current
academic year.
e) The Synod of Bishops directs you to
cease immediately all activity, whether direct or indirect, relating to the
affairs of the Orthodox Palestine Society.
f) You are given until the beginning of
September 1986, according to the New Calendar, to provide a substantive
response and resolve the matters enumerated in the resolution of March 14/27 of
this year.
8. Instead of submitting, as a monk and clergyman, to his
ecclesiastical superiors and humbly accepting his new assignment and the other
instructions, Archimandrite Anthony, on his own authority and unlawfully,
withdrew from obedience to the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia and
was likewise unlawfully received by Metropolitan Paisios, a Greek Old
Calendarist hierarch in Astoria, New York.
For a number of reasons, the
Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia has not been in Eucharistic communion
with this branch of the Greek Old Calendarists since 1974. The 1969 decree
recognizing the Old Calendarists, published in Novoye Russkoye Slovo
(New Russian Word) on June 29 of this year, ceased to have effect after they
violated the terms of the agreement in 1974.
Archimandrite Anthony’s
unauthorized transfer and his unlawful reception by Metropolitan Paisios
violate the following ecclesiastical canons, which state:
“If any
Presbyter, or Deacon, or anyone at all enrolled among the clergy, shall leave
his own district and depart to another, and, having permanently removed, shall
reside in another place without the consent of his own Bishop, we command that
such a one shall no longer be permitted to serve, especially if he has
disobeyed his Bishop when summoned to return. But if he persists in this
disorder, let him remain there in communion as a layman.” (Apostolic Canon 15.)
“But if the
Bishop with whom such persons happen to be shall disregard the prohibition
against serving imposed upon them and receive them as members of the clergy,
let him be excommunicated as a teacher of disorder.” (Apostolic Canon 16.)
“If any
clergyman or layman who has been excluded from ecclesiastical communion, or who
is unworthy of reception into the clergy, shall depart and be found in another
city without letters commendatory, let both the one who receives him and the
one who is received be excommunicated.” (Apostolic Canon 12.)
The statements by Metropolitan
Paisios and Archimandrite Anthony that the latter was subjected to an unjust
ecclesiastical trial do not correspond to the facts, since no ecclesiastical
trial of Archimandrite Anthony has yet taken place; there has only been a
preliminary investigation.
9. The Secretary of the Synod of Bishops, His Eminence Archbishop
Laurus, sent a written protest to the First Hierarch of the Greek Old
Calendarists in Athens, Archbishop Chrysostomos, concerning the unlawful
interference of a member of his Synod in the affairs of the Russian Orthodox
Church Outside of Russia. On June 19 (Old Style), the Greek Archbishop
Chrysostomos and Bishop Kallinikos sent the Secretary of our Synod a copy of
their letter to Metropolitan Paisios, in which they gave him the following
directive:
“In view of our
desire to restore canonical relations with the Synod [of the Russian Orthodox
Church Outside of Russia], which were broken off as a result of the
ill-considered actions of the former Archbishop, now Monk Auxentios Pastras,
the Holy Synod [of the Greek Old Calendarists], at its meeting of June 18/July
1 of this year, unanimously issued a statement opposing the reception of
Archimandrite Anthony Grabbe into communion. You should bear in mind that any
adverse action on your part will hinder efforts to restore good relations
between our Church and our sister Church, the Russian Orthodox Church Outside
of Russia.”
Thus, even Metropolitan Paisios’s
own ecclesiastical authorities acknowledged the unlawfulness of his actions.
10. According to reliable information, Archimandrite Anthony, while
under ecclesiastical suspension, has begun performing sacred services and
intends to establish a new schismatic parish under the jurisdiction of
Metropolitan Paisios. According to the understanding of the Orthodox Church,
such divine services and Mysteries performed by clergy under suspension are
devoid of grace and constitute sacrilege. Such conduct on the part of Archimandrite
Anthony, should he remain unrepentant, will inevitably entail the severest
ecclesiastical disciplinary measures, up to and including deposition from the
sacred rank.
The Synod of Bishops warns its
faithful children not to enter into any prayerful or liturgical communion with
Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe) as long as he remains in schism from his lawful
ecclesiastical superiors. According to Apostolic Canon 10:
“If anyone shall
pray with a person excommunicated from ecclesiastical communion, even in a
private house, let him also be excommunicated.”
11. This brief account of the facts and circumstances concerning
the case of Archimandrite Anthony (Grabbe) is presented to our faithful to
clarify the matter, together with a request for their holy prayers that the one
who has gone astray may be brought to understanding.
Chancery of the Synod of Bishops
Translator’s notes
1.
The first canonical quotation in §8 is from Apostolic Canon 15. The Russian
text cites it as “Апост. пр. 5,” apparently omitting the digit 1. The English
text identifies the correct canon; the Russian original is preserved unchanged
below.
2.
In §6, the date “May 23/July 5” is reproduced exactly as printed in the Russian
text. This is not a normal Old Style/New Style date pair; the intended date has
not been independently established.
Russian
source: “Statement of the Chancery of the Synod of Bishops of the Russian
Orthodox Church Outside of Russia,” Church Life (Церковная жизнь), Jordanville,
1986, Nos. 5–6 and 7–8, pp. 74–78.
Also
see: https://orthodoxmiscellany.blogspot.com/2025/09/on-life-of-archimandrite-anthony-grabbe.html
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.