Monday, October 6, 2025

Discourse on Divine, Demonic, and Senseless Zeal

Archbishop Nikephoros (Theotokis) of Astrakhan and Stavropol (+1800)

 

 

Have you heard, my beloved brethren, what is narrated in the Apostolic reading that was read today? It says that the High Priest and those rulers who were with him were filled with envy—that is, with zeal (Acts 5:17). But what does “zeal” mean, and what kind of zeal did those wicked men have? Zeal, as its very name indicates, means fervor and ardor: and when our heart burns with love for God, then with great fervency we strive for truth, for righteousness, for the law of God, and for God Himself: “I have been very zealous for the Lord God of Hosts,” said Elias the Tishbite (3 Kings 19:10 [1 Kings 19:10 in Western Bibles]). But when our heart is filled with corrupt passions, then with fervor we defend falsehood, injustice, the works of the devil, and even Satan himself. Of such zeal, the brother of the Lord, James, said the following: “For where envy and zeal are, there is disorder and every evil deed” (James 3:16). Thus, from fragrant woods, when they are set on fire, a pleasant aroma comes forth, but from foul-smelling ones, a stench offensive to the senses arises. Likewise, when our heart burns with Divine love, our deeds are virtuous; but when it is inflamed with passions, then our deeds are sinful. Thus, there are two kinds of zeal: one Divine, and the other demonic. The first dwells in the heart of virtuous people; the second, in the soul of the corrupt.

The Jewish High Priest of that time was angry and corrupt, and the leaders of the Jewish assembly were for the most part heretics, deceitful men, and among the most wicked. Therefore, their hearts were filled with demonic zeal. They were filled with envy and zeal. And what were the works of such zeal? They laid their lawless hands and cast into prison those preachers of the truth, those luminaries of the universe, those vessels of the Most Holy Spirit, those thunder-voiced trumpets of salvation, those benefactors of mankind—whom God, as being above all men on earth both in faith and in holiness of life, chose from the world. And even after this, when the Almighty God delivered these divine teachers from prison by His Angel, they—being enflamed with demonic zeal—drag them before their lawless tribunals, brazenly revile them, cruelly beat them, and finally forbid them with threats to preach the most holy name of Jesus Christ, that thus the entire human race might be deprived of salvation.

In the history of the all-glorious Prophet Elias, one can observe the workings of both kinds of zeal. There, one may discern how divine and demonic zeal contend with one another: a blind attachment to her own delusion stirred up in the heart of Jezebel a demonic zeal for idolatry, while the holy deeds of virtue kindled in the soul of the Prophet Elias a divine zeal for piety. Jezebel corrupts Ahab, her husband and king, uproots from his heart the reverence for the true God, and in its place plants raging idolatry, making him a tool of her wicked desires. But Elias reproves Ahab: “Thou art the troubler,” he tells him, “of Israel, and thy father’s house, in that ye have forsaken the Lord your God and followed Baal” (3 Kings 18:18). And he prophetically threatens Jezebel as well: “The dogs,” he says, “shall eat the flesh of Jezebel, and her corpse shall be as dung upon the face of the field in the portion of Jezreel, so that they shall not say: This is Jezebel” (4 Kings 9:36–37). Jezebel’s demonic zeal raises up an idol to Baal and idolatrous altars in the grove; she establishes four hundred and fifty prophets of Baal, and four hundred of the grove (3 Kings 18:22), and prepares for them a daily lavish banquet. She persecutes and slays the prophets of the true God, torments and corrupts the pious, to such an extent that she nearly turns all away from true worship: for from the many thousands upon thousands of that people, only seven thousand remained who had not bowed the knee to Baal, nor worshipped him as God (3 Kings 19:18). But against all this rises up the divine zeal of Elias. Elias goes without fear to Ahab to announce to him the punishment of God for the ungodliness of the people. Elias, man of God! Art thou going to Ahab? “He made a grove and added to provoke the Lord God of Israel to anger, and destroyed his own soul; he did more evil than all the kings of Israel that were before him” (3 Kings 16:33). And thou goest to him to speak in the name of the God of Israel? How fearest thou not? How art thou not terrified by the wrath of Jezebel, who seeks thy life? Divine zeal is the daughter of perfect love: “Perfect love casteth out fear” (1 John 4:18). Therefore Elias the zealot is not fainthearted and fears nothing, but boldly goes to Ahab, and standing before him, fearlessly says: Hear, O king! I declare to thee in the presence of the Lord God of Hosts, the living God of Israel, whom I serve, that for three years there shall be neither dew nor rain upon this land, until at last my mouth shall call upon the true God concerning this: “As the Lord God of Hosts liveth, the God of Israel, before whom I stand, there shall not be in these years dew nor rain, except according to the word of my mouth” (3 Kings 17:1, 5, 10). After this, the holy Prophet withdrew to the brook of Cherith, and from there, when the brook dried up, to Zarephath of Sidon, and there awaited both the end of the three years and the correction of the people under punishment.

When the three years were fulfilled, and Ahab with his people—though punished by the drought—had not turned to God, but remained in impiety and continued to worship Baal, then Elias returned to Samaria and proposed to Ahab to gather all the shameful prophets whom Jezebel fed. And when they had assembled and come before Elias, he reproved them and said to the people: Give us two oxen, and let your prophets choose one of them and prepare their sacrifice, only let them not set fire to it; afterward, I too shall do the same with the other ox. Call then, he said to the false prophets, upon your gods, and I shall call upon the name of the Lord my God—and the God who shall hear and send fire from heaven upon the sacrifice, He shall be the true God. This proposal pleased everyone: “And all the people answered and said: the word is good which he hath spoken” (3 Kings 18:24). So, the shameful priests prepared their sacrifice and began to call upon Baal. They called upon him from morning till noon, cut themselves with knives, and beat themselves with scourges until blood flowed—but there was no voice, no answer, nor any that heard (3 Kings 18:26). Then Elias said to them: Give me space, that I also may offer my whole-burnt offering. And having prepared the altar, he laid the ox upon the wood; but so that there might be no room for doubt, and that the spectators might be all the more convinced of the truth of the miracle, he commanded those standing by to pour water upon the sacrifice and the wood three times. And as soon as the water overflowed around the entire altar, then he began to cry out and pray to God with great reverence, that He would send fire from heaven upon the sacrifice, so that the people, realizing that He is the true God, might turn to Him (3 Kings 18:36). And as soon as he finished his prayer—O most glorious wonder!—immediately “fire fell from the Lord out of heaven, and consumed the whole-burnt offering, and the wood, and the water that was in the trench, and the stones, and the dust the fire licked up” (3 Kings 18:38). Then all the people, seeing this great miracle, fell face down upon the ground and cried out with a loud voice: “Truly the Lord, He is God! He is God!” (3 Kings 18:39). Then all turned from impiety to piety, and soon thereafter the great rain fell and watered the earth throughout that land. Thus did Divine zeal overcome and destroy the works of demonic zeal.

Many are truly and most wondrous the deeds of zeal; but since there are various types of it, great discernment is required to know which zeal is pleasing to God and which is opposed to Him. Besides divine zeal, which proceeds from love for God, and demonic zeal, which is enkindled by destructive passions, there is yet another kind of zeal—so-called not according to knowledge. This kind of zeal, like the demonic one, is the cause of many and great iniquities. Such was the zeal of the Jews, as Paul testifies: “For I bear them record that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge” (Romans 10:2). They were unable to understand that the Law of Moses bears witness to Jesus Christ and is a noble tutor leading all to faith in Christ. Therefore, they did not believe in Him, but persecuted Him, and in the end crucified Him; they even mocked His resurrection from the dead. “For had they known it,” says the same Apostle, “they would not have crucified the Lord of glory” (1 Corinthians 2:8). Nevertheless, if senseless zeal arises not from some passion but from mere ignorance, it is worthy of some excuse. This was confirmed by the very Savior of the world, when He justified His crucifiers before His Father and prayed for them: “Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do” (Luke 23:34).

This senseless zeal once possessed the heart of the Apostle Paul. Believing it to be a virtue to defend the traditions of his fathers, he excessively persecuted the Church of Christ and in every way afflicted it. Here is his own confession: “Ye have heard,” he says, “of my manner of life in times past in Judaism, how that beyond measure I persecuted the Church of God and wasted it; and profited in the Jews’ religion above many of my equals in mine own nation, being more exceedingly zealous of the traditions of my fathers” (Galatians 1:13–14). Senseless zeal inflames his heart and darkens his mind: he does all manner of harm to the Church. He takes part in the stoning of the Protomartyr Stephen; breathing threats like a savage lion against the faithful, he bursts into their houses, cruelly drags men and women into custody, and casts them into prison. The flame of this senseless zeal fills him with a spirit of menace and murder, and he seeks permission from the Jewish High Priest to go to Damascus, that he might bind and bring to Jerusalem all whom he should find there who worship Jesus Christ: “And Saul, yet breathing out threatenings and slaughter against the disciples of the Lord, went unto the High Priest, and desired of him letters to Damascus to the synagogues, that if he found any of this way, whether they were men or women, he might bring them bound unto Jerusalem” (Acts 9:1–2). Nevertheless, this blasphemer and persecutor of the Church was shown mercy: “But I obtained mercy,” he says, “because I did it ignorantly in unbelief” (1 Timothy 1:13).

This senseless zeal often takes dominion over the hearts of many. One man is zealous, yet at the same time ignorant of the dogmas of the faith and the laws of God. And since he has zeal but lacks discernment, he boldly teaches others concerning matters of faith and morals, but instead of doing good, he causes harm: for instead of right dogmas, he preaches strange doctrines, and instead of the laws of God, he sows empty superstitions. Another man has zeal, but not according to knowledge, for he undertakes the work of correction without any discernment—that is, either with excessive severity, or without consideration of circumstances, or without the requisite skill. Therefore, instead of correction, he often stirs up hatred among relatives and friends, scandal between parents and their children, and discord between spouses. Every Christian, according to the apostolic commandment, ought to remain within the bounds of his station and calling: “Let every man abide in the same calling wherein he was called” (1 Corinthians 7:20). But senseless zeal, having taken hold of a man, draws him out of the bounds of his station and calling. Thus, the subordinate rises up against his superior, the people do not listen to the priest, the son does not honor the father, the servant disobeys the master, and the subject sets himself against his ruler. And from such disobedience, who can number how many disorders, rebellions, and crimes arise? Senseless zeal has often been the cause of wars and murders, the cause of the upheaval of cities, and of countless other misfortunes.

The zeal that was once in the Apostle Paul was, in truth, without understanding, yet it was a simple zeal, free from all passion. Therefore, God—Knower of hearts—dispersed the darkness of his soul and illumined his mind with His divine light, and transformed his unreasoning zeal into a discerning, wise, and Divine zeal. Being inspired by this zeal, he accomplished glorious deeds of virtue surpassing human strength. But our zeal is not only without understanding—it is also rooted entirely in the passions. Its source, from which it flows, is either pride, or envy, or vainglory. It only appears to be zeal, but in reality, it is some shameful and destructive passion. We are zealous—but often for the sake of being glorified before men. Dispassionate zeal, even if not according to knowledge, is worthy of excuse; but passionate zeal is inexcusable.

But how can one know which zeal is Divine and which is demonic, which is discerning and which is without discernment? This is not easy to determine—for the passions darken our mind, self-love deceives us, and Satan, transforming himself into an angel of light, presents vice to our mind in the guise of virtue, and virtue in the guise of vice (2 Corinthians 11:14). For this reason, the God-inspired Paul commands us to examine every matter with attention, and when we perceive that what we undertake is truly good, only then should we choose and do it: “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21). The general rule for such testing—that is, for discerning matters—has been given to us by the very Lord of all: “For the tree,” He said, “is known by its fruit” (Matthew 12:33). Examine, therefore, your zeal by investigating its fruits: and if you see that its fruits are love, righteousness, obedience, good order, the fulfillment of Divine laws, and the correction of the soul, then your zeal is Divine zeal, zeal according to knowledge. But if, on the contrary, you see that its fruits are discord, injustice, disobedience, disorder, the transgression of Divine laws, and the ruin of the soul, then your zeal is demonic, undiscerning, and passionate.

Beloved brethren! Zeal according to God is the fruit of perfect love for God; no one possesses it except he who loves God with all his soul, with all his heart, with all his strength, and with all his mind. Therefore, it is a great virtue and the cause of many other great virtues. All the apostolic labors, all the sufferings of the martyrs, all the virtues of the holy teachers, all the toils of the venerable fathers—these are the fruits brought forth by Divine zeal. Blessed is he, then, who has acquired the great treasure of this zeal. But demonic zeal, as well as zeal without discernment, is the source of many and great iniquities. From it have proceeded such persecutions against Christianity, such torments from tyrants, murders by heretics, assaults, treacheries, and scandals. Wretched and miserable is the man who is possessed by zeal that is either demonic or not according to knowledge. Take heed, therefore, brethren, and with all diligence test your zeal, lest you do sin in place of virtue, and bring upon your soul eternal torment instead of salvation: “Prove all things; hold fast that which is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21).

 

Russian source: Толкование Воскресных Апостолов с нравоучительными беседами, by His Grace Nikephoros, former Archbishop of Astrakhan and Stavropol, Moscow: Synodal Printing House, 1854, Vol. 1.

Online:

https://azbyka.ru/otechnik/Nikifor_Feotokis/tolkovanie-voskresnykh-apostolov-s-nravouchitelnymi-besedami/2

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

On St. Ieronymos of Aegina’s Return to the Patristic Calendar

Source: Botsis, Peter, The Elder Ieronymos of Aegina , Brookline, MA: The Holy Transfiguration Monastery, 2007, pp. 159-163.     The...